r16
not deity
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2008
- Messages
- 11,219
ı have noticed that a post about the endless agonies about being a Turk has been edited last week or so . Oh-kay , a short history of the Turkish Republic . Founded by Mustafa Kemal , who had the formative experience of the 1897 War with the Greeks which proved Turks were not totally dead . This proof of can-do attitude is hard to understand , unless one has suffered the same amount of "encroachment" of foreigners and the insecurity of being "determined to loose" . He was a beneficiary of reforms that were basically the last breath attempts of the Ottomans to be relevant , he had the schooling to see one had to share whatever limited resources . To cope with an ever hungry West ; multi-ethnic multiparty Democracy was the salvation . Especially if it managed to balance with Arabs (and the oil that lied beneath the land where they were the majority) with the Christians that were so industrious in all sorts of trade that no ethnic Turk could open a shop in the capital of the Ottoman Empire . His first major thing was selling Democracy to the Libyans who were aghast at the oust of Abdülhamid , with two of the greediest of two European colonial empires encamped to East and the West . With the obvious end to the Panislamist narrative enamated form Istanbul , theirs was perhaps a panic , perhaps a readiness to start the talks for the best bargain . Until promised that they were still part of the Ottoman state . Let the Libyans serve the State and they would be served by the likes of Mustafa Kemal .
then the wars came . We in Turkey never hear that his first major command , of the troops in Gallipoli in 1912-3 , ended in a major disaster . Not the way you think , as dictators hand wave and have their defeats deleted from the official history . See , not even his sternest enemies talk about that . How supposedly he was the observer in a recon flight that covered every single Bulgarian HQ inside Thrace , camps , ammunition dumps , artillery positions duly recorded by him on a map . This he could do , because nobody knew jack about camouflage in those days and he had previously been flown in some French Army maneouvres in 1910 and was familiar with the then limited art of aerial observation . How he meticoulously prepared an attack . With an heavy heart , too , knowing very well that many of his troops would be dead by the end of the day . See , the Ottomans were cornered so an amphibious attack behind the Bulgarian lines at the doorstep of Istanbul was planned . Forcing a decisive battle on the Bulgarians , saving Edirne , advancing as far as Selanik , if possible defeating the Greeks and the Serbians one at a time , taking the Ottoman Europe back , Turkish for the last 5 centuries , stuff like that . And the flight took so long that the German mercenary pilot had to land the two seater by the light of torches lit , making it the first combat flight at night or something .
because von der Goltz , the "father" of the Turkish Army , had traded letters with Ottoman Sultans that Kemal could be made the Chief of Staff of the Ottoman Empire , once he matured out of chasing French chicks , the Ottoman HQ in Istanbul duly noted the flight and the amount of recce it did . Bulgarians of course claim diseases made it impossible for them to capture the city of Tzars so they moved elsewhere and that's why they were there , ready to shoot Kemal's offensive into pieces . Doubling their forces on location because they were planning to capture Gallipoli , not because of something else ... Because the Bulgarians were so ready to kill Turks , they had needed lots of time to be convinced that Mustafa Kemal would attack on that day . And because that the Ottoman HQ had spent so much time convincing the Bulgarians , they forgot to ready the ships to carry the troops to land . So the landings could not take place simultenously , so the attack of Kemal could be processed without much hassle by the Bulgarians . Cancelling the attack now made sense , by not risking thousands of lives ? You don't know jack about anything , Kemal could have claimed he was bound to fail without the diversion of the amphibious landing . Despite his attack being the diversion for the amphibious landing ; if positions had been reversed Enver would have done that . So , the landing did take place , some time later , right under the noses of victorious Bulgarians , for a repeat pasting . Fighting went on and Bulgarians decided they were cheated with their Christian brothers looting far more for much little cost ; so there was a second Balkan War . Kemal was like doomed to obscurity with Enver arriving with Cavalry to beat him to Edirne , and later having Kemal exiled to Sofia as the military attachee . Yes , people should have been shot , but they were like all classmates to Kemal and he had no political clout out of Ittihad . So that would have only created more chaos . To the detriment of the country . Enver further erred in having him back from Sofia as the Great War began and some clerical error went unnoticed ; assigning him to Gallipoli he knew so well instead of some forsaken command in Yemen , as had been agreed upon by the bigshots of the Ittihad . They were busy selling the country to the highest bidder , which turned out to be Germany . And the Germans didn't exactly need a man of Kemal's caliber in their future Arabian colonies ; he might have organized a rebellion or something there . You know , with a solid record in Libya against Italian Liberators . The error remained .
