Hammers from Religious Buildings w/Apostolic Palace in Random Cities

In my recent BtS 3.17 game I declared war on and captured all the cities of one of my rivals who had built the Apostolic Palace. It was still the middle ages and my state religion matched that of the Apostolic Palace's.

However, after the war was over (and my rival was eliminated), I noticed that only some of the temples/cathedrals/monasteries got the production bonus. In some cities that hadn't built them yet, it would say that building them would give the bonus - but in most others, it didn't. All of the cities had the state religion in them and by this time I was the leader of the Apostolic Palace.

Is this a bug or am I just unclear on the requirements for a city's religious buildings to get the production boost from the Apostolic Palace? In the past I thought they all got it as long as the state religion was there and you didn't defy any resolutions (which I hadn't).

Here are four screen shots showing the issue, all from the same turn of the game.

Christian Holy City (captured from Pacal), showing production bonus for current and unbuilt Christian buildings:


Small, non-special city captured from Pacal: all Christian Buildings (built and un-built) with production bonus


My capital - no production bonus now or if I build it.


Pacal's Captured Capital - again, no production bonus now or if I build them.




I will try to add a savegame to this post later today.

Ive had this multiple times as well, curious about it.

Same problem, in my game I had a city with a monastery and it didn't give me the +2 then I did a temple and both gave me +2.
I'm almost sure I've had games where temples didn't give me the +2, not 100% thou.

are you sure the monastery was not obsolete by the time you checked whether it gave ?

yeah, I didn't have Scientific Method.
Anyways, as I said before, after building the temple the monastery gave me the +2 along with the temple.

wasn't there an issue if you defied an AP resolution you lost your hammer bonus. I thought this was causing crazy situations where you could get +0h, +2h or even +4h sometimes.

+4 hammers?? never saw that, anyways, I checked as soon as I finished building it so only the leader vote had been taken at that moment.