Sandwich Elimination Thread III

[Aiken_Drumn]

If anyone isn't familiar, every 24 hours you chose two items on the list- one you give a point to, and the other you take three points from.

Rules (as copied from another thread):
- You may vote roughly every 24 hours. You add one point to one city-state and take away three points from another.
- You must write a reason for each upvote and downvote.
- Delete the previous voters comments, and indicate your comments in some way (bold, italicize, colour, something that will draw attention)
- You may vote for the same thing multiple times


Cheese 10
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 10
Sausage 10
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 10
Tuna mayo 10
Chicken salad 10
Chicken mayo 10
Cheese and pickle 10

 

[SMcM]

Interesting thread...

Cheese 7 (10 - 3) Just cheese is a bit plain I suppose
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 10
Sausage 10
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 10
Tuna mayo 10
Chicken salad 10
Chicken mayo 10
Cheese and pickle 11 (10 + 1) Pickle is nice though

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 7
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 10
Sausage 10
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 7 more like may-oh-noes
Tuna mayo 10
Chicken salad 11 substantial with a bit of crunch
Chicken mayo 10
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Aiken_Drumn]

Cheese 7
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7 You don't make friend with sa-lad!
Sausage 11 Hot or cold its a treat!
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 7
Tuna mayo 10
Chicken salad 11
Chicken mayo 10
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Edmund Ironside]

Cheese 7
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 12 (11+1) But only if it is made with British sausages, no substitutes will suffice.
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 4 (7-3) Looks bad, smells bad, tastes bad.
Tuna mayo 10
Chicken salad 11
Chicken mayo 10
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 7
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 12
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 4
Tuna mayo 7 more like may-oh-noes
Chicken salad 12 don't be a chicken, eat some salad
Chicken mayo 10
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Aiken_Drumn]

Cheese 7
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 12
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 4
Tuna mayo 7
Chicken salad 9 Salad!?
Chicken mayo 11 Mayo?!
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 7
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 12
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 4
Tuna mayo 7
Chicken salad 10 get that green stuff
Chicken mayo 8 more like may-oh-noes
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Edmund Ironside]

Cheese 8 (7+1) Cheese makes all things better (American "cheese products" being the exception to this rule)
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 12
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 1 (4-3) This is the only option I would not let past my lips
Tuna mayo 7
Chicken salad 10
Chicken mayo 8
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 8
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 12
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise 1
Tuna mayo 7
Chicken salad 11 You won't be pallid if you eat your sallid
Chicken mayo 5 more like may-oh-noes
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Aiken_Drumn]

Cheese 8
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 13 Ooh BABY!
Cheese and onion 10
Egg mayonnaise
Tuna mayo 7
Chicken salad 11
Chicken mayo 5
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 8
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 13
Cheese and onion 10
Tuna mayo 4 more like may-oh-noes
Chicken salad 12 maybe there's a caterpillar for EXTRA PROTEIN
Chicken mayo 5
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Edmund Ironside]

Cheese 9 (8+1) So many great cheese to choose from, the permutations are endless..
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 13
Cheese and onion 10
Tuna mayo 4
Chicken salad 12
Chicken mayo 2 (5-3) Decidedly mediocre.
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 9
Ham and cheese 10
Ham salad 7
Sausage 13
Cheese and onion 10
Tuna mayo 1 more like may-oh-noes
Chicken salad 13 salad is about to "rocket" to the top
Chicken mayo 2
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Aiken_Drumn]

Cheese 9
Ham and cheese 11 A simple staple
Ham salad 7
Sausage 13
Cheese and onion 10
Tuna mayo
Chicken salad 13
Chicken mayo 2
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 9
Ham and cheese 11
Ham salad 7
Sausage 13
Cheese and onion 10
Chicken salad 14 time to "cress" the hill
Chicken mayo 0 more like may-oh-noes
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Aiken_Drumn]

How did we forget BLT from the list?!!?

 

[Aiken_Drumn]

Cheese 9
Ham and cheese 11
Ham salad 7
Sausage 14 Freud would be proud
Cheese and onion 10
Chicken salad 11 soggy lettuce
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Catharsis]

Cheese 9
Ham and cheese 8 more like cheese-oh-noes
Ham salad 7
Sausage 14
Cheese and onion 10
Chicken salad 12 crisp lettuce and succulent tomato slices
Cheese and pickle 11

 

[Edmund Ironside]

How did we forget BLT from the list?!!?

Because BLT is overpowered! To make it fair we would have to nerf it by removing at least 1 of the elements!

Cheese 10 (9+1) Because sometimes less is more.
Ham and cheese 8
Ham salad 7
Sausage 14
Cheese and onion 7 (10-3) Cheese & onion chips/crisps are great, but not sure how well it would really work in a sandwich.
Chicken salad 12
Cheese and pickle 11