Forgotten Wars: The Russo-Polish War

naervod

My current user title
Joined
Oct 13, 2002
Messages
5,327
Location
San Francisco
Many wars have shaped Eastern Europe, such as World War II, the Crimean War, and World War I. However, there was a war, not very publicized, that led to the removal of Communism from Eastern Europe in the 1920's and 1930's. The Russo-Polish War was a war fought shortly after the bitter treaty of Brest-Litovsk, in which Russia had lost much land and power to the Germans.

Poland had been part of the Russian Empire during the 19th century, but the Treaty of Versailles created a new independent state and outlined it’s borders. This state was led by Marshal Pidulski, who commanded the Polish Legion on the Austro-Hungarian side during the First World War. Now that the Russians had a new frontier with Poland, in early 1920, they started to negotiate a new frontier. At this point, Russia had a weak military, and was prepared to cede territory east of the Curzon Line (frontier established by Treaty of Versailles in 1919) to Poland. However, the Poles wanted all territory that had belonged to Poland before 1772 and withdrew from the talks on April 7th.

On April 15th, the Poles attacked Russia with five armies, supplied in part by the Great War Entente, who had already unsuccessfully tried to intervene in the Russian Revolution, a few years earlier. The First and Fourth Armies were aimed at Belorussia and the Third, Second, and Sixth Armies were aimed at Ukraine, where the main attack was directed. The Poles aimed to destroy the Soviet South-West Front, the capture tje east bank of the Dnieper River, then push up and take Belorussia. The Poles would be helped by Simon Petlyura, an anti-Soviet Ukrainian leader, and Wrangel’s White Russian forces in the Crimea.

The Poles quickly pushed 124 miles into the Ukraine and captured Kiev on May 7th. In June, Wrangel’s forces broke out of the Crimea. However, the new Soviet Republic then mobilized 1.5 million men and concentrated forces on the right bank of the Dnieper. On June 12th, the Soviets recaptured Kiev and took Novograd-Volynsk on June 27th. This allowed the Soviet Western Front to attack and recapture Minsk on July 11th.

The Soviets, commanded by the 27-year old General Tukhachevskiy, then proceeded to drive on Warsaw. They reached Grodno on the 23rd of July, thereby beginning the ‘Warsaw Operation.’ After being ordered to pursue the Poles without stopping, Tukhacehvskiy reached the gates of Warsaw, the Polish capital on August 13th. Tukhacevskiy almost captured Warsaw, but he was out of supplies and reserves, and had stretched his communication lines to the limit.

In the Ukraine, the Soviet South-Western Front was bogged down in the Battle of Lvov, where the Poles, aided by the French, were holding the Soviets to a standstill. The Poles then took advantage of the lack of cooperation between the Soviet Western and South-Western Fronts and were able to get between them and hit Soviet Western Front forces, whom they outnumbered almost two to one. The Soviets were pushed back to Grodno on the 25th of August and to Minsk on October 12th.

By the time the Russians were pushed back to Minsk, peace had been signed in Riga. A frontier was established 155 miles east of the Curzon Line (which the Russians would have agreed to before the war). This armistice gave the Russians time to defeat the White Russian forces deep inside their territory. Poland proceeded to control the western parts of Ukraine and Belorussia, which it would hold for 18 more years, before the Russians invaded in September 1939.
 
Poland in 1921:
pl_1921.gif

Poland Today:
poland.jpg

Marshal Tukhachevskiy:
TUH.JPG
 
Originally posted by Richard III
...Although not forgotten... ;)
Indeed. I didn't even know about it, so how could I forget? :lol:
Nice article. :thumbsup:
 
The Poles did remarkably well to form a professional army so soon after their independence. Although they suffered badly, they seemed to have benefitted greatly from the out come of ww1 and 2. Nice article.
 
Originally posted by rilnator
The Poles did remarkably well to form a professional army so soon after their independence

there were plenty of trained and battle tested polish soldiers---in the russian, austro-hungarian,and german armies. this time they were fighting for themselves;)
 
