I remember... back in, let me see... yes, almost exactly a hundred years ago. I was just a small boy, a student in the Glen of Killybegs; still a small town in the jungle then, not the bustling city of today. We were being taught about our duty to Sirona, to offer mercy to the fallen, and compassion to those who could find it nowhere else. The world was full of evil, my teacher said, and only love could we hope to defeat it. "But where," I asked, "does this evil come from?" She frowned. Apparently children weren't supposed to ask such questions. But she decided to answer it. "From the dark parts of men's hearts. All men are good, deep inside, but sometimes they forget that. Sometimes they get led astray, and need to be shown the right path, to goodness and happiness." A simple answer, meant for children. Of course, there is nothing a child hates worse then being treated like one. "Who leads them astray?" I asked. She shuddered. "The Fallen One. We do not speak his name. At first, the universe was good. But then the Fallen One went astray..." I interrupted her. "Who led him astray?" "Nobody. He made a mistake, and chose the wrong path." "Why?" But all she could say is "nobody knows. He was once the greatest of the angels, the King of Hope. Our Lady seeks to redeem him, for even in him the spark of goodness remains."
I was satisfied, at first. But then I found myself wondering. She had never really answered my question: where had evil come from? It had corrupted the Fallen One, but he had not created it. The question floated in my head for a few years. Maybe the Fallen One had created it. But then, why? Maybe it was a sad, but fundamental part of the universe. But wouldn't that mean that it was also a fundamental part of humans, unlike what I had been taught?
I toyed with this question into my teenage years, as I studied magic, when the Luonnatar came, and accidentally offered me the answer. I first laid eyes on one in the middle of the town square, preaching. "The gods you worship are false, petulant children!" Officially, we tolerated other beliefs, but that didn't stop some from laughing at this man's absurd rantings. But they made sense to me. The gods had been created by a greater god, the One, the preacher explained. I asked, "is this One the same as the Fallen One?" For a brief moment, he looked at me as though I had just casually asked what brothel his mother worked at, how much she cost, and whether or not, in his opinion, she was worth the price. But then he laughed. "Ha! Agares, the Fallen One whose name your people fear to speak, is as much a child and a fool as all the rest! Worse, it is by his hand that our world is in its sad state, that the One could not rule as he was meant to. Nay, the One of which I speak is the purest good. He is all-knowing, all-seeing, and almighty." This made little sense to me, however. "If the One knew everything, saw everything, and could do anything, why did he not stop the Falle... Agares... from descending into evil? And if he created everything, didn't he also create evil?" The preacher didn't seem to like this suggestion much. "I never said he created everything. The One did not created your clothes, did he? Nay, it was Agares who created evil..." "How?" I am certain the preacher did not want me to ask that question. He didn't have any answers either. He stammered a bit about unknowable mysteries and unimaginable intelligences. But he had nothing. And I had a name.
Agares. It seemed absurd. The terrible, dark, Fallen One had a name, just like any other creature. Perhaps he had fears. Perhaps he had dreams. Maybe he did regret his mistakes, and was too proud to admit them. I wondered: who was Agares? And why had he followed, or perhaps forged, the path to darkness? Indeed, I felt sorry for him. Maybe he had been looking for answers to a question nobody could answer, just as I was.
A few months later, a stranger came into our lands. A woman, with unnaturally pale skin and icy white hair, despite her relative youth. She was only a little older than myself, in fact. She asked only for shelter and food, and both were provided. She was silent, graceful, and beautiful beyond words. She dressed simply, but whatever she wore seemed to be the rainment of queens upon her. Of course, all the men in the village wanted her, but she showed only polite interest, occasionally smiling a sad but unimaginably wonderful smile. Then one day, she asked for me.
We met by the bank of a small creek. For a while, we listened to the sounds of the jungle. Then she spoke, in broken Elohim. "I sense... strange thoughts?" A lilting Balseraph accent; she sounded as wonderful as she looked. I wasn't sure why, but I nodded. "I sometimes wonder... about the Fallen One..." She smiled. Oh, what a smile. "Your question, I knew. Answers, I give you. But first, we drink." She offered up a bottle of Balseraph wine. It smelled magnificent, and tasted even finer. I drank eagerly, and as I did so, she began to speak. "Evil, I tell you. Elves, you know? Fellowship, you know?" I guessed, correctly, she spoke of the Fellowship of Leaves. "Yeah." "They do not protect prey from predator, yes?" "That's one interpretation..." "Is true interpretation, I say. But I not know, I not them. Truth, I tell you. Evil, you must accept. Good cannot win. Also, evil cannot win. Is nothing to win, in world." I stared at her. "I see future. In future, in your heart, good has lost. Abyss has won. But no. I change future."
