If only we could to this here...

Serutan

Eatibus Anythingibus
Joined
Feb 20, 2002
Messages
5,582
Location
Baja Arizona
At last, someone is doing constructive about cell phones in public places...
 
Serutan said:
At last, someone is doing constructive about cell phones in public places...

Great idea, but I wonder how they ensure that emergency calls get through the jamming?
 
They won't, I'm fairly sure. Outgoing emergency calls would be from landlines, and incoming ones will have to manage the same way they did before mobile phones.
I guess if you are expecting there might be an emergency you wouldn't be there, and if you weren't - hard luck.
Still, I'm all for it.
 
Frankly, I'm not sold on the idea that preventing emergency calls from getting through is a valid reason to stop cell phone jamming. Just post a notice saying that cell phones will be jammed on the premises. If someone really has a job that they can't be away from for two hours...well, no movie for you, then.

Civilization survived and thrived without 24 hour access to every emergency worker in the area. I suspect it could survive again.
 
I saw on TV the concept of "phone-sitters". You give you phone at the cloakroom and, if there's a call, they take the message. If it's really an emergency, they can tell you without disturbing other peoples with phones rings. I think it was in a discotheque, but I'm not sure. That would be nice for places such as theaters or restaurants.
 
Hurry up and buy 'em before they are banned. If you can, buy several to sell at a later date. I imagine them going the way of police radar detectors.
 
Would there be any way to attach this technology to satellites, in order to enforce a total mobile-phone blackout worldwide?
 
Personally, I've never had the problem of someone using their cell phone during a movie so I'm not so sure this is necessary. Maybe the French are just rude and inconsiderate :confused:
 
If people don't switch off their cell phones in cinemas when asked, let them face the consequences. There's a reason you're asked to. If you're so attached to your cell phone that you have to have it turned on 24 hours a day, you seriously need to get a life.
 
Switching off a cell phones takes 0.2167 seconds....

It's very easy to ask the audiance to switch it off.

Weird.
 
I think it's a great decision. However, what worries me is the way the jamming signal works ; is it a strong magnetic field ? Or something else ? I would hate to see studies pop up in three years, saying "Mobile jamming in theaters causes testicle cancer", or that kind of thing...
 
Stapel said:
Switching off a cell phones takes 0.2167 seconds....

It's very easy to ask the audiance to switch it off.

Weird.

Actually, they do, in French movie theaters. But guess what ? Some people forget, other don't bother. I go to the movies at least once a week, and mobiles ringing are not that uncommon.
 
Masquerouge said:
I think it's a great decision. However, what worries me is the way the jamming signal works ; is it a strong magnetic field ? Or something else ? I would hate to see studies pop up in three years, saying "Mobile jamming in theaters causes testicle cancer", or that kind of thing...
This and emergency calls arer my concern as well.
 
IglooDude said:
Great idea, but I wonder how they ensure that emergency calls get through the jamming?

This law is a good idea indeed, but yesterday I heard on TV News that it is almost impossible to be done. The law forbid jamming emergency calls, but equipment that can make the difference between normal and emergency calls must be military-style, which cost 30.000 (!) euros piece.
The solution would be to jam all stupid brains when entering the movie theatre, but then there won't be a lot of people (including me) ...
 
Hygro said:
This and emergency calls arer my concern as well.
Conventional phones are still available. BBC also reported that somewhere in the UK, there's a ban on mobile phones; part of an experiment. I don't have a URL as I read it some days ago.
 
I'm not sure emergency calls are an issue, here. How did people do before mobiles ? They had to rush to the nearest phone booth, or whatever. Well, same now.
And if you're EXPECTING emergency calls (doctors, or anyone), well, don't go to the movies, please.
 
Masquerouge said:
Actually, they do, in French movie theaters. But guess what ? Some people forget, other don't bother. I go to the movies at least once a week, and mobiles ringing are not that uncommon.

Isn't it easier to ban those visitors?
 
Back
Top Bottom