et cetera , et cetera , more et cetera ... Now it's 1920s . Greeks have come and gone . And they still blame us for the population exchange , you know , with their army trying to conduct a scorched earth policy in retreat and pulling the local Greeks with them , the "Christian conduct" of the Balkan Wars and the related ethnic cleansing being a mere decade old at the time . The Greek defeat brings Venizelos back and what does he want ? All the Greeks deported from Anatolia , except that City . Not only because he will be able to deport the Muslims off Greece but he is gaining a solid core of support . People uprooted from Anatolia because political opponents of Venizelos lost a Crusade there ... A thousand deaths a day for quite a while cuts their number to a more manageable level , too ... While keeping the political stuff up , right ? He even corrects an unsightly sight . Orthodox Christian Turks of central Anatolia , because if left here they would be proof that we monsters are not the monsters the European PR claims we are , intolerant savages bent on destruction of each and every Christian . Kemal once again saved people from being shot , after gaining solemn oaths from them on they would never utter Social Darwinist BS , not even in the sanctity of their homes . Sure enough , there was a Kurdish "Islamist" rebellion in the East , which the battle hardened army of the young Republic was like totally unable to contain . Musul and whatever oil wealth it contained went out of the window , alongside the Kurdish "autonomy" in return for opening their feudal existance to "Science" . You see , Kemal was proud to be a Turk , couldn't see how a guy wouldn't want to be . Schools and trains , education and economic / military ties to secure the area and let the dudes own whole 'ing factories instead of one or two villages ; real wealth instead of undisputed "right" to molest the women and having b_stards . You think it's an accident that a ringleader was this "Right Wing" Ittihadist scholar ?
having sent away the Greeks of all types with the justification of stopping the British using them as a 5th Column and sabotaged the multiparty democracy through the Kurdish rebellion , Ittihad was ready for a showdown with its rebellious progidious son , Kemal . Enver had been killed in Central Asia , Armenians had assasinated the remaining members of the trio that had ruled and ruined the Ottoman Empire . There was an attempt on Kemal's life , but without the trio , there was no one within Ittihad ranks that could "replace" Kemal . Nor there was any opposition to Kemal's Reforms . Everybody wanted to be a dictator and had long counted upon the idiocy of the population , seemingly always content for shows of piety in the Mosque . And removing other types of people would make it easier to impose the "law" ... No Muslim would be offended by the sight of Christian neighbours earning far more with an equal amount work , and question the leadership of the country on why they were not achieving as much . But the godless Bolshies were doing so good in Russia and people were awestruck by the prospects . Let Mustafa Kemal blaze a path and allow an incident and become the Stalin of Anatolia ... Better in the sense that you could drink and do all sorts of stuff instead of praying 5 times a day and even more when required . You really don't know how much the West has hated the Republic , for continious failures to roll over and die . They expect us losers praying all day long so that we will not "produce" and become a captive market and get a Crusade as soon as possible . Then , they are deceived by the enthuasism of their assets on the ground and let us become godless and their Crusade is to be a mite easier , especially when compared to 1915 . America hates this British failure right from the start and entire US policy ever since is to make us Muslims , 'cause we can't be ...
sure enough , Kemal keeps to his personal timetable and starts a second period of democracy right in 1930 . Hopeful by the prospects as the Wall Street Crash has taken some wind from the US and it seems to be getting worse . Makes his best pals join this new party , despite the misgivings of the pals themselves . Sure enough , some guy wants to cut his son's throat in a political rally . As a sacrifice to Allah , as a way of thanks that the "Muslims" will soon be saved from the godless tyranny . The best pals say "Well, screw them!" and Kemal has always been a realist . And yes , the worse is yet to come . Like being forced to emulate radical secularism of Europe with stuff . "Muslims" have given up their work to convince people that the Menemen rebellion was an anti-"Muslim" conspiracy where some young Lieutenant was beheaded ; they are much more vocal on the Disgrace of July 15th where apparently a cadet was beheaded and nobody ever like conducts investigations against heroes of Democracy .
as Europe inches closer to war and Turkey becoming ever more valuable as a partner for any side (thus becoming a bigger threat to the side that remains) the Tunceli issue becomes the issue . The guys have long been allies to the Kemalist regime , helping quite a bit to put down the Kurdish rebellion . It's the same thing , schools and roads and Kemal will personally oversee the education of the sons and grandsons of the notables of the area , just like the Sultans used to do , to let them to be valuable citizens , members of the Parliament by the strength of the votes of the province , President of the country if they are that good . The response was the same ; rebellion on claims that the soldiers had raped village women . And why the Alevis are so staunchly for the memory of Atatürk when ı would be extremely hard pressed to convince them that there were like no massacres ? Because Atatürk's Republic , at least theoretically , allows them to be anything they want to be . While every "Reformist" that bandies about the ills of the same tends to have some connection to the large scale murders of Alevis . To the extent that Tunceli had its own "one-province" Communist insurgency to be beaten down by some sort of alliance between the seperatists and the State . The Radical Left keeps accusing the State of being American puppets , but you won't see any particular insults against Kemal , the Great Revolutionary . Otherwise they would have to close shop , with like zero recruitment from the Alevis . Alevis are just people , they have honest people and they have scum people -but not in any different ratios compared to the rest of the country . Yet they tend to be always on the wrong side for the Americans for some unshakeable loyalty to Atatürk .
