Gotm21-Mediterranean Melee - Speculation Thread

cracker

Gil Favor's Sidekick
Joined
Mar 19, 2002
Messages
3,361
Location
Colorado, USA
This month's game is going to be a fairly unique experience in several ways and hopefully you will all have a lot of fun.

There is so much to speculate about, I hope it doesn't cause frenzy overload.

Two things to reveal to you in advance so that you can use these great pearls of wisdom to help guide your wild guesses to teh target. First, the playable civilization will be Greece for this month's game. Second, there will be a number of added resources in the game that should help to set a distinctive flavor to the game while still keeping the strategic play concepts fairly standard. See if you can guess what they are?

The question is, "What's your best guess as to what Gotm21 will be like and what some of the key features will be that will be included in the game?"
 
Originally posted by cracker
Second, there will be a number of added resources in the game that should help to set a distinctive flavor to the game while still keeping the strategic play concepts fairly standard. See if you can guess what they are?
Olives and garlic? Sheep? Marble?
 
My first thoughts about the special resources were Dolmas and Ouzo. :D Not likely, but that's what I was thinking.

I am wondering about the differences between the difficulty levels. If this isn't a Deity game, then I'm guessing that Conquest players won't get a second settler. That was probably just in the last game to counteract the AI advantage, so I don't think it would be included in a game that wasn't Deity. The Defense units won't be in the game either as they become obsolete with Bronze Working, which is one of the starting techs.

I'm guessing that barbarians will be one of the main differences, and maybe an additional worker or warrior unit for the Conquest players. As to the Predator class, it'll probably be the same as the last game.
 
Map: Large inland sea/ocean, and land on all sides on the map (edge separated by either mountains, or mountains/ocean). Possible smaller seas/lakes to be connected through straits (Black Sea). Many peninsulas. Mountain ranges separate civilizations between each other, to make sea-based invasion easier than land based one. A couple of large islands to become future strategic points in the middle of the inland sea (Cyprus. Crete).

Civilisations: Besides Greece, Rome, Spain, Chartage, Egipt, Arabs,
French? Gauls? Phoenicians (home made)? Ottomans? Atlantida (home made)?

Added resources: Is this about strategic resources? Well the distinctive thing about Greece is that they lacked resources. One could add Bronze (for early battle units), Wood (for boats), Papyrus? for Libraries?. You could have other bonus resources (Camel; Oasis – for the Desert area).
Or is it that generally the game resources. I would imagine changed luxuries (olives). Maybe there would be additional sea units but the AI would not use them effectively so I doubt. I could see some new buildings/wonders to provide culture/happiness Stadium/Olympics, the remainder of the seven wonders of the world not already included in Civ3: Statue of Zeus, Temple of Artemis, Mausoleum of Halicarnassus?

I believe that cracker definitely enhanced the sea dimension of the game but I can’t really figure out how to do it so that the AI is persuaded to use it as well. (Frequently build ships options turned on for all AIs?)
 
My first guess would be a difficult Emperor level game. This would fit nicely after easy-ish Emperor and Deity of last months (Don't get me wrong, I'm still playing GOTM20 and not sure of a win yet :p ). Maybe islands for us, pangaea for the AI.

Barbarians, yes, although the Greek called *all* the non-Greeks barbarians.

New resources, eh, hmmmm, marble is a nice one, tao. Olives, yes, or maybe olive-oil.
 
Mediteranean Melee.... (?)

Maybe as greece was originally formed from indepentant states there is the posibility of having quite varied ancient age military units... geeze I cant even think of their names, maceadonians umm spartans?? a Greek aliance??

Maybe unit at a low cost meaning lots of units for both the AI and us???

maybe maybe maybe errr

:confused:

resources hmmm
yeap, olives and marble are all I can think of as well..

all I can think of here is localized resources to lend towards each civs historical stregths..
 
Well, this is looking promising. I hope there will be a good part about the Ancient Times, as I'm trying to build a mod about it. :p So I might find some ideas, who knows ?

Hum, I hope all these changes will still allow French players to participate. Just in case someone forgot about us... :D Will it require some special fixes again ?
 
