Do we want to build The Great Library??? And where???

Rihiter · May 10, 2006

It has to be done so I will do it.

The question is "Do we want to build TGL after the Literature is finished? And if yes, where should we build it? BW or maybe some other city???"

-The Great Library gives two free scientist specialists to the city until the invention of Scientific Method
-It gives 8 culture
-It generates 2 Great Scientist points ( big chance for academy )

Possible polle opinions:
1) Yes, we should build it. I don't care where.
2) Yes we should, and the best location is Boaring Wallow.
3) Yes we should, but not in Boaring Wallow.
4) No we shouldn't, we do not have chanse to get it or we do not need it!
5) I have no opinion in this matter.

You can only vote fore single choise.
Anwsers 1, 2 & 3 are going to be counted as "YES".
EDIT:This poll will be open for 3 days.
EDIT2: I have just noticed a little mistake in one of the poll anwsers... There is ofcourse "Yes we should, in Boaring Wallow".

Rihiter · May 10, 2006

Ofcourse I vote "YES, in BW".

We have the highest RP production there already, and there are many forests which can be chooped to build it.

GeorgeOP · May 10, 2006

4. The Minister of the Interior may decide where to build any Citizens Assembly approved Wonder.

You should have just left it as "yes" or "no". Having multiple "yes" votes will lead to "no" winning.

But this makes me wonder where our MoI is located.

robboo · May 10, 2006

TIME OUT....dont we have this poll already...

Who is the MoI? Has it been 7 days? George contact the judges to start an investigation.

dutchfire · May 10, 2006

GeorgeOP said:
You should have just left it as "yes" or "no". Having multiple "yes" votes will lead to "no" winning.

But this makes me wonder where our MoI is located.

it won't if you add the Yes together (or at least yes but don't care where and yes in BW)

Rihiter · May 10, 2006

GeorgeOP said:
You should have just left it as "yes" or "no". Having multiple "yes" votes will lead to "no" winning.

Like I have written in the poll text: /Anwsers 1, 2 & 3 are going to be counted as "YES"./

robboo · May 10, 2006

This poll wont be binding..you can not add the yes's and its not public.

The not public thign I am not sure about but this really is already being polled. Just because the last poll is not going the way you like is no reason to start another one.

Also let the MoI take the lead on this, this is like someone requiring a poll on troop movement approval...you wouldnt like it either( I know I didnt). We have people in officies to oversee there areas...let them do it.

Rihiter · May 10, 2006

robboo said:
The not public thign I am not sure about but this really is already being polled. Just because the last poll is not going the way you like is no reason to start another one.

This is a text from that pole about which You are talkin about Robboo...

DaveShack said:
It looks like another poll is needed, between yes - build it and no - don't build it.

About the MoI... Have You seen him lately?

SkippyT · May 10, 2006

ok ... about boaring wallow, what is that

greekguy · May 10, 2006

SkippyT said:
ok ... about boaring wallow, what is that

Boaring Wallow is the capital city of our country, Licentia.

btw, there are several things wrong with this poll. no abstain option available...poll is not public...poll about this already up.

Vind2 · May 10, 2006

Didn't more people say no to building it in the last poll?

Rihiter · May 11, 2006

greekguy said:
btw, there are several things wrong with this poll. no abstain option available...poll is not public...poll about this already up.

I have no opinion in this matter = abstain

I have allready written why this poll is up though another poll is up with similar problem. Scrolle up a little.

About public... what do I have to do to make poll public?

greekguy · May 11, 2006

Rihiter said:
About public... what do I have to do to make poll public?

when making a poll scroll down before posting. there will be a bunch of options, each with a box next to them. simply check off the "public poll" option and when you post the poll, the results will be public.

GenMarshall · May 11, 2006

We should build it in a city with a high production output.

donsig · May 11, 2006

Rihiter said:
About public... what do I have to do to make poll public?

That is a good question. You can always ask for a judicial review about this.

robboo · May 11, 2006

where is our censor? mr.CJ..that is abetter question

donsig · May 12, 2006

robboo said:
where is our censor? mr.CJ..that is abetter question

I don't think it's a better question. If the Censor was to validate or invalidate this poll, a judicial review could still be requested that could possibly overturn whatever the Censor did.

Also, IIRC, the Censor's procedures specifically state that if a poll isn't reviewed within 48 hours it is to be considered as validated. Not a good procedure in my view but a valid one until superceded by something else. As I said earlier, you can always request a judicial review of this poll.

DaveShack · May 13, 2006

The Constitution is written so the last poll to close takes precedence, if the polls start out at equal levels.

This poll does not state it is a referendum or an initiative, nor does it meet the polling standards required to make it binding because the options are not clear, in the sense that it is not clear how the votes should be interpreted. Also there is no link to the discussion. I think that makes this poll informational.

II. Polling Standards

IIA. The description and initial post for all official polls should be stated in a clear and neutral manner.
IIB. The initial post should contain a link to all relevant discussion threads. Each option should be explained if not immediately clear. The time frame for the poll, and how the results will be interpreted should also be in the initial post.
IIC. All official polls must be open for a minimum of 2 days to be binding, however it is recommended that binding polls be open from 3 to 4 days if possible.
IID. Official polls should be marked Public unless directly concerning another Citizen.

Rihiter · May 13, 2006

DaveShack said:
I think that makes this poll informational.

Did I ever said that this poll is something more then informational? So is this discusion realy needed? This poll is informational, and always was. So tell your opinion, and nothing more is needed. OK? Are we clear? Good.

dutchfire · May 13, 2006

there is nothing wrong with an informational poll so the official knows what the public wants

but according to the Code of Laws certain things must be decided by the citizen by means of a formal poll, we should follow that rule

Do we want to build The Great Library??? And where???

Do we want to build TGL after the Literature is finished, and where???

Yes, we should build it. I don't care where.

Yes we should, is Boaring Wallow.

Yes we should, but not in Boaring Wallow.

No we shouldn't, we do not have chanse to get it or we do not need it!

I have no opinion in this matter.

Lord of War

Lord of War

RF Bleachers

Deity

Deity

Lord of War

Deity

Lord of War

Who?

Missed the Boat

Woof?

Lord of War

Missed the Boat

High Elven ISB Capt & Ghost Agent

Low level intermediary

Deity

Low level intermediary

Inventor

Lord of War

Deity

Similar threads