So let me see if I get this right: You don't like the game. You put it "on a shelf int he closet" (not a wise place to put your games) and are done playing. But you're not done complaining. You are still going to give your time to complaining, even though you're not giving any time to playing.
There are lots of places to talk about how you hate the game, but you are so ticked you even have to post in a thread titled "what's right" what you think is wrong. like you missed the other 30 threads on what's wrong with the game! Why not put the complaining on the shelf with the box. take deep normal breaths . . . it's just a game.
As for the tax rate being messed up -- don't pay taxes. Build a big warehouse extension and sell to europe. 50% less to Europe is better than a 51% tax.
You seem to have a bad attitude when it comes to people criticizing this game. Every criticism is either met with glib, sarcastic responses or "whoa calm down man just a game just a game."
As for the game, I did like the new pioneer interface. Constantly reequipping pioneers with tools kind of became a hassle. Additionally, the new combat system is a welcome change, especially since now combat is more than just crossing your fingers and hoping the caravel doesn't inexplicably sink your privateer.
I also like the Continental Congress. It's a neat idea, although I wish there was more emphasis on earning the points rather than just building them.