Struggle For A New China : Liu Bang vs Xiang Yu

Knight-Dragon

Unhidden Dragon
Retired Moderator
Joined
Jun 25, 2001
Messages
19,961
Location
Singapore
In 221 BCE, King Zheng of Qin unified the Chinese states by force, and proclaimed the founding of the Empire of Ten Thousand Years. Renaming himself as Shi Huangdi, the First Emperor, under advise, expanded the Qin Legalist-oriented administration all over the Empire. The Chinese script, coinage, weights, cart-widths, measurements etc were standardized across the Empire, ensuring a unified China for ages to come. Particularly the draconian Qin laws were implemented and enforced thru out the Empire.

The simple hardy people of Qin proper were able to endure the draconian laws, due to the contingencies of inter-state warfare and threats of barbarian attacks from all directions. However, for the more sophisticated elites and peoples of the other Chinese states, the laws of Qin were impossible. Discontent was rife, and only awaited a proper opportunity to be ignited.

In 209 BCE, a year after the death of Shi Huangdi, a farmhand named Chen Sheng rebelled. Though this rebellion in itself was quickly suppressed by the Qin army, it signalled the beginning of a general Empire-wide rebellion against Qin imperial authority, by original people, and former royalists and aristocrats alike.

One of the more organized of these diseparate rebellions was by Xiang Liang, and Xiang Yu, his nephew, in the former state of Chu. Xiang Liang enthroned a descendant of the former King of Chu, and won a series of victories against the Qin. But he grew over-confident and was killed in one battle.

Then, the former kingdom of Zhao was under heavy attack by the Qin armies and requested for aid from other rebel forces. The King of Chu dispatched an army to aid them, with Xiang Yu as second commander. But the army didn't move as the commander awaited his chance. Xiang Yu, ever rash and impatient, killed him and took over the command. Nobody objected as he was the paramount warrior of the age. Having no choice, the King of Chu confirmed his new position as commander of the Chu army.

The anti-Qin rebel forces all converged on Zhao, to battle the formidable Qin armies. The Chu army, led by Xiang Yu, was at the very forefront, and won a whole series of victories against the Qin. By general acclaim, he was acknowledged as the leader of the anti-Qin forces. In the meantime, the great Qin general, Zhang Nan, was forced to retreat repeatedly. Back in Xianyang, the imperial capital, the power behind the throne, the eunuch Zhao Gao, began to plot against the general, whom he feared because of his military ability.

Fearing for his safety, Zhang Nan surrendered, along with 200000 of his troops, to Xiang Yu. Many of the anti-Qin rebels had suffered great hardship at the hands of the soldiers of Qin, as labourers, commoners etc. During the night, they slaughtered the 200000 men of Qin while they slept, with the tacit approval of their commander, Xiang Yu, except for Zhang Nan and his immediate associates. The anti-Qin forces were victorious and the days of Qin were numbered.

Xiang Yu then led his large army to Xianyang and was infuriated to discover it had been occupied by Liu Bang, commander of another rebel army sent by the King of Chu to subjugate the imperial capital. Liu Bang, from the village of Pei in Chu, had started off by serving under Xiang Liang. A minor official; he had set free the labourers he was supposed to escort to work on the huge tomb of the First Emperor. Faced with punishment shld he return to his post, Liu Bang rebelled instead and joined up with Xiang Liang who assigned him a force of 5000 men to lead.

Liu Bang and Xiang Yu fought side-by-side. After the death of Xiang Liang, Xiang Yu agigated and demanded to be allowed to attack Xianyang immediately. The King of Chu, fearing his rashness and vengefulness, disallowed him. Then, came the Zhao situation, and Xiang Yu was sent to help the newly-raised and inexperienced Zhao forces. And the more benign Liu Bang instead, was sent with an army to capture the Qin capital.

