Best Knight Replacement?

[ShahJahanII]

Which of the replacements for the knight is best?

 

[Louis XXIV]

Mandekalu?

 

[ShahJahanII]

Mandekalu?

shoot
forgot that
could we get a moderator to add Mandekalu Cavalry to the poll?

 

[The_J]

PMing one is far more effective than saying it just in the thread...

Moderator Action: Option added.
Note: That poll is public, if anyone would like to get his vote moved, then you have to know that the name will stay at the old option and can't be moved.

 

[Babri]

Keshlik => Win

 

[Aspon]

you have to consider the nations they belong to if i had to choose between the keshik and the camel archer yes i would take the keshik but I think I would much rather have Arabias UA as its a very efficient and powerful UA if played right. and I don't think the keshik has enough of an edge on the camel archer to compensate for this theres not much in it to begin with. hence I voted for the Camel archer.

 

[nnja]

On its own the keshiks is best/most fun knight replacement, though i have great memories of the camel archers bailing me out as i was trying to buy the world with my piles of gold. If you consider the khans+keshiks its not even fair. I mean, every one of my keshiks has always had a khan or two behind it.....

 

[Vo01985]

Keshik hands down. Best UU in the game. Camel Archers are great too.

 

[Zenstrive]

Camel Archers of course. Mobile Artillery of the medieval wartime!

 

[Babri]

you have to consider the nations they belong to if i had to choose between the keshik and the camel archer yes i would take the keshik but I think I would much rather have Arabias UA as its a very efficient and powerful UA if played right. and I don't think the keshik has enough of an edge on the camel archer to compensate for this theres not much in it to begin with. hence I voted for the Camel archer.

Sorry but the OP is talking ONLY about Knight UUs not about civs having knight UUs. BTW if u compare Keshliks & Camel Archers including their other UAs etc then Keshlik is even more powerful as it gets 5:c5move: (+1 from from UA ) & faster healing (from Khan).

 

[Becomedeath]

Keshik FTW!

Although with all of these, I always feel that the removal of the Knight is a sad loss. Not that I'm complaining when I'm raining arrows down on people at 5 moves a turn, but there is something comforting in having Knights about.

 

[Louis XXIV]

I haven't really used Keshiks yet, but speaking for Camel Archers, I love their ranged attack, but I do miss the ability to kill of units every so often.

 

[Hasire]

you have to consider the nations they belong to if i had to choose between the keshik and the camel archer yes i would take the keshik but I think I would much rather have Arabias UA as its a very efficient and powerful UA if played right. and I don't think the keshik has enough of an edge on the camel archer to compensate for this theres not much in it to begin with. hence I voted for the Camel archer.

Arabian UA is terrible.