Hi.
As said in another post i enjoy very much the new civics, since they complete many ancient empires... i was tired to see that ancient roman republic ruled by senate was considered "tribal" with "barbrism" justice...
Anyway i have a couple of suggestions...wich you can or not add in next release
i just say my ideas.
Now...straight to the point. GOVERNMENT
[1]Government civics are only about government. Right? So no economics, nor society inside government choices.
[2]When you chose a government system, there should be no "question marks" about it. Democracy is democracy. Monarchy is monarchy.
Fascism and Communism civics are not satisfyng those 2 points.
If u read in sevopedia about fascism and communism, and compare with federalsim or the others you see:
a- communism doesn't define a government type (can be republic, as China or autocrat such as Stalin's Soviet Rep.). This doesn't satisfy point [2] since there is no way to define the exact government type with the other categories
b-both communism and fascism deal with economics and society: Communism doesn't admit private propriety and corporations. Fascism is defined as nationalist society. They shouldn't be under "Government" choice. This doesn't satisfy point [1]: you can create
Government:Communist ---- Economy: free market (with bonuses on corps?)
Government:Fascist ---- Society: Liberal/marxist (wasn't nationalist? this is contraddictory)
Oh...and... more objectivity. If you say communism is based on social equality (so... defining that civic as ALWAYS equal) you can't cite Stalin.
So... what do I suggest?Only an example...
Government:
-cancel: fascist and communist
-add: Modern totalitarism (+ production like both F.ism and C.ism , - culture due to propaganda like F.ism, + espionage like C.ism, and so on)
-add: something else...
Economy:
-cancel: something
-add: State property (wich correctly eliminates corps... + production - money like C.ism and wathever)
The new system allows more precise simulation, according to points [1] and [2]
So... Fascism would be
Gov=modern totalitarism Soc:Nationalism Eco:Mercantilism
China would be a Republic and Stalin's Soviet Rep. a modern totalitarism. Both with Statal property. PERHAPS marxist society...(?)
This wasn't mean to be a political thread, just suggestions for a more accurate model of simulation. Without some contraddictions. Hope you appreciate.
As said in another post i enjoy very much the new civics, since they complete many ancient empires... i was tired to see that ancient roman republic ruled by senate was considered "tribal" with "barbrism" justice...
Anyway i have a couple of suggestions...wich you can or not add in next release
i just say my ideas.Now...straight to the point. GOVERNMENT
[1]Government civics are only about government. Right? So no economics, nor society inside government choices.
[2]When you chose a government system, there should be no "question marks" about it. Democracy is democracy. Monarchy is monarchy.
Fascism and Communism civics are not satisfyng those 2 points.
If u read in sevopedia about fascism and communism, and compare with federalsim or the others you see:
a- communism doesn't define a government type (can be republic, as China or autocrat such as Stalin's Soviet Rep.). This doesn't satisfy point [2] since there is no way to define the exact government type with the other categories
b-both communism and fascism deal with economics and society: Communism doesn't admit private propriety and corporations. Fascism is defined as nationalist society. They shouldn't be under "Government" choice. This doesn't satisfy point [1]: you can create
Government:Communist ---- Economy: free market (with bonuses on corps?)
Government:Fascist ---- Society: Liberal/marxist (wasn't nationalist? this is contraddictory)
Oh...and... more objectivity. If you say communism is based on social equality (so... defining that civic as ALWAYS equal) you can't cite Stalin.
So... what do I suggest?Only an example...
Government:
-cancel: fascist and communist
-add: Modern totalitarism (+ production like both F.ism and C.ism , - culture due to propaganda like F.ism, + espionage like C.ism, and so on)
-add: something else...
Economy:
-cancel: something
-add: State property (wich correctly eliminates corps... + production - money like C.ism and wathever)
The new system allows more precise simulation, according to points [1] and [2]
So... Fascism would be
Gov=modern totalitarism Soc:Nationalism Eco:Mercantilism
China would be a Republic and Stalin's Soviet Rep. a modern totalitarism. Both with Statal property. PERHAPS marxist society...(?)
This wasn't mean to be a political thread, just suggestions for a more accurate model of simulation. Without some contraddictions. Hope you appreciate.
