Is the game as good as galciv II? I know it is kinda early to ask, but what are your overall impressions of the gameplay?
Well, most of the game is missing as you know. The AI is mentally handicapped heavily - it almost just sits waiting to die and while many features are present in appearance, they are not really "there". Like you can unlock components in the tech tree but there is no shipyard in the game yet so you unlock them in namesake only. It mostly plays like GalCiv2 which I take to basically mean they plan to pick up design "where they left off" with Gal Civ2. The graphics engine has been updated and all animated 3D models look better. (Still in 'Uncanny Valley' but much better)
The way they are reworking the tax spending is better than Gal Civ 2 IMO but it isn't a major improvement. Rather than clicking multiple sliders, its more of a click and drag function on a "golf ball" if that makes sense. The center of the "golf ball" is 33% - 33% - 33% spending in science, growth, and production.
In short, atm it plays like very very basic Gal Civ 2 with an improved UI, less cluttered (although archaic) tech tree. All of the other features, I wouldn't call features yet. I am actually waiting for an update or two before actually posting any feedback as everything that needed to be addressed, got addressed by the community within 24 hours on the forums.
There is no NDA but videos and screenshots seem murky. I love that Stardock is really stressing that this is an alpha and not a "pay to play early" type of deal like the Early Access games that have started to get abused lately from my perspective. The game currently isn't fun. I happen to have benefits for watching them develop it through the alpha- but those benefits certainly won't apply to most people. Right now, you are paying $100 for "not even a game". I also feel it is important to stress that and hope to see at least a 2-3 year development cycle. Right now, it "feels" like Gal CIv 2, which is good. Actually playing the Alpha makes me just want to play Gal Civ 2 again.
EDIT: Oh yeah and they use cell shading on the ship graphics which actually makes it look more awesome than I would have thought. I'll post a pic of one of the ships in a couple hours.
This feedback 'review' hits up almost everything worth talking about so far.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/0ibt1cbis5tucan/Initial Impression v0.0.1.0.pdf