ya the Russians pretty much got the sh*t kicked out of them in the Russo-Polish War. hehehe.
i say they deserved it for subjugating the Poles and then trying to come back in to dominate them again. too bad after WW2 the Allies let the Soviets come into Poland (and the reast of Eastern Europe) again and dominate it for half a century :rolleyes: .
but basically, Poland and the rest of Eastern Europe was just seen by Britain, France, etc. as the blockade that would prevent communist gov'ts from springing up in western Europe. The west didn't give a rat's ass about what government would be in Poland or Eastern European nations as long as it was not pro-soviet. And the Treaty of Versailles never fully defined some of the borders of the new Eastern European states. Example: The new Polish-German border was not defined. The western territories (of inter-war Poland) were made as plebiscite zones. The new German government actually sent thousands of Germans from Germany into the plebiscite zones to offset the overwhelming Polish population, and there were 3 uprisings/conflicts in the areas. Eventually the areas were (mostly) given to Poland.
Seriously. That Treaty caused more problems and intensified already-existing problems rather than eliminating and preventing problems.
In fact, if I could, I would get the actual, original Treaty of Versailles document, show it the middle finger (just for the fun of it), drag it through mud, stomp on it, tear it apart, douse it with gasoline, and throw a match at it to incinerate it. :mwaha: :rotfl: :mwaha: :rotfl: :mwaha:
and then i would throw an after-party to celebrate!
:band: :jump: [party] [dance]
 
Thats a bit harsh old Kamilian
 
Thanks for the feedback, I am planning another Forgotten Wars article, probably on the Barbary Coast.
 
Give us a link when you do make this article.
 
The Poles did remarkably well to form a professional army so soon after their independence. Although they suffered badly, they seemed to have benefitted greatly from the out come of ww1 and 2. Nice article.

The Polish army of 1920 was an odd collection of soldiers who had served in the Russian, Austro-Hungarian, German, French and even Italian armies, and had completely different training, equipment, unit structures, and command structures. As late as the September 1939 campaign there were still some units with the 1918 German or Austrian helmets and uniforms. And as anyone who has ever served in a military knows, there are naturally inter-service rivalries that were exascerbated in the Polish armed forces as those who served in the Western armies looked down on those in the eastern armies, etc. There were also fused into the Polish Army some local irregulars and militias formed in border regions in 1918 as Poles, Ukrainians, Germans, Lithuanians, Czechs, etc, jostled over their new borders.

This makes Pilsudski's achievement at Warsaw in 1920, given the mish-mash army he had to deal with, all the more remarkable. It should also be mentioned however that the Bolshevik Russian armed forces were just as patched together and disorganized; the evidence being that some very brilliant Soviet strategists (Tukhachevsky, Budienny, etc.) were on the Russian side despite their defeat.

My only negative comment on the article is the need for some context. the war started really over Ukraine, as Poland in 1919 finally settled its border disputes with the Ukrainians and signed a treaty with Simeon Petljura to rid the rest of their country (especially the capital, Kiiv) of Russian Bolsheviks. This the Poles did in Spring 1920, taking Kiiv in May. The Bolshevik counter-attack against Poland and Ukraine is what is known as the "Russo-Polish War". It should also be remembered that in the Treaty of Riga that ended the war in 1921, both Lenin and Pilsudski broke various promises they'd made to Ukraine, essentially partitioning the country between Poland and Soviet Russia.

As one of the people principally responsible for the political aspects of the war, a certain Iosif Djugashvili took great umbrage from the defeat and held a special grudge against Poland. Known better to history as Stalin, he got his revenge in 1939....

Recommended reading would be Pilsudski's own account, long since translated into English, called Rok 1920 ("The Year 1920").
 
Poland had been part of the Russian Empire during the 19th century, but the Treaty of Versailles created a new independent state and outlined it’s borders. This state was led by Marshal Pidulski, who commanded the Polish Legion on the Austro-Hungarian side during the First World War. Now that the Russians had a new frontier with Poland, in early 1920, they started to negotiate a new frontier. At this point, Russia had a weak military, and was prepared to cede territory east of the Curzon Line (frontier established by Treaty of Versailles in 1919) to Poland. However, the Poles wanted all territory that had belonged to Poland before 1772 and withdrew from the talks on April 7th.

I think You ment "west" to the Curzon line.
It's not true Poland wanted all the lands it posessed before partages; there were two conception; of nationalists, who wanted most of pre-partages territory (but not all, because then, Poles would have been a minority in their own state), and a federalist conception, in which Poland would have been a major partner of other nations yet under Russian (Soviet) rule

On April 15th, the Poles attacked Russia with five armies, supplied in part by the Great War Entente,

I'll just add that at least the official excuse were Soviet plans of invading poland in order to get across it to help revolution in Germany. When it comes to the west helping Poland, it's not that obvious at all. Some states were hostile; Belgium forbidden sending even food to Poland, Tchechoslovakia invaded border regions (and kept them up to today) and forbidden transporting any supplies also. I think German attitude wasn't better, and Poland practically had no access to the sea
 
good thing that Russia got back at the Pole in WWII.
 
Back
Top Bottom