jimmygeo said:
... I'll send comments later. For now: I got 200253 VPs, the last date was 293 BC and the Persians had only two small towns left.
As promised, here are at least some of my observations after playing 200 turns of (and winning) as Macedonia in a slightly modified form of version 1.22.
Frist, the changes I made. Added a section of road east of Abderea. Allowed Argyraspists and Hypaspists to enslave since historically Macedonia recurited much of their troops from conquered Balkan tribes and others, especially under Philip II, Alexander's father. Changed the linked alliances to Athens, Lacedemon & Ionia vs Persia & Phoenicia, and Rome vs. Carthage, as this is closer to the historical allignment for most of the period.
Now my comments and observations.
The time between turns is quite long, especially after ca. turn 100. I regularly went out and did something else for the ten or fifteen minutes it took. (Sometimes I stayed away longer, hence why it took me 86+ hours to win!). I doubt that anything can be done about this.
My VP win came too soon (293 BC/turn 200). VP level should probably be raised to 250 or 300K.
Hannon's Voyage should probably be made obsolete later (say, by Astrolab?) since by the time it's built 'Rostrum' will already be acquired.
The cost of city improvements, esp. temples and libraries, should be reduced ca. 10-20% since in new or conquered towns it takes a huge amount of time to build anything.
The Persians can build way too many immortals. As well as the pop. cost, the shield cost should be raised (60 is much too low).
The Romans still seem to be too powerful. To slow them down in the early game, the Early Rep. government should have forced rather than paid labor. Historically, Rome was not a threat to the major Hellenistic powers untill after the Second Punic War. To balance this, you could give Rome back some of the Legions they had in earlier versions. This would give them a fighting chance without becoming an early Italian 'steamroller'.
(I started another game using v. 1.23 and this seems better.)
jimmygeo