WLTxD benefits formula?

iguana1

Chieftain
Joined
Nov 15, 2002
Messages
81
In my current game, I have a fairly happy society and have access at most times to 5-7 luxuries either by rights or thru trade. Depending on the number of luxuries and my luxury tax rate, I can get and keep virtually all cities in a WLTxD state. After one turn when I lost 2 luxury trade deals without the option to renew the deal, I got to thinking that I no longer know what the true value of a WLTxD is.

In the "good old days" it used to be easy to determine the opportunity cost of getting to a WLTxD state (monarchy gave you extra trade like a republic/democracy, rep/demo gave you one city growth per turn, etc). Last night I realized that I don't know exactly what I gain by getting to a WLTxD state and thus could not really determine if it was truly worth it to give the Greeks the 600+ gold they wanted for their precious spices, if I should just bump the luxury slide up a couple notches or if I was best served to just let my people be mostly happy without all the celebrations since I am playing a reletively peaceful game with a moderate sized perfectionist nation with rather limited corruption/waste in a republic.

I know there are a lot of very intelligent people on here that have broken down every last scrap of detail about this game. Can someone point me to a thread/FAQ/site that lists the actual, measurable effects of a WLTKD? I looked thru quite a few of the help docs on this site and searched the forums for something with this. Sp far all I have found is a couple of things saying it "lowers corruption" or "reduces waste". I know that from the manual. What I really want a list of actual (measurable) benefits per government, if still applicable, for WLTxD so that I can determine the opportunity cost of giving away my precious gold and/or losing revenue/science in exchange for luxury taxes.
 
The thread you want to read is alexman's treatise here:
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=19922

If you have C3C, it's changed a bit. Look here:
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=76619

Either way, in general, my opinion is that WLTxD is rarely worth it. Empire-wide, it's mostly a waste. In the occasional city, with entertainers instead of other specialists, it is worth it. Nearly nobody buys luxes to get WLTxD for in-game, help-you-win effects. The costs almost always overshadow the gains. The articles will let you figure exactly how much gain you can get with WLTxD

Arathorn
 
To summarize the results from alexman's findings, WLTKD reduces waste (i.e. shield loss) in that city, but not corruption (commerce lost). The effects of WLTKD are the same as a courthouse or police station, just for waste.
 
Back
Top Bottom