Realistically, once cities get walls I never see garrisons take more than 5 damage per hit. Its almost clockwork.
Looking at this proposal in the info era, we are going from the garrison taking 5 damage per hit to 12 (for a typical 30 damage attack). That means that garrison once could take 20 attacks before dying (maybe a few more if it gets to heal a bit in between), to 9 attacks. that is NOT a small change.
I can respect wanting garrisons to take a little more damage....but that is waaaaaay too big a jump to me.
Looking at this proposal in the info era, we are going from the garrison taking 5 damage per hit to 12 (for a typical 30 damage attack). That means that garrison once could take 20 attacks before dying (maybe a few more if it gets to heal a bit in between), to 9 attacks. that is NOT a small change.
I can respect wanting garrisons to take a little more damage....but that is waaaaaay too big a jump to me.