Falcon02
General
ice2k4 said:I disagree, what if a nation asks us to stop trading with a certain civ. If your really playing a good civ game, you dont go on your first instinct to deny the request. Many a times I find it extremely beneficial to stop trading. This is also not something you can deny and go back to later, without repercussions. Diplomatically you lose -1 with the requesting civ. You cant save the game either with the diplo screen open. I think that the Foreign Adviser if present should decide and allow input from citizens. If the Adviser is absent from turnchat then the citizens who took time out of their schedule to attend should be able to vote and discuss such an unexpected decision.
To a certain extent some of these things can be handled in the forums.
However, practically speaking you can't anticipate everything the game forces you to decide right then and there. And as Ice suggests this is one reason why turnchats are valuable.
Would you rather a DP go with his instinct and find out later there was something he missed when he made that decision. Or would you rather the DP ask the people who are available for advice, so that they can point out the thread he missed, or point out the strategic implication he missed.
"Rome Demands you stop Trading with China!"
"Okay, public polls show China is low on our favorite list, and we want to stay friendly with Ceaser, so sure we'll stop"
~agree~
"You have lost your sole source of Iron"
"WHAT!?!?!"
This may be an extreme scenario, but fact of the matter is it's easy to miss a single post or forget a single fact when making such decisions. And a Foreign Advisor can't include all possible demands in their instructions.
Gonna have an instruction for every leader, ever tech, ever amount of gold, every "stop trading with" scenario?
You can try but I doubt you could cover them all and still enjoy the job.
Also, any comments on my "preliminary turnchat guidlines"? I guess the clarification for details on "Un-pausable game events" might be in order, though honestly I think they're fairly well covered in the current draft.