PhilBowles
Deity
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2011
- Messages
- 5,333
2. Not necessarily. The point I was making is the arguments for the inclusion of Italy highlight its role in the Renaissance. So I noted that we've already had a Renaissance focused expansion and thus makes its inclusion now seem..odd. So it has less to do with the industrial era, and more to do with the Italy people want having already had its moment in the sun pass by. "
3. This makes sense, but only if they're playing well thought out mindgames. Which, honestly, they havent shown signs of. Pictures of shadows and buildings on a poster are far from reverse psychology.
4. Sure, after they rebelled. The bastards.
I have the feeling they think they're being more obvious than they are, or at the very least that people here are overthinking it.
The Zulu giveaway was so basic they might as well have said "The next civ is the Zulu" straightaway.
Assyria was trailed by a unit with an Assyrian-style icon.
I still suspect everyone would have got Portugal straightaway if the supposedly helpful hint hadn't made it seem much more ambiguous than it was.
They showed a unit that's evidently Native American.
They've explicitly referred to Morocco once it was clear no one was picking up on the Kasbah hint they specifically asked people to look at.
Chances are the achievement is intended as a similarly obvious "look, Italy isn't in". Quite possibly showing Venice as the only 'unaccounted for' city-state change was intended as a deliberate hint that Venice is a civ - after all, if Italy had been added they could have shown the CS that replaced Florence or Genoa instead.
Also note that they've made certain reveals as apparent responses to fan speculation. So after the Kongo debate, they stepped in and revealed that Mbwanza-Kongo was a CS. The Venice hint only emerged after Italy and Venice threads abounded.