Cities for the eastern expansion

Chieftess · May 27, 2003

Origanal discussion was here: Eastward Expansion

Which city plan should we take for expanding to the east? NOTE: This is NOT "Should we expand this way?". This is not a priority poll. This is simply city locations for the east. I will post a comprehensive poll/discussion next for the city priority

GenMarshall · May 27, 2003

Vote for Option 2. This one IMO would see less City overlapings.

Bootstoots · May 27, 2003

I also voted for option 2.

Plexus · May 27, 2003

I agree, two is the way to go.

Fier Canadien · May 27, 2003

I voted One as this option only has 7 overlap tiles as option 2 has 12.

Donovan Zoi · May 27, 2003

I like #2 as well, as it will allow us to culturally claim the hills. With this, we can better defend ourselves against the most powerful country in the game --- on our terms.

DaveShack · May 28, 2003

Ok, put me down for "other" and see this alternative for the dye city, and adjust accordingly.

I know, it's not likely to change, but gotta throw out an idea...

dye city alternative

Isaac_Newton · May 29, 2003

I'm going to vote for plan 2, as plan 1 will give us quite an overlap is we decide to capture any egyptian cities :evil:

, especially at El-Amarna.

Eklektikos · May 29, 2003

I've not had sufficient time to decide which of these options I wish to vote for as yet, but I must say that I'm not sure I understand the rationale behind the antipathy towards city radius overlap displayed in this thread. Particularly since both options appear to me to be erring in the direction of OCP style spacing where feasible, a build pattern I consider less than efficient in the earlier stages of the game when no city can hope to expand past the much vaunted "size 12". I would personally prefer more overlaping radii than either of these plans contain.

Almightyjosh · May 30, 2003

This poll has been rated UNFAIR by the PSC for failing to satify the mandatory requirements of a fair poll.

Assessment

Cities for the eastern expansion

Which cityplan do we take?

Expansion Plan 1

Expansion Plan 2

Other

Abstain

Chieftess

Moderator

GenMarshall

High Elven ISB Capt & Ghost Agent

Bootstoots

Deity

Plexus

Architeuthidae puericomedentis

Fier Canadien

Citizen

Donovan Zoi

The Return

DaveShack

Inventor

Isaac_Newton

Chieftain

Eklektikos

Eponymous

Almightyjosh

Governor in Waiting

Similar threads