Mediterranean Melee
My vision is to have lot of civs on limited landmass. Civs will not be able to grab territory as easily as on recent games resulting on a limited number of towns that will need lot of micro management to optimize :( and enforcing heavy usage of boats / harbor for commerce and expansion.

Map
Archipelago / peninsula but no need of suicide galleys.
Potentially a bigger landmass but we won't be there more for Persia / Egypt / Babylonians but unsure

Civs
Babyloniens / Persia / Gauls (Frenchs) / Celts / Germans / Romans / Carthaginiens / Egypt / Ottomans / Spain / Zulus / English ?

Ressource-Luxuries
As said above Olives / Marble / Papyrus
Maybe some nice Oasis palm trees like in civ2 :D in desert areas
 
If I remember my history right, then Persia was the monster empire of the greek era. A massive number of cities, huge piles of cash and a million man army (although mostly mp in civ terms). Alexander beat the Persian Emporer Darius with his small but well trained army, allowing him to take over.

I wonder if they might get a boosted start, much like the Romans in GOTM-19?
 
I'm guessing two new resources, Bronze (SR) and Olive Oil (luxury).

For a map I'm guessing something similar to the eastern Med.

For civs I'm guessing Celts, Rome, Persia, Carthage and Egypt will be included. I'm sure there will be others. Maybe Babylon?
Well at least hoplites are great, even though they will cause an early GA...
 
I can only think that possibly Copper would be a resource. Hopefully we have a better start position then the mountains of Greece :)
 
Well, I've just spent the last 3 hrs in an intensive Greek history lesson, I've only looked into ancient and modern parts so far, but the rest may follow. Maybe what I've learnt can add to the debate. The more I read, the more I hope that next month's GOTM is going to be fairly historically acurate. I'd love to try to role play it to a certain extent.

Anyway, from my reading here are some general ideas of what we might see and what strategies might be effective, followed by a bit of history and some further ideas:

- Civs I'd expect: Egypt, Hittites (?), Persians, Ottomans, Romans, Carthage, France, England, Russia
- Early wars with the Egyptians and Hittites might bear fruit.
- The Persians may also be an early threat.
- We'll have iron and coal but no saltpeter?
- Expect the Ottomans to be annoyed or furious with us for most of the game.
- LOADS of delicate alliances to be founded and managed. Expect sporadic wars to break out left right and centre from the middle ages onwards.
- A tricky middle ages with a lack of saltpeter in our local area? Rise back to the assendence in modern times as we have coal and iron (ironworks?).
- A powerful Ottoman empire in the east, with whom we will need to constantly battle one way or another for the political and cultural dominance of our immediate region.

50,000 years ago
The first hunters from Africa and Asia set foot in the Greek heartland, hunting herds of game

7000 BC
Evidence of the first farming communities establishing themselves in what is now modern day Greece

2200BC - 1400BC - The Minoan Period
Settlers found communities on Crete, with its great opportunities for plentiful fishing and trade. The Minoans were the 1st great Aegean culture, with had developed a knowledge of writing, and thrived due to plentiful food sources and efficient farming methods.

- Map Making early will be v. useful to settle lush terrain on islands close by.
- Lets build some early libraries too!

1550BC - 1000 BC The Mycenean Period
(The Myceneans developed later than the Minoans, but by 1400BC had become very prosperous. They buried their dead with gold, jewelery, swords and silver cups. Their wealth came from a strong agriculture and international trade. Their warlike attitude allowed them to conquer the Minoans in around 1400BC. By 1200BC they were launching raids on foreign lands, hence the legend of the siege of Troy.But the wars took their toll, and Mycenean culture collapsed into civil war in around 1000BC.

1000 - 750BC - The Greek Dark Age
Following the collapse of the Mycenean culture, the Greeks went through a period of decline (revolution?) The population slumped, and artists and writers ceased their works.Recovery was slow, but recieved a major boost by the discovery of a new technology to smelt iron ore. Plentiful tools helped increase food production and thus restore the population and prosperity
- So we're likely to have iron then?

750-480BC - The Archaic Age
The Greeks gradual develop the unique idea that power is best shared. The City state is established, and new imaginative forms of art and architecture are developed. As the economy improved in the Archaic Age, the population grew rapidly, creating a shortage of good land and natural resources. The search for new farmland and metal ore drove Greeks to settle far from their homeland, sometimes living in others' settlements, sometimes establishing trading posts, and sometimes founding colonies as new city-states. By 500 bc, Greeks had founded numerous colonies in present-day southern France, Spain, southern Italy, North Africa, and along the coast of the Black Sea.

