• Civilization 7 has been announced. For more info please check the forum here .

World Size and Land Mass

Cyc

Looking for the door...
Joined
Mar 18, 2002
Messages
14,736
Location
Behind you
In previous discussions, it was more or less determined that this first Revival Game should not be made too large or to run for too long, but just to get back into the swing of things.

A Pangaea on a Standard size Map was the initial solution. This would keep the game fun and operational in DG terms, but not get too top heavy towards the end.

What are your thoughts?
 
I lean towards Pangaea, but Continents are okay
 
It's basically 5 to 5. Pangaea to Continents. :undecide::yup::nope::dunno:

I have never really been one to build a navy (well, there was the WWII scenario). Other than a galley or A caravel to explore, plant a city. So I'm not seeing the advantage of a smaller land mass. Why would having smaller, thinner pieces of land be better to develop a nation on? Clue me in. Why are Continents better than Pangaea?
 
Continents add mystery to the game. You don't have quick contact with everyone, and don't know what's going on with the other continent's tech speed and development. Sometimes the first you hear of a wonder is when the other continent completes it. There's more of a variety of things to build -- who builds ships on pangaea? With no ships you don't have stories about ships and sailors, no intrepid voyagers risking their lives crossing ocean in a galley, no need to research <whatever tech it is> to enable ocean trading.

Continents gives the whole game experience. :yup:

Small land mass can be avoided by using 60% water. ;)
 
Pangaea made the Great Domino War of DG1 possible :yup:
 
Same here. I also like Fantasy World, although I've never figured out what's the difference.

Sorry, this is CIVIII.
I think that Archipelago is even more mysterious than Continents. If we want mystery and a challenging game, I'd say that we should go with Archipelago.
 
we could try archipelago, adds a challenge with building an empire..across various islands.
if continents vs. pangaea, i would go with continents with the same reasons above =D
 
Ok, it looks like we are shifting towards Continents. I'm going to put up a Land Mass poll. It appears we only have one suggestion of going larger than a Standard Map. So for now, we'll leave that as our decision. If I am wrong, please let me know.
 
Pangea = Borders and Borders = War :D
 
El Justo, please be sure and go to the Poll sub-forum and vote on these issues. We need your votes. :thumbsup:
 
Top Bottom