My vision began to blur. "You drink. You are saved. Abyss cannot get you. Overlords protect you." I began to hear voices. A thousand voices, each speaking differently, and surrounding it all the roar of the sea. "Listen. Listen. You hear truth. It hurts, yes? But in time, you hear music. Wonderful music. Music of eternity." I could make no sense of the voices; some congratulated me, some mocked me for haven been so easily tricked, either by Agares or by them, some seemed disappointed at their victory. I realized, calmly, that I was going mad. Some part of my mind refused to listen, though. It sought out some island of stability. And it found it.
"Silence." At this powerful, incredible command, the voices died down. I sensed an awesome presence, and it spoke to me. "Long have you sought me. Sought to understand me. I am Agares. I am the Fallen One. I am the King of Hope. You are my child. You are my chosen. You shall show the world who I truly am." The Balseraph began chanting, and at her command the voices rose up again, louder, and perhaps more desperate. They attempted to unite. "The Lord of Depair offers only the flames and the Abyss. Dance with us for eternity, and we shall show you things more beautiful than you can imagine, more wonderful than you can dream of..." "You can offer a life spent dreaming, with only idle fantasies and endless distractions. But nothing real. Nothing substantial. You are naught but the nightmares of a slumbering god. You are dust and ashes, blowing across a shattered mind. You are pathetic." And indeed, before Agares, they were nothing. They continued to speak even as Agares did, but I could barely hear them. He did not yell. His voice did not even drown out the others, simply swept them away with its confidence, its calm, its assurance.
"Kill her." I resisted. It seemed easy, until I realized he wasn't trying to control me, or even command me. Even resisting a simple suggestion from one so magnificent was an effort. Rather then try to force me, Agares calmly added, "Or you can let her kill you. It seems a simple choice." It was then I became aware of the fact that the Balseraph woman was holding a long, elegant knife, decorated with pearls and coral. And she was planning to use it on me.
"In your eyes, I see. Abyss has won. I must send you there. My lords demand. All gods demand. World demands. For Erebu..." she never finished her sentence. I'm not sure how I killed her. I didn't use any magic, I simply recall letting go, allowing the great, unimaginable presence of Agares to guide me. I think I broke her neck. It was hard to tell, though, since I'd also shattered many of her bones. Further, I'd carved all sorts of sigils and symbols into her with her own blade. A fine, well-weighted thing. It seemed different, although I wasn't sure how. Less beautiful, more terrifying. Sharper, more refined. Before it had seemed a work of art that could be used for killing; now it was clearly an instrument of death.
"Do you swear to serve me?" "Yes..." I couldn't even contemplate answering otherwise. How could I refuse one who was so much more than I had dreamed possible? "Good. Then spread the word. You shall be my first. You shall be my child. The King of Hope awakens to cleanse the world of pretenders, to bring the truth to those brave enough to seek it, to bring death to those too weak to understand it. Do this, and I shall grant you power. Power beyond your wildest dreams..." "I don't want power. I only want the truth." "The truth is power. Evil, some would call me. Perhaps. But follow me, upon the path I took. You asked where evil came from? I shall tell you. It came from those who would be more than what was chosen for them. It came from those who, rather then blindly kneeling before their elders, dared to ask the unanswerable questions. It came from Hope. The hope of becoming something greater. I offer you this hope." And of course, I accepted.
(I intended several things, hopefully most or all of them worked. I first intended that the narrator's fate not be obvious until the fourth paragraph. Then I sought to imply the Balseraph woman was a servant of Agares, and would bring the narrator to him. Technically, she did indeed bring the narrator to Agares. But that hadn't been her plan. I had originally thought of making the narrator's would-be savior Empyrean or Order. But I wanted to explore the dynamics between the Overlords and Ashen Veil a bit. Besides, the theme of Order/Empyrean vs. Ashen Veil is pretty common. The Overlords offer a less traditional salvation, and allow Agares to present himself as the lesser of two evils.)