What is the Penalty for Defying a Resolution?

[bardolph]

What is the Penalty for Defying a Resolution?

 

[Navarre]

-5 happiness for a while in each town (each town with the religion in question for the AP ?).

 

[Defiant47]

Massive growing unhappiness in each city

 

[illram]

I believe the 5 unhappy faces last 20 turns on Normal speed. Only occurs in cities with the religion of the AP, but UN resolutions are empire-wide.

 

[KaytieKat]

Hi

I think in defying AP resolutions your civ also loses the hammer bonus for religious buildings that are of the AP religion in addition to happiness hit to any cities that have the AP religion.

For defying UN resolutions it is unhappiness hit in all your cities.

Kaytie

 

[Lord_Zath]

Yeah found that out the hard way the other night.

What's the bonus to defying a resolution?

 

[Defiant47]

Yeah found that out the hard way the other night.

What's the bonus to defying a resolution?

Freedom from having to deal with it being passed, in case it is passed. Note that you cannot in game mechanics defy a resolution after it in case it has passed.

 

[Ad Hoc]

and not forgetting the diplo hit.... the world considers you a villain

 

[GIO888]

Same as in the real world - nothing that makes you alter your selfish Nationalistic behavior!!!

 

[Craterus22]

and not forgetting the diplo hit.... the world considers you a villain

Really? I played a game where I was defying ap resolutions left and right. I didn't see an extra negative when I moused over leaders.

I had to defy at least 4 resolutions in my last game and it didn't seem (meaning I didn't see any reluctance to trade or unusual war declarations) to add any hostility.

It seems like when you defy a resolution - you should immediately be put in a state of war with anyone that voted yes to the resolution.

 

[Arksa]

Thank god there's a Defy resolution- option.
One election was "Enviromentalism for global civic". I had 2 corporations and huge coastal income through trade with portugal. First I just pressed "no" and then they elected Envm. and my economy collapsed (had to keep science 10% to survive).

 

[lutzj]

don't forget the non-proliferation treaty...

 

[jujubean]

your people will think u r evil and hate u

 

[mice]

You can completely get away with it if your cities dont have the AP religion as was said. It makes theocracy a good option if you're playing continents and the AP is on the other side. (except the diplo hit as Ad Hoc said)

 

[KrikkitTwo]

You only get the diplo hit if it would have passed (more Yes than No/Defy)

 

[AfterShafter]

don't forget the non-proliferation treaty...

Let's face it - if you're defying that one, the world was going to end up hating your guts anyways, so you may as well scratch the diplo hit from defiance.