Critique my college essay

Syterion

Voodoo Economist
Joined
Nov 24, 2003
Messages
4,287
Location
San Diego, CA
I'm applying to college, and I think the essay could make it or break it, since I'm probably similar to a ton of applicants. Any advice is welcome. BTW, the essay is about 35 words too long, so anything you think I could get rid of or streamline would also be useful. And lastly, don't fill this thread with sympathy posts.

Here it is:

It was a wintry afternoon in second grade. I was doing multiplication tables at my desk when my mother and my sister entered the room. Startled, the teacher walked over and my mother whispered in her ear. My mother pulled me out of my chair and we left the room. Confusion clouded my thoughts until I saw the books in my mother’s hands. I asked, “Who’s dead? Is it Daddy? Is Daddy dead?”

I was right.

My father died in his sleep when I was seven years old. He was an alcoholic and his liver just could not take further abuse. Following my father being subpoenaed with another charge of Driving Under the Influence, my mother received full custody of my sister and me right after I was born. Since then, my mother has taken care of both my sister and me all the while maintaining a job.

Following my father’s death, my thoughts were paralyzed. I could not form a cohesive opinion of the event. I did not hate him for abandoning his family for his addiction, but I did not have any love for him. I never really knew my father. My only interaction with him was in brief conversations over the phone and during awkward weekend visits. People have told me I look like him, and that I inherited his intelligence and penchant for mischief, but also his vices of laziness, procrastination, and lack of willpower. Unable to cope with the tragedy, I expunged thoughts of my father from my mind completely.

But I had to deal with the matter at some point in my life. The issue was forced upon me suddenly in middle school, when in an argument with my mother over my declining grades my mother said, “You’re just like your father.” I was stunned. Was my laziness a result of my genes, was I doomed by my heritage to live out my father’s life? I was genuinely fearful that my fate in life was immutable; that my potential would be for naught, just as it was with my father.

That day I decided I would never make the mistakes my father did. I witnessed firsthand the effects of losing a parent. I saw the strain it put on my mother, causing terrible migraines weekly. I saw how it robbed my sister of her childhood, as the onus of controlling me was immediately thrust on her. I saw how an addiction forced even a person with great potential to succumb until he had lost his job, his family, and his life. From then on I was adamant that I would succeed where he had failed, that I would fight on where he had given up, and that I would reach my potential where he had faltered.

While I can never forgive my father for losing the battle to alcoholism, I can make peace with it. Though I can never give my mother back the years she sacrificed for her children or give my sister back her childhood, I can promise them that I will always be there for them. My father’s death traumatized me for years, but in the end has given me strength for life.


Thanks in advance. I'm sure a group of people who don't know me will be most discerning.
 
Hmm...I like it Systerion. There's some grammatical mistakes but I'm sure this is just a rough draft.

I wouldn't emphasize the negatives but I how it's made you strong. It can be very powerful when someone reads how much character has been built through this difficult process. Overcoming internal struggles we all deal with. That's my initial thoughts.
 
It's quite good. I agree with Whomp also; make sure you accentuate the ways that overcoming this tragedy made you stronger. I'm not saying you haven't done this effectively--I'm not a particularly good judge in this regard--just that this should be a main concern.

Hmm...If you're looking to pare it down, perhaps you should consider dropping the last paragraph entirely. I think the penultimate paragraph ends with your strongest statement, and the part of the last paragraph that is useful could just be appended to it.
 
Yes, I agree with the above, I could probably eliminate much of the third paragraph and put whatever is necessary from it into the fourth, and then expound more in the last one how exactly it made me stronger as a person. Showing growth is important. And I've already set precedents for bringing up better grades, better willpower and so forth. As for grammatical mistakes, I'm not sure I see what you, Whomp, are referring to. Could you explain?
 
I don't see anything that I'd qualify as "grammar mistakes," but if you'll suffer pickiness (I'm naturally picky, it's a flaw of mine), I think you could improve a few places.

"Following my father being subpoenaed with another charge of Driving Under the Influence"

--I find this phrase somewhat unwieldy.

"Was my laziness a result of my genes, was I doomed by my heritage to live out my father’s life?"

--I would suggest giving each question a question mark here.

"I was genuinely fearful that my fate in life was immutable; that my potential would be for naught, just as it was with my father."

--I think should use a comma instead of a semicolon here.
 
To be honest it's so emotionally loaded I couldn't read it at one go.

I could be wrong, but to me it makes you sound like you have might have issues. Not saying it does or you do, just maybe talk more about motivation, success, being at college for a purpose etc.

It's got a lotta down in it, maybe it needs a bit more up in some form. I don't know, but consider it. You got to consider your target audience - how do you want this college to look at you?

There's being honest, and then there's being stupidly honest.
 
It's very good. Nearly the exact same thing happened to me, except it was my mom that died of alcoholism rather than my dad. I wrote about it in my college essay and heard first hand from an admissions officer that it was a definite plus factor. Colleges get so many essays of the type "[x volunteer experience] really opened my eyes to diversity and helping others blah blah blah", that real hard-core personal hardship is something of a good change of pace.

