7ronin
海軍少佐
Arrgh. My head is spinning. I will happily keep myself well removed from the art of sausage making.
Blue:
"Need: Passes through impassable mountains such as the Himalayas Solution: Use the LM Hills slot with changed graphics. All mountain terrains will be flagged impassable.
Mangroves and mudflats are quite different ecologies and distinct appearances." Agreed.
"Need: In real world terms the questions to be answered are things like the desirability of representing the Rann of Kutch and/or the Sundarbans as terrains that are different from any other deltas and estuaries." Based on your comments, I would say that they do.
"Need: Representing the presence of coral reefs in the island chains. Solution: depends on whether the reefs need to impede or block naval units. Also whether or not land units should be able to move onto them. If the latter then should they be settleable? With those questions answered the solution can be anything from a visually interesting decoration that makes no difference in game terms to use of a lm terrain that requires careful consideration of several other slots." My take is that they block movement and cannot be settled.
"Need: Thorn scrub to be distinguished from desert. Solution: could be LM Desert if the majority of effects will be the same." Okay. I have no thoughts on possible effects.
"The waterfall graphic I mentioned is just a variation within the Mountains pcx and has no game effect in any way distinct from the mountains." Okay.
"The Rann is an area of seasonal salt flats/marsh nearly unique in the world. Most likely worthy of both distinct graphics & game effects." I agree. It seems that it would be impassable terrain.
"The Sundarbans are a complex mix of mud flats, mangroves and inhabitable islands. If mud flats, mangroves and salt marshes need to take up three terrain slots then other questions arise - such as what effects can be shared with other terrain slots and which need to be distinct. Only then can the types be assigned." If you feel that this is a desirable terrain type, I will defer to you on how to bring it about.
"Irrawaddy Delta." Senior moment on my part; I meant to say Ganges/Bramahputra Delta. After further thinking, I don't think we need to do anything special with it.
I hope I answered all your questions.
Blue:
"Need: Passes through impassable mountains such as the Himalayas Solution: Use the LM Hills slot with changed graphics. All mountain terrains will be flagged impassable.
Mangroves and mudflats are quite different ecologies and distinct appearances." Agreed.
"Need: In real world terms the questions to be answered are things like the desirability of representing the Rann of Kutch and/or the Sundarbans as terrains that are different from any other deltas and estuaries." Based on your comments, I would say that they do.
"Need: Representing the presence of coral reefs in the island chains. Solution: depends on whether the reefs need to impede or block naval units. Also whether or not land units should be able to move onto them. If the latter then should they be settleable? With those questions answered the solution can be anything from a visually interesting decoration that makes no difference in game terms to use of a lm terrain that requires careful consideration of several other slots." My take is that they block movement and cannot be settled.
"Need: Thorn scrub to be distinguished from desert. Solution: could be LM Desert if the majority of effects will be the same." Okay. I have no thoughts on possible effects.
"The waterfall graphic I mentioned is just a variation within the Mountains pcx and has no game effect in any way distinct from the mountains." Okay.
"The Rann is an area of seasonal salt flats/marsh nearly unique in the world. Most likely worthy of both distinct graphics & game effects." I agree. It seems that it would be impassable terrain.
"The Sundarbans are a complex mix of mud flats, mangroves and inhabitable islands. If mud flats, mangroves and salt marshes need to take up three terrain slots then other questions arise - such as what effects can be shared with other terrain slots and which need to be distinct. Only then can the types be assigned." If you feel that this is a desirable terrain type, I will defer to you on how to bring it about.
"Irrawaddy Delta." Senior moment on my part; I meant to say Ganges/Bramahputra Delta. After further thinking, I don't think we need to do anything special with it.
I hope I answered all your questions.