Better to automate workers or micromanage?

TyranusBonehead

Bound & Determined
Joined
Feb 7, 2005
Messages
812
Location
Somewhere with a good book
I've just started playing Civilization recently, starting with CivIII and now messing around some with Conquests. I think I'm a long way from understanding what it takes to win, but I had a general question regarding workers. Right now, I like to automate practically all my workers so they do what needs to be done on their own. Is this a good practice or should I micromanage them, which will force me to keep better tabs on what they're doing? Thanks :king:
 
Welcome to CFC Tyranus!

Automate for pollution only. You'll be able to maximize production by doing the worker actions manually. Irrigate bonus food.
 
Never automate, unless you have improved your lands so much that your workers cannot mess it up, you need to keep your workers from destroying your lands.
 
Tomoyo said:
Never automate, unless you have improved your lands so much that your workers cannot mess it up, you need to keep your workers from destroying your lands.

then use automate without overriding previous improvements. Preferably as said use only automate clean polution. Even that i prefer to do myself though, when i have railroads, i normally just move a big stack of workers around, press the needed buttons to do a job until enough workers are doing it to do it in 1 turn then move to the next job. The AI will spread the workers around for multiple jobs.

NOTE: while it is more efficient to stack your workers when you have railroads and if you do it with some care also when you have roads already on the tiles to work, stacking workers when working unroaded tiles is inefficient since then multiple workers must waste a move.

Since i see many people around on this forum who still do not understand this, i will explain it once more and also the real impact it makes:

suppose you have 2 workers in a city and you have 2 tiles to irrigate:
NOT STACK:
1 move both to different tiles.
2 both irrigate turn1
3 irri 2
4 irri 3
5 irri 4

STACK:
1 move both to tile one
2 irrigate 1
3 irrigate 2
4 move both to tile two
5 irrigate 1
6 irrigate2

Now the cost of it:
A worker is about half the cost of a settler. Little less in shields, but food is the real cost of these units so i calculate half.
If you think you can't compare it like this for the matter i am going to: If it would be worth less than half a settler, you wouldn't build any and build only settlers instead since cost IS half.

A settler = a city.

so 1 worker turn = 1/2 city turn.

With the example i gave, 2 workers were working 1 turn longer. so that is 2 worker turns = 1 city turn.

So you payed 1 cities full production (food + shields + gold) by stacking teh workers on that 1 job.
 
A note on auto workers.

If yo umust use them, automate them using Shift-A, rather than just A, Shift-A will automate them without changing any improvements you have already made.

If, later in the game, you just automate them, they will waste time irrigating over mines and mining over irrigation, just to make pretty patterns.

As a rule, just dont bother automating them until you have 200+ of them.
 
My friend has a good automation sytem. Where he's expanding cities, he's automating workers for trade, so they build roads to his cities. In his major metropolitan area, he has the workers either at automate without changing, or at manual.

I always use manual, even if I get hundreds of wrokers. I don't trust automation.
 
I only automate to clear pollution and to clear jungle (Civ3-PTW). Else, I'm always finding them doing things I don't want. I do find the 'road-to' and 'railroad-to' options handy though.
 
Welcome to CFC, kaelas! [party]

One more note: Automated workers are cowards; they flee from no danger.
 
They prefer to run in a non-defended city that behind a warrior. So you lose worker and get your city pillaged at the same time.
 
I automated one the other day and it started chopping down the forest near one of my cities. never again will I automate. the city in question had more then enough food without clearing the forest square and the shields per turn from the forest were important in that city
 
Back
Top Bottom