Moo3 too good to pass up. I think the answer is no. It has many flaws, some of which can be over come or corrected with the patch and some of the user mods. You can further tweak a few things to your taste with little effort.
I just put in another long attempt to like this game, but only moved from my original it sucks to it is not terrible. IF you do get it, make sure it is cheap, go to the Atari site and gets some of the mods and read some of the threads.
I will say I did enjoy the space combat, but that is not enough to recommend the game to others. It is also a very complex learning curve game.