Fellowship of the Ring - A Mini Mafia

Alright, I'm gonna start sending result PM's.
I have one more to wait for, but we'll start when I get it.
 
Am I completely stoopid, or has our fine host given away the secret role in the op? Seemed a logical guess, but there were other options.
 
Am I completely stoopid, or has our fine host given away the secret role in the op? Seemed a logical guess, but there were other options.

It wasn't really secret. Since you were observant enough... :p
 
Yeah, he did. At least I think I could see the creature I think I saw...
 
Day 2 Begins!
The Fellowship awoke to a new day. Well, most of the Fellowship...

Visorslash was killed!
topsecret said:
You're Legolas
attachment.php

Race: Elf - An Elf is always watching. (25% chance to see a corrupted player if they attempt to kill someone)
Ability: Friendly - Kindness has it's advantages (You can see another player's race and the ability each night.)
Item: None
Alignment: Good

Victory: You'll win if all the corrupted players are killed!

Gimli said, "Not even an Elf can see his own death."
Gandalf turned to The Company, now numbering seven and said, "We must move on."
The Fellowship marched on, unaware of the creature continuing to follow them...
"My Precious! My Precious!"

It seems that during the middle of the night, someone took Boromir's horn!
There is a extra vote against Daveshack this day.
You may now vote for the evil one among you :evil:

1 - Jarrema
2 - Autolycus
3 - Mat93
4 - Dreadnought
5 - JoanK
6 - Buddhafish - Boromir, Unknown
7 - Johnhughthom
8 - Visorslash - Legolas, Good
9 - Daveshack
10 - Verarde
 
Hmmm. I know for sure that someone tried to steal my item last night, and I know who he is. I will give him a chance to explain to me why did he do it. 24 hours. After that, I will reveal who it was, and I'll push for his lynch.
 
Hmmm. I know for sure that someone tried to steal my item last night, and I know who he is. I will give him a chance to explain to me why did he do it. 24 hours. After that, I will reveal who it was, and I'll push for his lynch.

Interesting.

So, we have nine members of the Fellowship, plus an additional tenth player, who I'd think to be Gollum. With that in mind, the only people who would fit in the role as an item thief would be one of the hobbits, or Gollum himself. Out of the four hobbits, Merry seems like the one that would be the thief, though Pippin might -- for a stretch -- be capable of stealing too.

I'd place my money of Gollum though (maybe trying to "steal" the Ring?).
 
After seeing the part about Boromir's horn, I'd be willing to guess that perhaps one of the hobbits took the horn -- I'm not condemning or condoning that bit, however.

I'm speaking strictly from a Middle-Earth perspective.
 
There is a extra vote for Daveshack this day.
Umm, does this mean I get to place an extra vote, or that a mysterious extra vote against me has appeared?
 
I'm going to start with a vote:mat93, mostly on gut instinct and to try to get some discussion going while we wait for the thief to either be revealed or not.
 
Umm, does this mean I get to place an extra vote, or that a mysterious extra vote against me has appeared?

A mysterious extra vote :p
 
vote: JoanK
 
:agree: I am specially interested on Jarrema's vote... why would you try to kill someone like me?
 
Back
Top Bottom