- So now were a Republic then. Or at least thinking about becoming one... I doubt we'd be able to settle new towns this late in the game though. Maybe grabbing the last few bits of terrain in Africa might be a possiblity though...

480-323BC The Classic Age
By 500BC Sparta was a powerful city state with a fearsome army. Athens was also a large city state, but with a much more democratic form of government. The Athenian powers sought an alliance with the hugely powerful persian empire to protect them from the increasingly agressive Spartans. However, the Athenians quickly abandoned this alliance to go to the aid of their Ionian Greek friends who were attempting to rebel from Persian control. This led to the first Persian Wars (490-479BC). The hugely outnumbered Greeks managed to repulse the initial Persian attack at Marathon, A messenger ran more than 32 km (20 mi) from Marathon to Athens to announce the news, a run memorialized in modern marathon races. (Well, you learn something new every day!).
To avenge their defeat at Maraton, Xeres lead the Persians ammased with army so large that the Greeks claimed it required seven days and seven nights of continuous marching for it to cross a pontoon bridge between Asia Minor and Mainland Greece. Some city-states in northern and central Greece surrendered, but Sparta led an alliance of 31 city-states against the Persians. A small detachment of Greek soldiers led by Spartan king Leonidas I gave their lives to temporarily block Xerxes’s army at a narrow pass called Thermopylae (see Battle of Thermopylae).
By the time the invading Persians reached Athens, the residents had evacuated, and the Persians burned an empty city. Athens was prepared to fight with its navy, built up from the proceeds of a rich discovery of silver a few years before. The Athenian general Themistocles defeated the Persian navy in the Battle of Salamís by luring Persian ships into a narrow channel, where the Greeks’ heavier ships proceeded to ram and sink them. In 479 bc the Greeks completed their triumph by defeating the Persian infantry at Plataea, relying on superior tactics and armor. This string of unexpected Greek victories in the Persian Wars preserved the Greeks’ independence and gave them so much self-confidence that they felt superior.

- Well, this certainly looks like this is the equivalent of our golden age! We'll need a fair few elite hoplites to drive back all those immortals though!




1453
Ottomans capture Greek capital of Constantinople


1770-1814
Alliances with the Russian Orthodox powers and spurred on by ideas generated by the French revolution, nationalism and insurgence against Ottoman rule are rampant

- Our initial strong culture makes it hard for Ottomans to dominate. And a keen interest in science, language and the arts helps us to retain our national identity. (Lots of libraries early on will really help).

1814 Armed revolt.
Alexandros Ypsilantis, a Greek general in the service of Russian emperor Alexander I, launches an attack from Russian territory into Moldavia, then part of the Ottoman Empire. Hoped-for Russian assistance failed to materialize, however, and the invasion was defeated. Another uprising at about the same time in the Pelopónnisos, led by Archbishop Germanos of Pátrai, met with greater success. The Greek War of Independence had begun.

- Russian MPP or alliance possibilities. But would they stab us in the back?

1814 Cont...
With no help from the world powers, England, France, Austria, Prussia and Russia and with the Ottomans signing an alliance with Egypt in return for the promise of handing them Crete, the future of the Greek uprising looks grim
- Effective alliances and MPPs will be key to retaining our grip on the region, with powerful players in other parts of Europe holding the key to our future as a great power.

1815-1827
With the war escalating and the threat to delicate eastern mediterranean trade routes intensifying, France, Russia and Britain join forces to oust the Ottoman-Egyptian threat. Count Ioánnis Kapodístrias, a Greek who had served as the joint foreign minister for Emperor Alexander I, was elected president of Greece, and a new constitution, the third drafted for the still unofficial state, was proclaimed.

- A Ha. Alliances might come good in the end!

1831-1832
Political instability, anarchy and intervention of the great powers leads them to nominate Otto of the Bavarian Wittelsbach dynasty to be king of Greece

- Threat of almost vassiliasation by great powers if we put too much reliance on them... Should have got hold of some more luxuries to control disorder there...

