My Pet Project - America in the Philippines; 1898-1902

El Justo

Deity
Joined
Mar 5, 2004
Messages
12,948
Location
Southern NJ
the last third of my studies as an undergrad college student consisted primarily of this exact era (spanish/american war-philippine/american war-turn of 20th century). as such, i had always wanted to put together a scenario featuring the dearth of information i've acquired for this particular era. so, over the last several days, i've put together what i'd describe as "America in the Philippines; 1898-1902". this is very likely my last ever civ3 scenario so now is the time to finish it up!

ask someone what they know about the Americans in the Philippines and they may say something like "civilize 'em with a Krag!" or "Benevolent Assimilation". you may even get the bataan death march, corregidor, or the battle of leyte gulf which are all from ww2.

America first became active in the Philippine Islands on 1 May 1898 when acting secretary of the navy, theodore roosevelt, ordered then Commodore George Dewey to destroy the Spanish fleet at Manila. a state of war had existed for just over a week when Dewey proclaimed "Gridley...you may fire when ready!". as a result, Dewey's Asiatic Squadron was responsible for firing the first shots of the Spanish-American War.

Dewey's fleet made quick work of the dilapidated spanish squadron in Manila Bay. sure, they fired their guns at the Yanks (as well as shore batteries) but were all pretty much off the mark (a few shells got through but did little damage & no KIA). the sole american casualty was a sailor who suffered a heart attack before the battle even took place.

the Spanish were quick to realize that they were clearly outgunned and they took refuge in the old port city of Manila and the surrounding vicinity while the Americans and the Filipino rebels dug in around Manila. what our history books failed to tell us was that the Spanish and the Filipinos were just resuming hostilities against one another when war broke out vs the US and the Spanish. in 1896, the Filipinos had engaged the Spanish in open warfare w/ an eye towards independence and the eviction of the oppressive Spanish colonial regime on the islands. a cease-fire had been brokered by the time the US came into the picture but soon thereafter, by May of 1898, the USN (by Dewey himself!) picked up the rebel leaders in Hong Kong and delivered them back to the islands in an effort to assist them in their struggle for the Spanish.

fast-forward to June of 1898: the Filipinos declare their independence from Spain and form what historians refer to as the "First Philippine Republic".

the turning point of American involvement in the Philippine Islands came in December 1898 when the US and Spain negotiated the Treaty of Paris thus officially ending the war and as a result, the Philippine Islands were ceded over to the US for the sum of $20M. left completely out of the negotiations were the Filipinos. tensions were mounting as the US began sending in transport after transport full of re-enforcements.

4 February 1899: the recently signed Treaty of Paris was waiting for Congressional ratification when an American sentry fired on a Filipino when he refused his order to halt. the Philippine-American War had begun.

little is taught or spoken of about this war. it wasn't until 1998 that the US Congress officially changed the name of the conflict from "The Philippine Insurrection" to the "Philippine-American War". this switch was done primarily b/c many Filipino historians note that since the rebels declared independence from Spain in June 1898 that the rebels were no longer rebels and that they were instead a soveriegn nation when the hostilities between the US and the Filipinos began in February 1899. however, the classification of the conflict as an "insurrection" is somewhat accurate as a) the US Congress never declared war vs the Filipinos and b) from a legalistic standpoint, the islands were a possession of the US as a result of the Treaty of Paris and for all intensive purposes, were of internationally recognized as the possessors of the islands.

a quick synopsis of the war:
american KIA: about 4,500
filipino KIA: about 20,000 (enemy combatants only)
an additional 200,000 were said to have perished as a result of the war. most were peasants who had the not-so-good fortune of being in the path of the American forces as they burned villages to the ground, bombarded cities and barrios from land and sea, and generally rendered much of the countryside usesless from an agricultural stand point.

it was not until 4 July 1902 when Theodore Roosevelt proclaimed the hostitlites over with. however, fighting raged on in some parts of the archipelago (sounds familiar, eh?). the southern-most island of mindinao wasn't completely pacified until 1913 or so.

pictured below is the USN Asiatic Squadron w/ the USFS Olympia on the top. sweet gfx, too (Wyrmshadow).
 
below is a shot of the map. it is originally done by Emperor (aka Lord Parkin). on the far right corner is San Franciso and the surrounding area. this may seem a little out of scale but it's the only option, really, if i want to include any part of the US.
 
order of battle:

blue = USA
white = Philippines

US

1st columm from left to right and top to bottom:
US Scout
1.65" Hotchkiss mountain gun

2nd columm:
US Volonteer
US Regualr
3" Hotchkiss mountain gun
US Marine

3rd columm:
Gatling Gun

4th columm:
Macabebe Scout

5th columm:
US Cavalry Troop


Filipinos

clockwise from left to right:

Insurgent Regular (pointy NVA-VC type hat)
Maxim MG (they had only a few of them)
Insurgent Irregular
Insurgent Regular (again)
Moro Rifleman (mindinao)
Moro Radier (mindinao)
Boloman

not pictured: Insurgent Militia

cool trenches, too! the insurgents were said to have constructed very impressive earth works (according to reports).
 