In Nov 207, Liu Bang entered the captial, accepted the surrender of the Qin heir, the Second Emperor having been murdered by the eunuch Zhao Gao, held order over the Qin lands and sealed off the treasuries and palaces to prevent looting, to the general acclaim of the Qin people. This was after he had broken thru the last Qin forces guarding the passes into the Wei Valley, wherein laid the magnificent captial of Shi Huangdi.

Xiang Yu was furious that Liu Bang had entered the enemy's capital first. With 400000 troops at his command encamped at Hongmen, he prepared to attack Liu Bang and his much smaller army of maybe 100000 troops. Alerted by Xiang Bo, an uncle to Xiang Yu, (who owed a favour to Zhang Lian, Liu Bang's strategist and advisor), Liu Bang rushed to Xiang Yu's camp, attended by none except Zhang Lian and a guard, to apologise, explain and mollify the impetous Xiang Yu. Mollified, Xiang Yu entertained Liu Bang to a banquet, and allowed him to go free, despite advice fr his advisor, Fan Zeng, to kill him. Fan Zeng had seen Liu Bang as Xiang Yu's greatest opponent in the power struggle now commencing.

Xiang Yu marched into Xianyang in the spring of 206 BCE. He immediately executed the last heir of the Qin, looted the treasuries, and burned the palaces. It was said the palaces burned for three whole months. Then came the great conference of the anti-Qin forces. As leader of the rebellion, Xiang Yu divided China into 19 kingdoms and rewarded them to the generals of the rebel forces. He, of course, took the lion's share. Liu Bang was given Han Zhong, in mountainous and remote northern Sichuan, and ennobled as the King of Han. Xiang Yu set three defected Qin generals, incl Zhang Nan, as kings of adjacent territories to watch over him.

The conference ended, and Liu Bang and his army marched into Han Zhong. He burned the suspended roadway over the gorge separating the territory fr the rest of China - a grand signal to signify he didn't intend to return to contest with Xiang Yu. In practise, it was to prevent Xiang Yu fr chasing him with an army. In fact, Xiang Yu did change his mind and send off an army to pursue the Han army but by then it was too late.

Xiang Yu returned to his own fief, the kingdom of Chu. Bearing a grudge against the incumbent king, he had him murdered and took the throne of Chu for himself.
 
The stage was set for a showdown between Liu Bang of the Han, and Xiang Yu of the Chu. Xiang Yu was militarily stronger and had more troops but Liu Bang had the better geographical position and more talented men under his command. Like Xiao He, formerly secretary to the magistrate of Pei, Liu Bang's home county, and a talented administrator. And Zhang Lian, a great military strategist, an aristocrat from the former state of Han (different Chinese character fr Liu Bang's Han). His father had been the Prime Minister of Han, when it was overrun by the Qin armies. And also Chen Ping, a defecting general from Xiang Yu's forces. He had lost a stronghold to Liu Bang, and fearing reprisal from the mercurial Xiang Yu, Chen Ping had defected to Liu Bang's side and became an advisor.

Best of all, Liu Bang had Han Xin, a great general of the age. Han Xin had started off as a guard for Xiang Yu's forces. Having no luck at promotion, he had defected to Liu Bang's faction where he was made a commissary officer. Having access to Xiao He, Liu Bang's Prime Minister, Han Xin convinced the high official of his ability. But nothing happened, Han Xin, growing hopeless, left to look for an outlet with another general's army. Xiao He personally set off to chase after him and persuaded him to return. Finally convinced by Xiao He's action, Liu Bang made Han Xin his marshal.

The war resumed. Han Xin's first task was to defeat the three ex-Qin generals surrounding the Han territory. Under the guise of restoring the suspended roadway which had been burned earlier by Liu Bang while fleeing from Xiang Yu, Han Xin's forces utilized a forgotten mountain footpath, and achieved total surprise when attacking the forces of the three ex-Qin generals. By now, 3 of the 17 kings (apart fr Liu Bang and Xiang Yu) were defeated, 2 had surrendered to Liu Bang, and 5 were allied with him. The other kings had revolted against Xiang Yu, for he was vain when dividing the land of China at the earlier great conference, giving the best territories to his own people.

