Any tips on DV editing?

CrackedCrystal

Where am I?
Joined
Dec 9, 2002
Messages
1,007
I decided to dive into the Digital Video editing realm. I am very much a newbie in this area as networking is my specialty. Hopefully, I can transfer my VHS to DVD (I just bought a burner). I was wondering if anyone has any tips on the matter.

Also, it would be great if someone could give me a link to a place I can download an uncompressed DV video at DVD quality. As I understand, that is 720x480 resolution? Yes, I know that they are around 220 MB/minute but a 5 second clip would be just fine. I would like to get some practice with my software before my DV encoder arrives through the mail on Monday. The closest I have found is Dolby Digital trailers already encoded. That's nice, but most of the work has already been done on those.
 
Thanks for posting Plutonium, but I found that site a few days ago. It is an awesome site.

I have a DC-100 Analog to DV coverter that connects via firewire. Windows essientally thinks it is a digital video camera. I am extremely happy with it. I have made 2 DVDs and 3 SVCDs so far. Its alot of fun. But, boy does it hurt the pocketbook. :(
 
I can imagine how much that must cost!

How is the editing going?
 
Its going great. My first goal is to transfer all my recoded episodes of the short-lived live action series "The Tick" to DVD. Anyone remember that show on Fox a few years back staring Patrick Warburton? There were only 8 episodes before it was cancelled. I have all 8 on VHS.

So far I have two episodes recorded in DV format (i.e on my computer). I still need to go through and edit such as cutting out the commercials, and running video filters to clean the images. Then encode the movies. I have come into a storage problem though and have ordered another hard drive to compensate. DVD quality video takes about 200 MB/minute of disk space before you encode it.

I am still in the learning phases right now. But I am becoming better. The process is much more complex and time consuming then I imagined. It take about 2 days (around 8 man-hours) to author and create a disk from the moment you start recording til you have the finished product. Most of it is waiting for your computer though (as I said, these are HUGE files), so you can grab a bite to eat or whatever.

So far I have made the following creations...

Video CDs:
- A commercial my company produced for a road show (it was a computer file I transferred to a video CD)
- A pair of music videos with a simple text only menu selection
- A copy of one of my favorite Saturday Night Live sketches I recorded from TV

DVDs:
- Transferred a movie I bought on VHS, compete with scene selection menu. A DVD version has not been produced so I had to make my own.
- A sample disk to test which encoding programs did the best job before I bought the full versions. Its the same scene encoded 7 different ways.

As for the cost, I went with low-end professional quality products so there are cheaper routes, but it was as follows.

DV-100 converter $260
DVD burner $220
Firewire card $30
3' High-quality video cable $8
Software $120
2 DVD-RW $13
10 DVD-R $18

Except for the DVD burner (I wish I got a DVD+RW instead of a DVD-RW because media is more readily available) I am happy with the purchases. The great part is that the re-writable DVDs are playable in set top DVD players. So, you can create a disk, fine tune it, write again, and repeat until its just right. Then you burn your final version to a write-once disk. That saves a lot of money since disks are expensive.

If anyone else is thinking about picking this up as a hobby, its very fun. You don't need to spend as much as I did either. If you don't need 2 hours per disk and are happy with about 40 minutes per disk (and a little loss of quality), you can burn to normal CD-Rs that play in set top DVD players. Thus you skip a large chunk of what I paid for. And you can get a cheeper converter as well. In fact, if you have a digital video camera (not a web cam though) most models will convert for you and you won't need to buy that either.
 
WoW!

The most I've done is transferred old videos to DVDs, and done some minor cleaning up of them :)
 
Originally posted by gonzo_for_civ
WoW!

The most I've done is transferred old videos to DVDs, and done some minor cleaning up of them :)

Yeah, I am going all out ;) I hope to have all my VHS videos on DVD or CD within a few months (there are a lot).

I am also thinking about scanning some family photos and making a video collage with music. But that will be some time off. We will have to see how things go.
 
Hehehe, I know I could get away without getting the software but before I even think of getting the DVD hardware I need to upgrade from my 17inch monitor. Thinking a nice 19inch Sony for $310 or might splurge and get the 22 for $600......decisions decisions. ;)

The most I have done is making VCDs (the lack of DVD burner limits me to CDs). I used Nero for that and it was pretty much a no-brainer. Drag and drop the video, in the correct format, and it burnt away.

What software are you using CC? What brand/model of DVD burner did you get?

Also, www.vcdhelp.com has some info on video editing.
 
I use Pinnacle Studio 8 for the editing and capturing (found it on sale for $20 down from $99 :) ). Then I send it over to TMPGEnc for encoding to MPEG2 and for cleanup of noice created from being a VHS source. Then I import the files created into Dazzle Complete for menu creation and other DVD features. I then burn it to DVD with Dazzle Complete.

I will occationally use Ulead VideoStudio 6 (it came with the Firewire card) for a little editing as well. It has a few filters that Pinnacle Studio does not have. But for the most part I stick with Pinnacle.

I have a Pioneer-105 for my DVD burner. It was on sale. I think I may have been happier with the Sony DRU-500A which supports both DVD formats, but mine is good and much cheeper. The cheeper part was my deciding factor.

EDIT: I have used Nero before making test CDs, it works pretty well at making VCDs and SVCDs. But unless you buy the add-on, it won't encode it. Since I already have other programs that do that, and burn the disk as well, I don't use Nero except for data DVDs.
 
Back
Top Bottom