I made my essay out eerily similar to yours, explaining how my mom died of alcoholism and what it did to me, and how my grades slipped badly and finally one day someone said something to me that woke me up (in my case it was an English teacher telling me a certain Emerson quote), which made me achieve more and want to excel academically. The format definitely goes over well and yours is very nicely written.
 
"A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds"
 
and what did they mean to you? how did it change your attitude/behavior?

edit : I really like the passage, I feel the same way. :)

Spoiler :
Emerson said:
The other terror that scares us from self-trust is our consistency; a reverence for our past act or word because the eyes of others have no other data for computing our orbit than our past acts, and we are loth to disappoint them.

But why should you keep your head over your shoulder? Why drag about this corpse of your memory, lest you contradict somewhat you have stated in this or that public place? Suppose you contradict yourself; what then? It seems to be a rule of wisdom never to rely on your memory alone, scarcely even in acts of pure memory, but to bring the past for judgment into the thousand-eyed present, and live ever in a new day. In your metaphysics you have denied personality to the Deity, yet when the devout motions of the soul come, yield to them heart and life, though they should clothe God with shape and color. Leave your theory, as Joseph his coat in the hand of the harlot, and flee.

A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little
statesmen and philosophers and divines. With consistency, a great soul has simply nothing to do. He may as well concern himself with the shadow on the wall. Speak what you think now in hard words and to-morrow speak what to-morrow thinks in hard words again, though it contradict every thing you said to-day. --'Ah, so you shall be sure to be misunderstood.' -- Is it so bad then to be misunderstood? Pythagoras was misunderstood, and Socrates, and Jesus, and Luther, and Copernicus, and Galileo, and Newton, and every pure and wise spirit that ever took flesh. To be great is to be misunderstood.

I suppose no man can violate his nature. All the sallies of his will are rounded in the law of his being, as the inequalities of Andes and Himmaleh are insignificant in the curve of the sphere. Nor does it matter how you gauge and try him. A character is like an acrostic or Alexandrian stanza; read it forward, backward, or across, it still spells the same thing. In this pleasing contrite wood-life which God allows me, let me record day by day my honest thought without prospect or retrospect, and, I cannot doubt, it will be found symmetrical, though I mean it not and see it not. . . . Character teaches above our wills. . . .

I hope in these days we have heard the last of conformity and
consistency.

Syterion, I think the essay is good. I wrote one about my unusal adolescent experience and the lessons gleaned from it for two out of the three colleges I applied to (the third I sent an earlier written and kind of dull essay just for the hell of it, I wasn't really interested in getting into there) and got into those two of three. Good luck. :thumbsup:
 
To be honest it's so emotionally loaded I couldn't read it at one go.

I could be wrong, but to me it makes you sound like you have might have issues. Not saying it does or you do, just maybe talk more about motivation, success, being at college for a purpose etc.

It's got a lotta down in it, maybe it needs a bit more up in some form. I don't know, but consider it. You got to consider your target audience - how do you want this college to look at you?

There's being honest, and then there's being stupidly honest.

I can see what you're saying, my teacher was talking before about being too negative. Do you think talking about the strengths gained from it would help it be more positive?

As for being emotionally loaded, the point of the essay is to show them who you are, and If I write about my father's death and it isn't emotional, it'll probably come off cold and unfeeling.
 
I really think this is a great admissions essay. It's much better than I can write now and a world ahead of what I could have written coming out of highschool. That being said, I won't critique it 'cause I certainly wouldn't have any thing constuctive to add. BTW what books were in your mother's hands? Good luck in college.
 
Systerion I will ask my financee' to take a look. She's an educator and is much smarter than I. She went to Berkeley and Columbia so she'll be able to give you some insight.
 
I'm not big on grammer, but you might want to change the bit where you and your sister were put in your mom's custody to "my sister and I" instead of, "my sister and me". One of the few grammar rules that has stuck in my head from my English classes is that you are supposed to use "I" instead of "me" when you use phrases like that.

As for the content, I think it sounds pretty good. However, I agree with Whomp and Shortguy about putting more emphasis on how it has made you stronger, and how you are avoiding the mistakes your father made. You're doing good though.:goodjob:
 
Actually what Evil Tyrant said changing me with I was what I was thinking too. I'm not a grammar expert though. Where's the Brits when you need them. :p
 
It's me when it's in a preposition. I'll check if I made that mistake when I shoud lhave used the nominative, but I don't think I did. As for the books, They were like, "Coping with death" and "How to continue your life after a death" and stuff.
 
My father died in his sleep when I was seven years old. He was an alcoholic and his liver just could not take further abuse. Following my father being subpoenaed with another charge of Driving Under the Influence, my mother received full custody of my sister and me right after I was born.

I don't see how the blue part relates to the red part. In the first part, his death is described, but then leaps back in time to actions around your birth and I can't see the link. I don't think you were going down the 'circle of life' road (I hope not anyway), so it might be better to put those sentences elsewhere.

It's a good short piece though, and good luck
 
Back
Top Bottom