Xiang Yu was then in Qi (modern Shandong), putting down the revolt of a disaffected general. Seizing his chance, Liu Bang marched rapidly eastwards with a 560000 strong army and took Pengcheng (in modern Jiangsu), Xiang Yu's capital. Enraged, Xiang Yu turned back at once and leading a 30000-strong elite force, he drove Liu Bang's forces back. 100000 Han soldiers were killed; another 100000 were drowned while attempting to retreat across the river Sui (in modern Anhui) without boats. There were so many dead bodies that the river was dammed, and the water turned red for days.

Liu Bang fled to Xingyang (in modern Henan), where his remaining forces were located with Xiang Yu in hot pursuit. Despite his faults, Xiang Yu was really the great warrior leader of his age. The Chu forces surrounded Xingyang and beseiged it for a year. With food supplies beginning to run low, Liu Bang resorted to craftiness. Actually, it's more like his advisor, Chen Ping, resorted to craftiness. With 40000 gold, he sent agents into the enemy camp to spread rumors amongst Xiang Yu's generals and senior counselors - to spread dissent. Chen Ping had fought for Xiang Yu before, and knew him to be credulous and would fall easily for such tricks.

In particular, Chen Ping caused Xiang Yu to suspect the loyalty of his ablest, and longest-serving advisor, Fan Zeng. In disgust, the old man resigned and set off for home. By the time Xiang Yu realized his folly, it was too late, for the old man had died during the journey home. With Fan Zeng's removal, Chen Ping proceeded to the next stage of his plan of deception. While a decoy led 2000 women (Xiang Yu, like all the Chinese warlords, were fond of women) out of Xingyang to surrender to Xiang Yu, the real Liu Bang fled thru the back gate. He was beyond Xiang Yu's reach by the time the trick was discovered.

This temporary setback to Liu Bang caused some of his allies to defect to Xiang Yu's side. Liu Bang ordered Han Xin to deal with them. The marshal succeeded brilliantly and brought every one of them to heel. Then in an engagement with one of Xiang Yu's general, Han Xin tricked the enemy into crossing a river he had dammed. Pretending to flee, his forces fled back across to their side of the bank. The Chu general, who had never thought highly of Han Xin, led the Chu troops into a rush into the river to pursue the Han forces. Of course then, the Han soldiers destroyed the embankments and the waters flowed downriver swiftly to drown the Chu troops by the tens of thousands. Survivors who made it to shore were slaughtered by the awaiting Han army. Xiang Yu lost 200000 men that day. After this battle, Liu Bang and Xiang Yu were of similar military strength.

Xiang Yu's lines had been extended too far, and the guerilla tactics of a disaffected northern general were devastating them as well. Xiang Yu left to take care of them, giving standing instructions to his generals to hold steady regardless of enemy provocation. Of course, the Han soldiers then provoked the Chu generals into attacking. Without the great leadership of Xiang Yu, the Chu forces were decimated. The three generals in commanded committed suicide, rather than faced Xiang Yu.

By now, the Chu army was exhausted and running out of food. In contrast, the Han army was strong and well-supplied due to the Prime Minister Xiao He's excellent logistical support. Xiao He had at his disposal, the official records and maps made by the Qin bureaucracy, confiscated during their earlier occupation of Xianyang. Which enabled him to do wonders with supply lines to support the Han army in the field.

Liu Bang made peace with Xiang Yu, dividing all China between them, with the Hong canal, SE of Xingyang, as their mutual border. However, Zhang Lian and Chen Ping urged Liu Bang the break the peace treaty and to attack while the Chu was still weak. Two months later, the Han forces launched a full-scale attack. Xiang Yu was infuriated, and marched to battle. He scored some early victories, but the supply problems caught up with him again.

