Peace Theme Elimination Thread

[AW Arcaeca]

Arabia - 23
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 20
China - 21
Dutch - 24
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 18
Indonesia - 21
Japan - 17 - 3 = 14 Sounds to me like just any other stereotypically Asian theme with wooden flutes - maybe it's that being of European heritage makes so I can't tell the difference between two different wooden flutes - that never culminates to anything exciting. Also, to anyone else here who avidly plays civ4... listen to 3:57 to 4:04 and tell me if you notice anything... strange.
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 23 + 1 = 24 Because no else gives Poland any attention.
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 22

 

[NebuchadnezzarB]

Arabia - 24
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 20
China - 21
Dutch - 24
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 18
Indonesia - 21
Japan - 11
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 24
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 22

THIS THEME IS AMAZING. Fits perfectly with Arabia. Intimidating? A little I'll admit. Around the two minute mark, this theme just gets amped up in awesomeness by twelve. I LOVE the mixture of instruments. Screams, "Welcome to my kingdom. I'm making you jealous, aren't I?"

Relaxing, but boring after a couple minutes.

 

[kingfish101]

Arabia - 24
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 20+1=21
China - 21
Dutch - 24
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 18
Indonesia - 21
Japan - 11-3=8
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 24
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 22

Byzantium: The vocals give you this upvote.

Japan: NebuchadnezzarB is right.

 

[AW Arcaeca]

Arabia - 24
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 21
China - 21
Dutch - 24
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 18
Indonesia - 21
Japan - 8 - 3 = 5 So together we can wipe out Japan here and now
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 24 + 1 = 25 Because it's no longer leading, and not by a "ridiculous" amount that it totally deserved
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 22

 

[JonnasN]

Arabia - 24
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 21
China - 21
Dutch - 24
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 18+1=19
Indonesia - 21
Japan - 5
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 25
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 22-3=19

Greece's theme should be above 20, I think.

Pretty much the only reason I'm downvoting the Zulu theme is because it doesn't resonate with me as well as European or Middle Eastern sounds... Those are some really fine hairs I'm splitting.

 

[NebuchadnezzarB]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 21
China - 21
Dutch - 24
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 19
Indonesia - 21
Japan - 2
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 25
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 19

Sounds great the entire way through. The only peace theme that can compete with Sweden(my favourite).

Anyone wanna do the honours? In Canada it's ou by the way.

 

[TheBoulderite]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 21+1=22
China - 21
Dutch - 24
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 19
Indonesia - 21
Japan - 2-3=-1 ELIMINATED
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 25
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 19

Byzantium: MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEELIMA. 'Nuff said.

Japan: Sorry Japan, but this theme is the least of the best.

Japan lands 20th!

 

[joncnunn]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 21
Dutch - 25 Really nice sound.
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22
Greece - 19
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 25
Portugal - 17
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 16 I don't like this one compared to the others

 

[AW Arcaeca]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 21
Dutch - 25
England - 25
Ethiopia - 22 + 1 = 23 Because even though I'd love to give the point to Poland, it's apparently not allowed to get too far ahead :/ So going with my #2 choice.
Greece - 19
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 16
Persia - 18
Poland - 25
Portugal - 17 - 3 = 14 And lo and behold, after all this time... Portugal's theme still hasn't gotten any better.
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 26
Venice - 25
Zulu - 16

 

[joncnunn]

24 hours later and voting for my second most favorite & second least favorite remaining:

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 21
Dutch - 25
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 19
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 13 The sound just doesn't do much for me.
Persia - 18
Poland - 25
Portugal - 14
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden - 27 A really nice pleasing sound
Venice - 25
Zulu - 16

 

[Merciorum]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 21
Dutch - 25
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 13
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 13
Persia - 18
Poland - 25
Portugal - 15
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden -27
Venice - 25
Zulu - 16

Portugal: Not even a contest. It is objectively the best peace theme in the game. Sad, sorrowful, great.

Greece: As with the war theme, very bland.

 

[AW Arcaeca]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 21
Dutch - 25
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 13
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 13
Persia - 18
Poland - 25 + 1 = 26 This is going to be the best reason ever guys! Ready? Here goes... I like it.
Portugal - 15 - 3 = 12 Sad and sorrowful? Personally, I don't think that makes for a good piece.
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden -27
Venice - 25
Zulu - 16

 

[TheBoulderite]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 21
Dutch - 25
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 13
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 13-3=10
Persia - 18
Poland - 26
Portugal - 12+1=13
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden -27
Venice - 25
Zulu - 17

Portugal: Hey, don't go dissing Portugal like that.

Ottomans: I think they are the least of what remains.

 

[TheBoulderite]

Any predictions for the top 5? Here's mine.

1. Sweden
2. England
3. Dutch
4. Arabia
5. Poland

 

[AW Arcaeca]

Really? You don't think Venice will make it?
(Personally, I hope it doesn't, but that's a matter of personal taste)
Sadly Poland probably won't win, but in no particular order, I think realistically the top 5 will be:

1. Venice
2. Arabia
3. Dutch
4. Mongolia
5. Sweden

I love you Poland, but you're never going to make it with just one person's upvotes.
Not giving up though! Miracles happen!

 

[joncnunn]

Post Number 331 subtracted 6 points from Greece instead of 3

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 22 Should be higher than 21, so bumped to 22.
Dutch - 25
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 16 Corrected to what it should have been written as in post numbers 331 thru 333.
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 7 Called up Ottomans while at peace in my current game, still bland.
Persia - 18
Poland - 26
Portugal - 13
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden -27
Venice - 25
Zulu - 17

 

[TheBoulderite]

Oh, yeah! Forgot about that! I'd switch England out with Mongolia, since the Mongol theme is so much more awesome. Oh, and don't worry, Poland will likely make the top 10.

 

[kingfish101]

rabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 22
Dutch - 25
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 16
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 7-3=4
Persia - 18
Poland - 26
Portugal - 13
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden -27
Venice - 25+1=26
Zulu - 17

Venice: Venice will make it. It must.

Ottomans: Doesn't sound like the type of music I would listen to outside the game.

 

[joncnunn]

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 22
Dutch - 26 Really nice, so gets the upvote.
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 13 Yes, this is bland by comparison to just about everything else on the list.
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 4
Persia - 18
Poland - 26
Portugal - 13
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden -27
Venice - 26
Zulu - 17

 

[NebuchadnezzarB]

Guess who I'm voting for! Not Arabia for once!

Arabia - 25
Assyria - 18
Byzantium - 22
China - 22
Dutch - 26
England - 25
Ethiopia - 23
Greece - 13
Indonesia - 21
Mongolia - 26
Ottomans - 1
Persia - 19
Poland - 26
Portugal - 13
Shoshone - 23
Spain - 26
Sweden -27
Venice - 26
Zulu - 17

Persia's war theme is amazing. One of my top ten. Persia's peace theme on the other hand, holy crap. I don't know why I like this theme so much, it just fits and sounds awesome and grand.

While Ceddin Deden is pretty awesome, this is just the worst theme left. Sort of.