1843 Military coup

1862
Eventual overthrow of King Otto and granting of the throne to King George of the Danish Glücksburg dynasty. New constitution and greater political stability followed

1864-1908
Expansionist aspirations for the fledgeling greek state. Thessaly and part of Epirus ceded to Greece by the Ottomans in 1881 after the Ottomans lost the Russo-Turkish war.1896 - Revolt against Ottoman rule in predominantly greek island of Crete - brutally crushed by the Ottomans, but crete eventually becomes Greek in 1908

- Even in late game, culture and nationality continue to play a vital role. Tussles with the Ottomans continue into the modern age?

1910-1912 1st Balkan War
Modernisation, build up of the economy and armed forces, leading up to an alliance with Serbia, Bulgaria and Motenegro and a declaration of war against the Ottomans. Ottoman forces, heavily outnumbered, are beaten back from most of southern europe and the ailing ottoman empire cedes most of its european possessions to the Greeks.

1913 - 2nd Balkan War
Squabbling over territory captured during the first war leads to confict between Greece and Bulgaria, ending a month later with Bulgarian defeat.

1914-1918 1st world war
Greece sides with the allied powers, while the Ottomans side with Germany and Austria-Hungary. More conflict ensues

1939-1945 2nd world war
Mussolini demands an ROP through Greek Lands, which is refused, and war is declared. Greeks repulse the invaders and capture some of Albania (under a puppet Greek govt.) However, in 1941, German troops invade and over-run Greece despite British attempts to hold out in Crete. The harshness of the occupation regime led to terrible famine and spiraling inflation. More than 100,000 Greeks died as a result of the famine, and in 1943 most of the country’s Jews were deported to Nazi death camps in Poland.
1945-Present
After liberation, civil war between communists and nationalists. Ending in defeat for the communists. Greece joins NATO, various military coups, the creation of the Greek democract after the end of the militarty junta, then subsequently the EU.
 
Wow, Kello, what a summary!

I am a big fan too of Greek history ("Ancient Era", so to speak). It would be nice to recreate some of those challenges...

What about something on the "Sea people"?
 
Hmm... only extra I could suggest is maybe have tin as an extra strategic for bronze age spearman units - but I doubt many players would like that, so it probably will be olives.

Civs; I'd say Persia, Egypt, Keltoi, Carthage, Rome, Babylon, Zulu, China, Ottomans. I've noticed an entry for Minoans on the CivPaedia and they would certainly fit into a Med melee game.

Map size - standard or large.

Difficulty - Emperor I would guess.
 
The Greeks are scientific and commericial. It's like a double wammy in science. I'll be making a beeline for libraries. The cheap libraries, extra tech during the age change, and the extra cash to devote to research could make for a very fast tech race with us as the leaders of it.

I don't care for the Hoplite. It's a 1/3/1 unit. I'm not much into defense. I like offensive units. But it might be nice to make a couple and include one in a stack with some archers to protect them. An early GA might be just the thing to give us a nice advantage. Maybe I'll try to time the GA with learning Literature, so I can start building lots of libraries right away. That will help with science and culture.

Unfortuanately, I see lots of water in this one. I don't like water! I especially don't like it when you have to wait for navigation to contact everyone. It really slows the game down. Also, I'm worried that several AIs will be on their own continent and leap ahead with their tech trading.

Olives was the first thing that came to mind here too before scrolling down. I'm betting that there won't be new resources, but the names will just be in Greek. It's all Greek to me! Roman deja-vu anyone from about 4 GOTMs ago?
 
@ Rabies--that is just plain evil. Predator class, GOTM 20 (conquest only). Predator class GOTM 21 (AW). Ouch!

AW in a GOTM--that would be something!

And NO! I am not voting for predator class to be AW--I, for one, need a break from all these warmonger games.

OTOH...the greeks are a nice AW choice, with such a fine defensive unit...
 
Originally posted by Dislak
please cracker, not Zulu and Otto again!:cry: I can't contain them anymore!!!!

Like, Persians and Ottomans will be any easier?

Zulu and Persians are bad enough - but given location of Greece, I'd say even bet Ottomans are in.

This is all JUST speculation, so don't get disheartened yet!
 
Back
Top Bottom