D´you mean the American Spanish War at the end of the 19th century?
 
Then shouldn´t the Spanish have retreated by then?
 
yeah, sort of...but why not include Dewey's squadron and the 1st Battle of Manila?

although it was a pre-arranged sham...in that the Spanish and Americans pre-arranged to 'stage' a battle in order to preseve Spanish integrity. no kidding!

the US lost 4 or 6 KIA and the Spanish lost a few dozen iirc.
 
Absolutely fascinating. I would never had imagined a scenario based on this relatively forgotten and shameful period of American history - brilliant.

ps I can't wait to see what you and the unit creators come up with for Civ IV.
 
Yup, the Spanish knew they were going to lose, same in the Antipodes (Cuba), where they went out of harbor even when they knew the yankee navy was out there, ready to swaloow them.
 
Koba the Dread said:
Absolutely fascinating. I would never had imagined a scenario based on this relatively forgotten and shameful period of American history - brilliant.

ps I can't wait to see what you and the unit creators come up with for Civ IV.
hi Koba the Dread.

this is definitely a fascinating era for American history. i've seen multiple similarities between what is going on in iraq right now and what happened in the P.I. (pacification, resistance, civil govt, hearts-and-minds, etc). of course, it is not exactly the same but there are many likenesses.

civ4 creation, at least for me, will take a while. gfx, time, and newness will prevent me from working at the pace i do now.
 
Takhisis said:
Yup, the Spanish knew they were going to lose, same in the Antipodes (Cuba), where they went out of harbor even when they knew the yankee navy was out there, ready to swaloow them.
the Spanish actually put up a fight (on land at least) in Cuba. it didn't last too long though.
 
AlCosta15 said:
so when is this going to be released?

looks awesome, btw.
hi there AlCosta15.

i can't say for sure but i've been testing it. i just placed the american OoB around Manila. i'll try and post some more screen shots later.

one thing i'm noticing is the culture flips. it's not rampant but it has occurred both to the Filipinos and the Yanks. this is good b/c 'hearts-and-minds' was a large part of the conflict. another aspect i'm watching is the american amphibious capacity w/ all those islands. playing as the filipinos, i noticed multiple amphibious ops by the AI yanks and the they even attacked amphibiously w/ their lone amph unit, the US Marine, a few different times. this is very encouraging as the war was historically about amphibious expeditionary missions.
 
here's a shot of the Manila/Central Luzon area. the Yanks took Manila on the first turn and skirmished a little against me (Filipinos). the US has had that stack there near Cavite for several turns now. i've lost a good chunk of northern Luzon to the Yanks who landed several transports off the northern coast. i've also gained a few back from culture flips. i'm trying to figure the balance.

there's a custom resource sheet w/ all kinds of different stuff that's indigenous to the P.I. like sugar cane, hemp, salt, bananas, tobacco, timber, copper, rice, and not pictured: pineapples, corn
 

Attachments

  • PAWCLuzon.JPG
    PAWCLuzon.JPG
    227.5 KB · Views: 236
El Justo said:
hi there AlCosta15.

i can't say for sure but i've been testing it. i just placed the american OoB around Manila. i'll try and post some more screen shots later.

one thing i'm noticing is the culture flips. it's not rampant but it has occurred both to the Filipinos and the Yanks. this is good b/c 'hearts-and-minds' was a large part of the conflict. another aspect i'm watching is the american amphibious capacity w/ all those islands. playing as the filipinos, i noticed multiple amphibious ops by the AI yanks and the they even attacked amphibiously w/ their lone amph unit, the US Marine, a few different times. this is very encouraging as the war was historically about amphibious expeditionary missions.

In the scenario editor you can turn that off.
 
AlCosta15 said:
In the scenario editor you can turn that off.
i wouldn't want to shut culture flipping off completely. it was an 'insurgency' after all...but it does get annoying if it occurrs w/ high frequency.

i've never really worked w/ the exact ratios for culture flips before so it'll take some fine-tuning to get it right.

all in all though i'm pleased so far w/ the play-testing...
 
AlCosta15 said:
I like the city graphics, whose are they?
they're MaisseArsouye's "Polynesian" city gfx. they are pretty cool, aren't they? they fit in nicely for the theme and the era.
 
Do you know of any thad I could use for my War in Africa mod?
Right now I need more "Islamic" style buildings.
 
AlCosta15 said:
Do you know of any thad I could use for my War in Africa mod?
Right now I need more "Islamic" style buildings.
i searched through the city gfx library. give it a try...i'm sure you'll find something desirable.
 
Back
Top Bottom