I think the loot should go to those who have faced danger.
So far: Rheinmetall, Stuck In Pi, Izipo, Lutjz, Catharsis, Backwards Logic, Pinman, and Myself have faced danger. The loot should only be given to the listed UNLESS another can tell us what an item does and why it would benefit them/somebody else.
But, that's my opinion. I agree that the Shaman would be helpful in a 'tree room.'
I've also been among wilderness often, scouting for the tribe. Perhaps I would be helpful?