Build a canal on the penninsula?

DaveShack

Inventor
Retired Moderator
Joined
Feb 2, 2003
Messages
13,109
Location
Arizona, USA (it's a dry heat)
Donsig pointed out in the Domestic thread that an opportunity to build a canal through the SE penninsula is available. The earlier city placement threads overlooked this possibility, so the adjacent cities are not in optimum positions, but there are several options that could be used.

dg3-810ad-canal.JPG


We need one from each pair of locations, magenta/yellow and blue/green.

Taking the choice of magenta vs. yellow, the yellow site has far less overlap with PDX III but we would need to build culture to guard against flips, and maybe even take Jinjan. Magenta squeezes PDX but doesn't have to go head to head on culture.

For the choice between blue and green, the green site is slightly better to Shaitan than magenta is to PDX because it is offset a square rather than being in a straight line.

For the N side of the canal, a 3rd option is to move PDX one tile SE. (Note the image shows Worker, this is not what is really being produced there. It is really doing temple and will be done in 52 turns.) This is just a thought, making people move their homes is not a step to be taken lightly. If the people of that fine town wanted to take a greater place in the national picture by becoming one end of a great canal their wishes could be accomodated, and if they prefer stability along with giving some other group of daring souls the opportunity to be the canal builders, that would be OK too. :)

So now, let the citizens find their voice and lend us their opinions! :hammer:
 
I noticed this way before Donsig... :p

I advocate a green/yellow canal. Yellow is obviously the best place for the North end, with room for expansion and possibility for a flip. And Green, while it does cause some worrysome overlap, it has the most potential for growth.
 
blue/yellow
 
I say blue. yellow as well. I don't think we'll flip Jinjan any time soon but I don't think either of our cities would flip to Perisa either. I also don't forsee a profitable Persian war on the horizon. They have gunpowder and we do not. The bulk of our forces are in the east and Esquiline province in the west is hardly defended at all.
 
Blue & Yellow. Placing them within the radius of our existing cities gives no advantage in this instance.
 
I agree with blue / yellow.
 
Originally posted by DaveShack
I'll take that as enough votes to win a poll if one were held... ;)

I agree and would like to point out this as a prime example of the will of the citizens coming to the forefront through discussion only. We do not need to poll everything.
 
Yes, we can say that this was agreed to by general consensus. Most things, however, need to be polled, if we had more than one or two dissenting opinions I would push for a poll.
 
Originally posted by Bootstoots
Yes, we can say that this was agreed to by general consensus. Most things, however, need to be polled, if we had more than one or two dissenting opinions I would push for a poll.

Agreed:goodjob:

BTW, Blue/ Yellow
 
I would Pick Blue and Yellow :).
 
We could kill 2 birds with 1 stone. We can have a Canal, Plus a chance to Culture Flip Jinjan :D.
 
Blue and Yellow, and I agree with CG, this is an opertunity to attempt a flip of Jinjan as well.
 
Back
Top Bottom