20th c. Helmets Quiz!

Vrylakas

The Verbose Lord
Joined
Apr 12, 2001
Messages
1,940
Location
Bostonia
Greetings,

I have a strange hobby. Actually, I have many strange hobbies but we'll talk about one of my legal ones now. ;)

I collect helmets from the World Wars. I am fanatic about this; on the Saturday after the attack on the World Trade Center (Tuesday), I was on a flight from Poland to the U.S. that was complicated enough without the two Polish helmets I insisted on bringing back. (I got shook down by Polish, then later Danish soldiers because of this....) To celebrate my hobby, I put together a short quiz on the history of the helmet in modern warfare. Now don't worry; I'm not asking arcane details about models or chin strap designs. A general knowledge of modern military history will get you through this just fine. Give it a try!

1. Medieval combatants in Europe wore increasingly large amounts of body armor including helmets - with weights sometimes approaching 140 kg/300 lbs - but in the 16th and 17th centuries this trend suddenly reversed itself. Why?

2. At the same time as this trend reversal, European combatants began adopting extremely colorful uniforms. This 2nd trend persisted well into the 19th century, even through the standardization of military uniforms in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries, stopping abruptly in 1914. Why?

3. After 400 years with minimal or no headgear (aside from decorative shakos and kepis), what compelled Europeans to clamor for helmets in the first few months of World War I?

4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)

5. What country was the first to introduce a modern steel helmet into military service in the modern era, in October 1915?

6. This country (not the same as in question # 5) had actually entered World War I with its soldiers wearing a leather helmet with a famously-recognizable design, though this parade helmet proved inadequate for modern warfare. What country and helmet was this?

7. The British in World War I adopted a helmet based on a common design from the Hundred Years War some 500 years earlier. This 500 year old saucer-shaped design showed the British soldier of the Great War faced what similar threat as the English soldier of 1400?

8. Italy, Russia, Serbia, and 9 other countries in World War I adopted the helmet from what country?

9. In sheer terms of military value, what helmet design of World War I (or which country's) was the most successful?

10. How many countries used the American-made helmet design in World War I?

11. The Germans developed a strange and unique camouflage for their helmets in World War I that proved very successful, and was even adopted by the Allies for their helmets, tanks and even ships. What was this camouflage?

12. In the 1920s and 30s, helmets were seen as objects of national pride in nationalism-soaked Europe, so that nearly every country designed their own unique helmets for their armies, with dramatic flairs, feathers, colorful designs, etc. However, the reality of modern war had sunk in enough by 1942 in another World War that almost all combatants adopted one of 4 dominant helmet designs in Europe. Indeed, two of these basic helmet designs would dominate the world's armies well into the 1980s. What four countries produced these helmets?

13. Although the World War I model was still used by some branches of the U.S. military as late as 1942, the U.S. began the introduction in early World War II of a steel helmet with a unique design feature that allowed American soldiers to use their helmets in ways no other soldiers could. What was this feature? (P.S. Modern American helmets no longer have this feature.)

14. True or false: With a very different fighting terrain to contend with than the European theater in World War II, the Japanese Imperial forces never adopted a steel helmet in their uniform.

15. The French Adrian helmet had been a staple for French forces from World War I until the defeat of 1940, and yet in 1945 De Gaulle did not continue it. Why?

16. What country in World War II went through 3 helmet designs?

17. For whatever their regular army helmets looked like in World War II, every countries' paratrooper helmets all looked similar, like overturned bowls with no edges. Why?

18. By the end of World War II many countries began to use plastic webbing in their helmet liners instead of leather. Why?

19. In the early 1990s, the U.S. introduced a completely new helmet design to replace its 1942-1989 model. This new design incorporated two experimental features that were revolutionary, one in a technical sense and the other in a political sense. What were these features?

20. Care to guess what the most sought-after 20th century helmet is by avid collectors, sometimes (depending on condition) going for up to $6000 USD at an auction?

21. Multiple choice: There is an entire worldwide industry based on helmets collected from:

A. Grandpa's attic
B. Excavators who use metal-detectors on old battlefields
C. Counterfeiters who fabricate popular helmets
D. Paramilitary survivalist wacko freaks
E. All of the above

Good luck folks! It really isn't as hard as it seems at first sight!
 
Helmets...... OMG. :mischief:

I have a strange hobby. Actually, I have many strange hobbies but we'll talk about one of my legal ones now. ;)
And someday, we'll have to talk about one of your non-legal ones. :lol:

1. Medieval combatants in Europe wore increasingly large amounts of body armor including helmets - with weights sometimes approaching 140 kg/300 lbs - but in the 16th and 17th centuries this trend suddenly reversed itself. Why?
Armor can no longer provide protection against gunpowder weopans.

2. At the same time as this trend reversal, European combatants began adopting extremely colorful uniforms. This 2nd trend persisted well into the 19th century, even through the standardization of military uniforms in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries, stopping abruptly in 1914. Why?
Bright uniforms make you easier to see (and shoot at) on the battlefield.

3. After 400 years with minimal or no headgear (aside from decorative shakos and kepis), what compelled Europeans to clamor for helmets in the first few months of World War I?
Protection for the head. Probably due to artillery attks or maybe for trench warfare (so that can protect head while rearing it slightly above trench fortifications to look at the enemy). They used periscopes too for this purpose.

4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)
Rapid fire guns i.e. machine-guns? Or shrapnel fr artillery bombardment?

5. What country was the first to introduce a modern steel helmet into military service in the modern era, in October 1915?
Germany? If not, either France or Britain.

