Like most people here, I have been an avid Civ player since Civ I, and I have to say Civ V is such an abomination compared to cIV BtS expansions, not to mention the worst of the series by far.
Actually, the polls show otherwise, most people really like Civ V, it's just that the whiners and complainers are more vocal than those of us who actually like this version.
I believe I can speak for the majority of the Civ players here regarding features that absolutely must be brought back to Civ V, hopefully in future patches or expansions. These features are so essential to the whole Civ experience that I am not sure why Firaxis removed them in this generation.
Says who? Who made you the authority on the Civ Community?
1. We want our stack back: 1UPT makes moving units around so tedious and it's hard to get into formations in battle.
Really? I find combat to be easier now, it takes a good strategy to take down a city instead of a stack of 20 swordsmen to face off against their stack of longbowmen with +75% city defense.
2. We want the old strategic resource system back: who came up with the idea that one iron mine can only generate one swordman? If I have an iron mine, I should be able to put it to use and build as many iron units as I want.
??? One iron mine can provide iron for as many as 12 units (if you use Russia), doesn't it seem MORE realistic to have limited resources rather than these magical spots that can provide a source of Iron for 4000 years?
3. We want our slider back: the ability to shift the macro focus of your empire to either wealth/science/happiness is more dynamic than the current system.
Everything is based on production now, which makes more sense. Science comes from population and improvements, not from taxes. Simply by changing my production focus in my cities I can shift from an empire that promotes happiness, science, commerce, production or growth quite easily.
4. We want local happiness back: CiV's global happiness system makes the game MUCH shallower, it's like playing a game for 10-year-olds.
Really? I think Global happiness makes more sense. An individual city can have negative happiness and still be upset, but now the happiness actually plays a role in your civilization, providing golden ages in a way that is more than just "use great person to start golden age" and "build Taj Majal to enter golden age".
5. No more purchasing units/buildings plz: it makes no sense to buy a building and it's suddenly there the next turn. Firaxis please remove this feature. Realistically, gold should haste the production process, but not producing things out of thin air.
HAVE YOU EVER PLAYED CIVILIZATION BEFORE? This happens in every version of the game.
Wow. You could even buy WONDERS in previous games. Clearly you're not very experienced at playing Civ.
6. We want religion back: religion is what makes cIV a much deeper game than all others in the series, including ciV. Why did they remove religion?
Religion was okay, but it was not really that realistic. I simply played every game in a race to found as many religions as possible to build their super building that would generate TONS of gold for me. Tell me, is Mecca an economic powerhouse? How about the Dai Miao? Has that made its region crazy rich? Clearly not, but that was generally the main point of religion. That and the religious wars.
7. Bring back the graphics of cIV: as many players have noted since the game's release, ciV's graphics is absolutely terrible. Rivers and trading posts are just plain ugly. It's just about on par with Civ III if you ask me.
The graphics are basically the same as Civ IV, not exactly terrible.
8. We want the old map grid back: sure, hexes are interesting at first glance and seems to make the game look complicated (reminds me of a boardgame), but after several games they begin to get on our nerves.
Again, "it's too hard for me!" Waaa! I really don't see much of a difference between hexes and squares and it doesn't make it any more difficult.
Firaxis, please pay more attention to what we the core Civ players really want. Until these problems have been fixed, I'll stick to my cIV.
They did. Core CIV players wanted modability and a game that could stack mods without becoming unstable. If you want stacks back, there's a mod for that. If you want religions, there's gonna be a mod for that. If you want unlimited resources, there's a mod for that. Stop whining and complaining, especially when some of your complaints show a MASSIVE amount of ignorance. Just play Civ IV or V and stop whining about it on these boards which are meant for constructive discussion.