My two cents:
1939 Scenario
- Costs: technology, building and unit costs are way too high
-- Time: 1 week = 1 turn would fit to current costs
- Victory conditions: create different unique and historical victory conditions for each nation/team. You can ask Rhye about this. It was insane to achieve diplomatic victory in August '42 while playing Germany, score almost 1 Million.
- Nations and alliances: please create more civs. This Nation League thing is horrible. At least Spain, Greece, Turkey, Norway, Finland, Sweden, Denmark, Netherlands, Switzerland, Romania, Bulgaria, Yugoslawia, Egypt and Iraque are needed. Iraque and Egypt as vassals of Britain. Create preassigned alliances like Britain/France/Greece and later after the fall of Paris remove France and add Poland and also create Germany/Italy/Romania. After the fall of Paris France should become a german vassal and all french european cities should become german. Beirut should from now on attend to Free France, which is just added in-game as a new civ. Paasky handled that well in his mod. Same for fall of England.
- Cities: Please rework the buildings in cities. Preset factories and everything that has already been built that time. I think every city needs rework. You cannot go to war while building up your basic infrastructure.
- Additional wonders: What about event triggered wonders like the "Atlantikwall" or the "Ostwall"? Just like the great wall. If certain cities are captured the buildings will be available. A WWII style border defence line was published some days ago in the graphics section.
- Backgrounds: the images are great! But it is weird to look at some screens, because the information gets lost. All backgrounds in black and white would also look very nice. Also the blue interface colour doesn't fit to the mod.
- Remove or change United Nations. An agreement not to built nuclear weapons in 1940 makes no sense, remove diplomatic victory
- Mussolini: He has some red spots on his head
- Russian Waffen SS??? How come? I got attacked by those!?
- Infantry IV in many neutral cities just in the beginning? Impossible to conquer.
- Make USA stay neutral until '41 or certain events.
- Gibraltar was under american control
- Germany has no state religion in the beginning
- Germany should have Blitzkrieg in the beginning, when I researched this tech, the whole war was just over.
- Fill empty places on map with cities (Turkey, Iraque, East Russia, Finland), settlers founded way too many new cities.
- Weird promotions for preset units. They just have proms which same later built units cannot get.
- Settler in central Germany cannot build Wolfsburg due to minimum distance to other cities.
- Please find a german translator!!
- So much for now
Anyways great start for a mod with great potential!!
New graphics, buildings and units are just amazing!!