After playing this game for a day I have the following opinions
Pros:
-The best houses need about 32 resources to elevate themselves which adds the greatest space management challenges in a Civ builder game yet.
- Researching is a great addition to this genre
- Work time/free time is a more realistic feature in that when the sim is working, he/she cannot pick up goods.
- Each house tracks its members. It starts out with 1 man. Then he gets married. Then they have kids and in the top echelon, they start getting slaves. These other sims can handle the resource pickups while the man is at work.
- There is a green sphere of influence that shows you who can reach a certain resource building. This is better than the tile estimations you had to do for Caesar/Pharoah/Zeus.
- Seeing inside structures is interesting. There is a lot of neat animation but so far, I think it's only used to see if your worker is idling. However, rotating the camera can only be done horizontally. Therefore no overhead view and most of the times, the walls will block 50% of your view into the building.
Cons:
- I found a bug already in the 3rd City of the scenario. You can click on a building to get details. However, it is not synched up during this mission. You actually need to click an inch next to the structure in order to get the popup. I didn't notice this bug in the sandbox mode or the first two missions.
- GUI is huge even playing at the highest resolution. I guess I'm used to the Civ4 text/icons.
- You have to customize anti-aliasing through the nVidia/ATI panel. It should have been in the options.
- The 6 god's temples look exactly the same except they use Mortal Kombat coloring. They don't seem to do anything different; it's just that houses need access to different temples in order to advance.
- NIMBY is not in the game. Aesthetics is calculated globally meaning I can put gardens in one corner of the map and houses on the other side and it still effects happiness. Putting houses next to your warehouses does not both people either like in the Impression games. It actually is beneficial because that is where your people retrieve their goods.
This game seems very different from the Impression games so I suggest you wait for the demo if you can only get this or Caesar 4 and not both. Caesar 4 looks graphically superior and it may appeal more to those of you who liked how Impression/Tilted Mill did things.