then the wars came . We in Turkey never hear that his first major command , of the troops in Gallipoli in 1912-3 , ended in a major disaster . Not the way you think , as dictators hand wave and have their defeats deleted from the official history . See , not even his sternest enemies talk about that . How supposedly he was the observer in a recon flight that covered every single Bulgarian HQ inside Thrace , camps , ammunition dumps , artillery positions duly recorded by him on a map . This he could do , because nobody knew jack about camouflage in those days and he had previously been flown in some French Army maneouvres in 1910 and was familiar with the then limited art of aerial observation . How he meticoulously prepared an attack . With an heavy heart , too , knowing very well that many of his troops would be dead by the end of the day . See , the Ottomans were cornered so an amphibious attack behind the Bulgarian lines at the doorstep of Istanbul was planned . Forcing a decisive battle on the Bulgarians , saving Edirne , advancing as far as Selanik , if possible defeating the Greeks and the Serbians one at a time , taking the Ottoman Europe back , Turkish for the last 5 centuries , stuff like that . And the flight took so long that the German mercenary pilot had to land the two seater by the light of torches lit , making it the first combat flight at night or something .
because von der Goltz , the "father" of the Turkish Army , had traded letters with Ottoman Sultans that Kemal could be made the Chief of Staff of the Ottoman Empire , once he matured out of chasing French chicks , the Ottoman HQ in Istanbul duly noted the flight and the amount of recce it did . Bulgarians of course claim diseases made it impossible for them to capture the city of Tzars so they moved elsewhere and that's why they were there , ready to shoot Kemal's offensive into pieces . Doubling their forces on location because they were planning to capture Gallipoli , not because of something else ... Because the Bulgarians were so ready to kill Turks , they had needed lots of time to be convinced that Mustafa Kemal would attack on that day . And because that the Ottoman HQ had spent so much time convincing the Bulgarians , they forgot to ready the ships to carry the troops to land . So the landings could not take place simultenously , so the attack of Kemal could be processed without much hassle by the Bulgarians . Cancelling the attack now made sense , by not risking thousands of lives ? You don't know jack about anything , Kemal could have claimed he was bound to fail without the diversion of the amphibious landing . Despite his attack being the diversion for the amphibious landing ; if positions had been reversed Enver would have done that . So , the landing did take place , some time later , right under the noses of victorious Bulgarians , for a repeat pasting . Fighting went on and Bulgarians decided they were cheated with their Christian brothers looting far more for much little cost ; so there was a second Balkan War . Kemal was like doomed to obscurity with Enver arriving with Cavalry to beat him to Edirne , and later having Kemal exiled to Sofia as the military attachee . Yes , people should have been shot , but they were like all classmates to Kemal and he had no political clout out of Ittihad . So that would have only created more chaos . To the detriment of the country . Enver further erred in having him back from Sofia as the Great War began and some clerical error went unnoticed ; assigning him to Gallipoli he knew so well instead of some forsaken command in Yemen , as had been agreed upon by the bigshots of the Ittihad . They were busy selling the country to the highest bidder , which turned out to be Germany . And the Germans didn't exactly need a man of Kemal's caliber in their future Arabian colonies ; he might have organized a rebellion or something there . You know , with a solid record in Libya against Italian Liberators . The error remained .
