Vicevirtuoso
The Modetta Man
Very interested to see the new direction you're taking the Madoka modpack, especially now as I'm partway through watching the anime series myself (been on my "to watch" list for a while, but your mod reminded me to get it ). Those new icons look good!
Good to hear! It's a bit bittersweet when I hear people say that my mod drove people to watch the show. On the one hand, it makes me feel like I did a great job on the mod, and have gotten people to experience what happens to be my favorite anime. Hell, my favorite work of fiction, if I may be honest. But on the other hand, the mod is chock-full of spoilers, so if this was your first exposure to it, you basically already know everything that happens, which probably will affect your enjoyment of the show.
A few things to point out though, it would be cool if Mami's guns poked out of her frame slightly as well, and Kyouko's weapon being cut off is slightly strange.
The funny thing about Kyouko's spear is that cutting its tip off is exactly what they did in the art piece I used to make the icon. Not exactly sure why.
For Mami, her guns stuck way too far out of the frame to make them fit -- they were poking into her Civilization icon! So for them to pop out of the frame, I'd end up erasing half of the guns and leaving the other half intact. While the idea of Mami using sawed-off versions of her muskets is pretty amusing, it would probably still look weird.