Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
I can probably put an inventory of items in this post; we'll see though.
[Large Mafia August] Archetype mafia game thread
- Thread starter Kennigit
- Start date
Well, that was a fun game, but it would have been better if I hadn't died so early.
A lot of interesting stuff going on there. I must say that the scum factions are a bit too big for a game of this size with recruitment abilities, unless they were just designed for the bigger game that never materialized. Could have been balanced a bit better, but there's certainly been worse.
Also, the percentage-based abilities made it way too overcomplicated, and you made too many. That must have been hell to keep track of on the first few nights.
Lastly, I totally called Jarrema being scum on Day 1.
A lot of interesting stuff going on there. I must say that the scum factions are a bit too big for a game of this size with recruitment abilities, unless they were just designed for the bigger game that never materialized. Could have been balanced a bit better, but there's certainly been worse.
Also, the percentage-based abilities made it way too overcomplicated, and you made too many. That must have been hell to keep track of on the first few nights.
Lastly, I totally called Jarrema being scum on Day 1.
TheLastDays
Warlord
I seriously tried finding the scum during the game, even though I completed my victory conditions on the side, I was able to win with the red team as well.
I didn't think the game would end after this night because I didn't factor in that Kennigit wasn't counting me and tailless as town (red). I knew after this night I would know for sure who was blue but alas, it ended before the day ever started.
GG, townscums, although I agree there were a bit too many of you
I didn't think the game would end after this night because I didn't factor in that Kennigit wasn't counting me and tailless as town (red). I knew after this night I would know for sure who was blue but alas, it ended before the day ever started.
GG, townscums, although I agree there were a bit too many of you
Yoshiegg737
Jungo Jungo
Hurry for the Hero's 
Kennigit
proud 2 boxer
well, you actually died to jukar's attack. Just you already won, so I didn't have you die.
left with 1v1, which is traditionally just counted as victory for the scum.
also, wrote some answers to "sentiments" in the questions asked post
the questions/sentiments asked are probably all discussed extensively on the GM log, but that isn't organised for nice easy convenient use.
mechaerik
Tuturuu!
Quite, considering you and I vouched for Verarde, I the previous day.
That being said, i thought TK was townscum until death.
Hurry for the Hero's
Yeah! for the team! Great lynches by Yoshi
Verarde
Pondering Wearing A Hat
So....if everyone had listened to me and voted jukar-c right at the end....
WE WOULD HAVE WON.
and then TK, why did you attack me? <facepalm>
WE WOULD HAVE WON.
and then TK, why did you attack me? <facepalm>
TheLastDays
Warlord
Right... I forgot about tailless attack ability, should have asked him to not use it that night.
Zack
99% hot gas
I was metagamed so badly, it's almost enough to convince me to stop playing here.
In four nights of play, I was...
Scanned: 7 times!
Attacked: 3 times!
Seriously not cool.
Not to mention never being able to kill anyone, even though I was the lone attacker for a scum faction, wasn't very fun either...
In four nights of play, I was...
Scanned: 7 times!
Attacked: 3 times!
Seriously not cool.
Not to mention never being able to kill anyone, even though I was the lone attacker for a scum faction, wasn't very fun either...
Zack
99% hot gas
Yes, because one of the 7 (!!!!) scans got me as blue.
TheLastDays
Warlord
I didn't metagame you even though you are one of the few people around here I already knew from the Org.
even though you are one of the few people around here I already knew from the Org.
Zack
99% hot gas
The full list (copied from the dead QT, so no names are given):
... scans Zack for items
... role scans zack
... faction scans zack
... scans zack for religious items
... scans zack for injury
... attacks zack
... faction scans zack
... attacks zack
... attacks zack
... PG scans zack
... scans Zack for items
... role scans zack
... faction scans zack
... scans zack for religious items
... scans zack for injury
... attacks zack
... faction scans zack
... attacks zack
... attacks zack
... PG scans zack
sirtommygunn
Emperor
I could have helped so much more if I had just bothered to do a self-preservation vote.
I still don't understand what Takhisis was thinking with that lynch, though.
I still don't understand what Takhisis was thinking with that lynch, though.
Backwards Logic
Emperor Palpatine
To be fair Zack, I only faction scanned you because your actions had pinged my scumdar. I sent The Bake to attack you another night, and the final PG scan I did on you was searching for a scummy looking PG that I could *maybe* use to track down another scum. If you, a confirmed scum, had a scummy looking PG (and you did), then it would be conceivable other scum would as well. So you weren't metagamed as bad as you think, as three of the actions were the result of me.
Nice game Kennigit. Wasn't a huge fan of the setup of others having to find other players (let's face it, it was mostly a crapshoot (Renata being the exception), and again not a fan of players being able to be converted from the faction, but it was different and I'll give you props for that. I hope you and (evenually) Renata had/have a good chuckle at the trekkie QT...
Nice game Kennigit. Wasn't a huge fan of the setup of others having to find other players (let's face it, it was mostly a crapshoot (Renata being the exception), and again not a fan of players being able to be converted from the faction, but it was different and I'll give you props for that. I hope you and (evenually) Renata had/have a good chuckle at the trekkie QT...