In the meantime, Han Xin had rejoined Liu Bang's main forces, now staged at Gaixia (in modern Anhui). Han Xin lured Xiang Yu into a ring of circlement made up of 300000 Han troops on all sides. Xiang Yu's army was decimated, and cut from 100000 men to only 20000. Devastated, Xiang Yu and the remnants of his army retreated to Gaixia. Then at night, the Han forces engaged in phsychological warfare. They began to sing. :eek: The Han soldiers sang the folk-songs of the Chu homeland. Overnight, the morale of the exhausted Chu army collapsed. When morning came, less than 1000 men were left for Xiang Yu to command.

Xiang Yu managed to break out, miraclously, but under hot pursuit by the Han forces. He was tricked again to enter a marsh and got bogged down. The Han army caught up with him. When he finally made it out, he had only 28 men left. In combat, Xiang Yu slained a Han commander and then fled again, under he reached the river Wu (in modern Anhui). There, the Han army caught up with him again. There would be no escape. Xiang Yu managed to kill several hundred of the Han soldiers. Finally, he recognized an old comrade among the enemy troops. Shouting for his friend to claim his head for reward, Xiang Yu cut his own throat.

Hence, Liu Bang became Emperor of the Han, and the Chinese today call themselves as the sons of Han, rather than of Chu. ;)
 
A picture of Liu Bang...

liu_bang.gif
 
Pls note that as the Han won, and not the Chu, and that victors wrote the history - Xiang Yu might have been given a blacker picture than necessitated. Nevertheless, he remained as one of the great military war heroes of China, and admired by many Chinese. ;)
 
Those numbers can't be right! :eek: Even in China, I can't see how battles could involve over 100,000 people. Also, why would Liu Bang break a peace treaty so quickly, in just 2 months? I thought the Chinese had "bushido" honor or some form of chivalry.

Also, is there any decent picture of Liu Bang? I mean, a serious portrait like they had in Europe at the time instead of a rough sketch of him.
 
During the Warring States age, the powerful states of Qin and Chu could field an army of one million men. Each. ;)

The Chinese had always been good at mass organization and signals operations. 'Sides, probably only smaller sub-forces that ran into each other and battled it out - those numbers probably incl support troops, technical and engineering troops etc.

As for chivalry, it had died towards the end of the Spring and Autumn Age, when war became a serious high-stakes affair and fought for keeps.
 
He's probably referring to that era in Chinese history depicted in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms classic, when supposedly military valour and chivalry were supposed to the norm... ;)
 
Great story indeed. It was a good text book case of what REAL leadership is:

Liu Bang lacked of any military or even administrative talents. The only things he know best was drinking and womanizing. So how did he managed to defeat the most feared and intelligent warlord of his time? His strong team, he managed to get himself some of the best generals and advisors to design and carry out his military plans. He allowed his generals to do what they had to do with complete freedoom and confidence.

Xiang Yu was known to be one of the most intelligent military leader of his time. Also THE BEST combat warrior in Chinese History (up to that point). However, there were two problems with Xiang Yu. First, he had no intention to unify China. Second, due to his superb talents, he did not have a lot of respect to those who worked for him. He forced his only good advisor into exile because of his suspicions and most of his generals were afraid of him.

In the end they both fulfilled their destinies. Liu Bang as one of the best Emperors and Xiang Yu as one of the best generals in Chinese history.

Maybe XIII can tell us about how Liu Bang's team ended up....
 
Han Xin later tried to stage a coup, influenced by someone, while the emperor (Liu Bang) was away to lead the army in a border skirmish. He was foiled first by Xiao He, he who had first chased him back. Liu Bang was disappointed more than anything and gave him an appropriate burial.
 
The Han census-taking later gave a figure of 50-60 million; in reality, probably more. Considering the agricultural tech and toal area were about the same, maybe about the same figure I guess. :hmm: Who knows...
 
Back
Top Bottom