Can this forum be made public?

[Matrix]

Some people from other teams are asking for this forum to be made public. Are there any objections to that?

If the majority does not object that still doesn't mean it actually will become public. That's Thunderfall's call. This is just an informative poll...

 

[RegentMan]

I don't object. I wanted the MSDG forum to become public too and hope that the ISDG forum doesn't suffer the same fate. Let the civ world know our history!

 

[Ginger_Ale]

Sorry, I meant "Yes" be public as in "No, I don't object". Weird double negatives. Switch my vote please Matrix.

 

[Rik Meleet]

Sorry, I meant "Yes" be public as in "No, I don't object". Weird double negatives. Switch my vote please Matrix.

Matrix isn't the mod here ....
I'll switch it to "No - I don't object".

Moderator Action: GA's vote switched

 

[Rik Meleet]

I have my reservations in opening the thread.
On 1 side of it: We have nothing to hide and I'd love to show the Civ-world how C3B is an untrustworthy team and show their lies.
On the other side: CGN and CDZ got penalised after the game for the upcoming game. Who knows what someone may find on our forum that penalises CFC in future games ?

I'll withhold my vote for now.

 

[RegentMan]

On the other side: CGN and CDZ got penalised after the game for the upcoming game. Who knows what someone may find on our forum that penalises CFC in future games ?

My interpretation of FortyJ's ruling was that the sentence was already carried out. It would seem kind of cheap that a team could be punished for an action they did in the previous game. I would protest any such action taken against any team (except C3B perhaps ). Besides, I think CFC's nose is clean.

Having now had the opportunity to dwell on this issue more deeply and to discuss it more thoroughly, we have decided that CGN and CDZ shall be forced to skip 3 turns each. This punishment shall be enforced immediately, but will only apply to the preliminary round of games. As the finalists from this game are already determined, this punishment will therefore be considered already carried out.

 

[akots]

Sure, lets open it. At least if nobody comes and reads it, we can always say that they should had come and read.

There is little to hide here and even if we did something wrong, it is OK.

On the positive side, I'm sure nobody will come and read. Who cares...

 

[GenMarshall]

I dont object to having this forum being made public.

 

[classical_hero]

I would prefer that we do not air our dirty linen in front of every one else. That what was meant to be private and private it should remain.

 

[Provolution]

Get out the Dirty Linen, that would clean the air and remove some external suspicions.

 

[Hygro]

Yes, I object classical_hero, Ginger_Ale, Nobody 2 20.00%

Anyone else notice 3 votes against but only 2 recorded?

Maybe Nobody really is.... nobody!

 

[Ginger_Ale]

I switched my vote, as I was confused by the wording of the double negative.

The count (2) is right. Counting the names one by one does not work.

 

[Emp.Napoleon]

Only if we can get the C3B intellegence threads deleted or hidden, I don't want C3B or anyone to know what I was doing.

 

[akots]

... I don't want C3B or anyone to know what I was doing.

You would have to face it sooner or later anyhow. Better sooner. Besides, Joker knew. How do you know he did not tell anyone?

 

[Rik Meleet]

Only if we can get the C3B intellegence threads deleted or hidden, I don't want C3B or anyone to know what I was doing.

post links of the threads / posts you want deleted and I'll take a look at it.

 

[Hygro]

please don't delete them

 

[Matrix]

Only if we can get the C3B intellegence threads deleted or hidden, I don't want C3B or anyone to know what I was doing.

It's especially things like this that makes it so much fun to let them read this! Although Joker might indeed have said something about this, I think The Cat will bash her head once she notices how much info she gave away.

 

[Goonie]

If we're going to open it, open them all. Don't deleted ANYTHING.

With that said, where the hell is the abstain option?

 

[RegentMan]

Yes, please do not delete any thread, post, etc. It's like deleting history; we mustn't do that.

 

[Matrix]

With that said, where the hell is the abstain option?

If you abstain it means you do not object.

This is not a poll where the majority decides, because if just one person comes up with a serious personal objection (though just one would have to be very serious) it might not become open.