et cetera , et cetera , more et cetera ... Now it's 1920s . Greeks have come and gone . And they still blame us for the population exchange , you know , with their army trying to conduct a scorched earth policy in retreat and pulling the local Greeks with them , the "Christian conduct" of the Balkan Wars and the related ethnic cleansing being a mere decade old at the time . The Greek defeat brings Venizelos back and what does he want ? All the Greeks deported from Anatolia , except that City . Not only because he will be able to deport the Muslims off Greece but he is gaining a solid core of support . People uprooted from Anatolia because political opponents of Venizelos lost a Crusade there ... A thousand deaths a day for quite a while cuts their number to a more manageable level , too ... While keeping the political stuff up , right ? He even corrects an unsightly sight . Orthodox Christian Turks of central Anatolia , because if left here they would be proof that we monsters are not the monsters the European PR claims we are , intolerant savages bent on destruction of each and every Christian . Kemal once again saved people from being shot , after gaining solemn oaths from them on they would never utter Social Darwinist BS , not even in the sanctity of their homes . Sure enough , there was a Kurdish "Islamist" rebellion in the East , which the battle hardened army of the young Republic was like totally unable to contain . Musul and whatever oil wealth it contained went out of the window , alongside the Kurdish "autonomy" in return for opening their feudal existance to "Science" . You see , Kemal was proud to be a Turk , couldn't see how a guy wouldn't want to be . Schools and trains , education and economic / military ties to secure the area and let the dudes own whole 'ing factories instead of one or two villages ; real wealth instead of undisputed "right" to molest the women and having b_stards . You think it's an accident that a ringleader was this "Right Wing" Ittihadist scholar ?
having sent away the Greeks of all types with the justification of stopping the British using them as a 5th Column and sabotaged the multiparty democracy through the Kurdish rebellion , Ittihad was ready for a showdown with its rebellious progidious son , Kemal . Enver had been killed in Central Asia , Armenians had assasinated the remaining members of the trio that had ruled and ruined the Ottoman Empire . There was an attempt on Kemal's life , but without the trio , there was no one within Ittihad ranks that could "replace" Kemal . Nor there was any opposition to Kemal's Reforms . Everybody wanted to be a dictator and had long counted upon the idiocy of the population , seemingly always content for shows of piety in the Mosque . And removing other types of people would make it easier to impose the "law" ... No Muslim would be offended by the sight of Christian neighbours earning far more with an equal amount work , and question the leadership of the country on why they were not achieving as much . But the godless Bolshies were doing so good in Russia and people were awestruck by the prospects . Let Mustafa Kemal blaze a path and allow an incident and become the Stalin of Anatolia ... Better in the sense that you could drink and do all sorts of stuff instead of praying 5 times a day and even more when required . You really don't know how much the West has hated the Republic , for continious failures to roll over and die . They expect us losers praying all day long so that we will not "produce" and become a captive market and get a Crusade as soon as possible . Then , they are deceived by the enthuasism of their assets on the ground and let us become godless and their Crusade is to be a mite easier , especially when compared to 1915 . America hates this British failure right from the start and entire US policy ever since is to make us Muslims , 'cause we can't be ...
sure enough , Kemal keeps to his personal timetable and starts a second period of democracy right in 1930 . Hopeful by the prospects as the Wall Street Crash has taken some wind from the US and it seems to be getting worse . Makes his best pals join this new party , despite the misgivings of the pals themselves . Sure enough , some guy wants to cut his son's throat in a political rally . As a sacrifice to Allah , as a way of thanks that the "Muslims" will soon be saved from the godless tyranny . The best pals say "Well, screw them!" and Kemal has always been a realist . And yes , the worse is yet to come . Like being forced to emulate radical secularism of Europe with stuff . "Muslims" have given up their work to convince people that the Menemen rebellion was an anti-"Muslim" conspiracy where some young Lieutenant was beheaded ; they are much more vocal on the Disgrace of July 15th where apparently a cadet was beheaded and nobody ever like conducts investigations against heroes of Democracy .
as Europe inches closer to war and Turkey becoming ever more valuable as a partner for any side (thus becoming a bigger threat to the side that remains) the Tunceli issue becomes the issue . The guys have long been allies to the Kemalist regime , helping quite a bit to put down the Kurdish rebellion . It's the same thing , schools and roads and Kemal will personally oversee the education of the sons and grandsons of the notables of the area , just like the Sultans used to do , to let them to be valuable citizens , members of the Parliament by the strength of the votes of the province , President of the country if they are that good . The response was the same ; rebellion on claims that the soldiers had raped village women . And why the Alevis are so staunchly for the memory of Atatürk when ı would be extremely hard pressed to convince them that there were like no massacres ? Because Atatürk's Republic , at least theoretically , allows them to be anything they want to be . While every "Reformist" that bandies about the ills of the same tends to have some connection to the large scale murders of Alevis . To the extent that Tunceli had its own "one-province" Communist insurgency to be beaten down by some sort of alliance between the seperatists and the State . The Radical Left keeps accusing the State of being American puppets , but you won't see any particular insults against Kemal , the Great Revolutionary . Otherwise they would have to close shop , with like zero recruitment from the Alevis . Alevis are just people , they have honest people and they have scum people -but not in any different ratios compared to the rest of the country . Yet they tend to be always on the wrong side for the Americans for some unshakeable loyalty to Atatürk .