New Border Proposal - Plan C

Goonie · Jan 5, 2003

New Proposal!
This proposal caters to those who voted no on the former proposal. This takes their suggestions and puts it into the proposal.

Some people have said that borders have to follow terrain. This proposal does just that. Here is another picture that makes it simpler.

Chieftess · Jan 5, 2003

A little better...

Immortal · Jan 5, 2003

I can't even read it, but it has been explained to me in enough detail that I will support it.

Goonie · Jan 5, 2003

Basically, the yellow line is what I think the new border should be.

Cyc · Jan 5, 2003

I still vote no. I can see you getting the 4 Mountain Tiles from the SW Province, but that's it.

Strider · Jan 5, 2003

As I supported the last one. I will support this one.

GenMarshall · Jan 5, 2003

Ill support Goonie on this

.

Zarn · Jan 5, 2003

This time I'll stand by you.

Goonie · Jan 5, 2003

Originally posted by Cyc
I still vote no. I can see you getting the 4 Mountain Tiles from the SW Province, but that's it.

CYC. Taking the whole square(including Dapperdan) is following the natural lay of the land. This proposal is trying to right a wrong. Borders follow terrain. Something went wrong with this border and it has to be fixed! My second picture is what I am talking about!

Shaitan · Jan 5, 2003

Sorry, I still can't support this. The mountains from SW Prov I can agree with. Snaking Dapperdan and part of the Spine I disagree with.

Goonie · Jan 5, 2003

Look at my second image Shaitan. I am taking the whole square and nothing but the square.

amirsan · Jan 5, 2003

I totally support this proposal to my formal Province, Gem Mountain Province realy needs another city anyways.

Goonie · Jan 5, 2003

It is now the Province of Montis abeo Gramen!

amirsan · Jan 5, 2003

oops.. sorry

Fier Canadien · Jan 5, 2003

I also think that the last proposal (yellow) is the best.

Goonie · Jan 5, 2003

Yes. Yellow is the current proposal. Plan C!

Shaitan · Jan 6, 2003

It still doesn't work, Goonie. You are still taking the end of the Spine in your grab for Dapperdan. There is still absolutely no call for Dapperdan to be part of MAG province. There is no geographical reason to toss a hill tile to the end of 4 mountain tiles when the adjoining hill is in another province. There is also no way that you can realistically argue that a city that abuts one province at hills and coast would owe it's allegiance to another province that only abuts mountains to it.

Take the mountains from SouthWest - I agree that those should go over. Stop trying to steal Dapperdan.

Chieftess · Jan 6, 2003

You could also argue the mountain to the SE is still part of Gem Mountain (the group of mountains

). I just don't what the big deal over border redistribution is in this game...

Shaitan · Jan 6, 2003

You can't argue that if you look at the actual topography. Look at the save and press Ctrl-Shift-M to remove the structures. It's very obvious where the border should be.

Cheetah · Jan 6, 2003

I had a look at the map as Shaitan suggested.
And as I see it the yellow border is the border which fits the terrain best. I too support Plan C.

New Border Proposal - Plan C

Lonely End of the Rink

Moderator

Deity

Lonely End of the Rink

Looking for the door...

In Retrospect

High Elven ISB Capt & Ghost Agent

Le Républicain Catholique

Lonely End of the Rink

der Besucher

Lonely End of the Rink

King of all Kings

Lonely End of the Rink

King of all Kings

Citizen

Lonely End of the Rink

der Besucher

Moderator

der Besucher

Deity

Similar threads