Initiative - Should donsig recuse himself from JR12

ravensfire · Apr 17, 2006

Citizens,

Public Defender donsig has a potential conflict of interest with JR12, related to various discussions and polls previous posted.

Discussion thread
Previous Poll
Relevant Initiative
Term 2 Judicial thread

Should he recuse himself from this JR?

Options:

Yes, he should recuse himself
No, he should rule on the Judicial Review
Abstain, I have no preference

This is a private poll, and will run for 4 days.

Should there be more Yes votes than No votes, donsig will recuse himself from the JR. Any other result will result in him ruling on the matter.

-- Ravensfire

DaveShack · Apr 17, 2006

I think the run time of this poll is too long.

I also think Donsig could have chosen to go with a pro-tem voluntarily more than a week ago and the docket would probably have been cleared by now.

DaveShack · Apr 19, 2006

Well, that's just peachy... tied 4-4-2 so far, with a couple of days remaining.

What are we supposed to infer from this if it's tied at the end? No decision, I guess, leaving it still up to Donsig to decide his own course of action. :rolleyes:

donsig · Apr 19, 2006

The other poll was 1-13-4. Did changing the question change to vote that much?

ravensfire · Apr 19, 2006

"Don't know and have no opinion"

-- Ravensfire

Donovan Zoi · Apr 19, 2006

donsig said:
The other poll was 1-13-4. Did changing the question change to vote that much?

If it helps, I abstained in the last poll.

FYI - Seeing the names of the voters in both polls may have helped to satisfy your curiosity about the voting trend.....

robboo · Apr 19, 2006

I voted abstain..Donsig if you think there is a problem then step down..if not stay. I trust our judges to do the right thing. If not next term, they wont get my vote. I voted abstain because I cant get into your head to see if you are influenced....

donsig · Apr 20, 2006

Donovan Zoi said:
FYI - Seeing the names of the voters in both polls may have helped to satisfy your curiosity about the voting trend.....

Yeah, I know. But then I'd be curious as to what effect the publicness of the poll had on the vote. One of these days I'm gonna run side by side public and private polls on the exact same question to see if there's any difference.

Cyc · Apr 20, 2006

I've already voiced my opinion on this matter. If donsig doesn't rule on the issue, Sister Mary Elephant should take a ruler to his arse...

ravensfire · Apr 24, 2006

This poll is closed, and is Validated.

Public Defender donsig should not recuse himself from JR12.

-- Ravensfire, Censor

Initiative - Should donsig recuse himself from JR12

Should Public Defender donsig Recuse himself from JR12?

Yes, he should Recuse himself

No, he should rule on the JR

Abstain

ravensfire

Member of the Opposition

DaveShack

Inventor

DaveShack

Inventor

donsig

Low level intermediary

ravensfire

Member of the Opposition

Donovan Zoi

The Return

robboo

Deity

donsig

Low level intermediary

Cyc

Looking for the door...

ravensfire

Member of the Opposition

Similar threads