6. This country (not the same as in question # 5) had actually entered World War I with its soldiers wearing a leather helmet with a famously-recognizable design, though this parade helmet proved inadequate for modern warfare. What country and helmet was this?
Turkey with the fez?

8. Italy, Russia, Serbia, and 9 other countries in World War I adopted the helmet from what country?
Germany?

9. In sheer terms of military value, what helmet design of World War I (or which country's) was the most successful?
Germany?

11. The Germans developed a strange and unique camouflage for their helmets in World War I that proved very successful, and was even adopted by the Allies for their helmets, tanks and even ships. What was this camouflage?
Not sure what it's called but using contrasting colors and streaking patterns to color their equipment.

12. In the 1920s and 30s, helmets were seen as objects of national pride in nationalism-soaked Europe, so that nearly every country designed their own unique helmets for their armies, with dramatic flairs, feathers, colorful designs, etc. However, the reality of modern war had sunk in enough by 1942 in another World War that almost all combatants adopted one of 4 dominant helmet designs in Europe. Indeed, two of these basic helmet designs would dominate the world's armies well into the 1980s. What four countries produced these helmets?
Germany, Britain, France, Soviet Union?

13. Although the World War I model was still used by some branches of the U.S. military as late as 1942, the U.S. began the introduction in early World War II of a steel helmet with a unique design feature that allowed American soldiers to use their helmets in ways no other soldiers could. What was this feature? (P.S. Modern American helmets no longer have this feature.)
With straps on the outside to hold small items like notes, cigarrettes etc?

14. True or false: With a very different fighting terrain to contend with than the European theater in World War II, the Japanese Imperial forces never adopted a steel helmet in their uniform.
False. The Japanese don't wear helmets due to the kind of enemies they fought with (Chinese). Or maybe because not enough resources to supply every soldier with one.

15. The French Adrian helmet had been a staple for French forces from World War I until the defeat of 1940, and yet in 1945 De Gaulle did not continue it. Why?
Symbol of Vichy France?

17. For whatever their regular army helmets looked like in World War II, every countries' paratrooper helmets all looked similar, like overturned bowls with no edges. Why?
To reduce air-friction when paradropping obviously.

18. By the end of World War II many countries began to use plastic webbing in their helmet liners instead of leather. Why?
Plastic is cheaper/easier to produce?

19. In the early 1990s, the U.S. introduced a completely new helmet design to replace its 1942-1989 model. This new design incorporated two experimental features that were revolutionary, one in a technical sense and the other in a political sense. What were these features?
Externally it resemble those helmets used by the Wehrmacht during WW2. Not sure about the technical one, maybe the material used to produce it?

20. Care to guess what the most sought-after 20th century helmet is by avid collectors, sometimes (depending on condition) going for up to $6000 USD at an auction?
The German Wehrmacht helmet used during WW2?

21. Multiple choice: There is an entire worldwide industry based on helmets collected from:

A. Grandpa's attic
B. Excavators who use metal-detectors on old battlefields
C. Counterfeiters who fabricate popular helmets
D. Paramilitary survivalist wacko freaks
E. All of the above
E?

Obviously, many of the above are wild guesses... :lol:
 
Originally posted by Vrylakas
1. Medieval combatants in Europe wore increasingly large amounts of body armor including helmets - with weights sometimes approaching 140 kg/300 lbs - but in the 16th and 17th centuries this trend suddenly reversed itself. Why?

Rifles with good armor penetration started appearing. Fast movement became more important than body protection.

2. At the same time as this trend reversal, European combatants began adopting extremely colorful uniforms. This 2nd trend persisted well into the 19th century, even through the standardization of military uniforms in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries, stopping abruptly in 1914. Why?

The first guns created lots of white smoke, dramatically reducing sight on the battlefield. Thus it was vital for the soldiers to have distinct uniforms, so they could be properly identified. In 1914, black gunpowder had removed the smoke, and with long-range weapons as the machine gun, the uniform was made to conceal the bearer and act as a camouflage.

3. After 400 years with minimal or no headgear (aside from decorative shakos and kepis), what compelled Europeans to clamor for helmets in the first few months of World War I?

Shrapnel from artillery. Helmets don´t protect against bullets.

4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)

Indirect artillery.
 
"Now don't worry; I'm not asking arcane details about models or chin strap designs"

This is crying out for a lewd remark! ;)

Great quiz - when will you put up the answers? Is there a time limit or something? :goodjob:
 
Rodgers, it was obviously too much to expect you to have a bash at the questions...;)
 
Originally posted by Vrylakas
4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)

Others have touched on this, but I think what you are looking for is explosive shells

7. The British in World War I adopted a helmet based on a common design from the Hundred Years War some 500 years earlier. This 500 year old saucer-shaped design showed the British soldier of the Great War faced what similar threat as the English soldier of 1400?

I'm going to guess that is attack from above. in the 1400's it was archers, in WWI it was airburst artillery over the trenches. The Biritish helmet flared out a bit, which would off a bit more protection.

10. How many countries used the American-made helmet design in World War I?

Just the US. (Guess)

17. For whatever their regular army helmets looked like in World War II, every countries' paratrooper helmets all looked similar, like overturned bowls with no edges. Why?

Edges could get caught on the parachute strings. I would expect this could be rather uncofortable, taking the shock of opening on your head and neck as opposed to your torso. Also, theoretically, the helmet might cut the cords
 
1, Reduced armour for increased manoeuvrability. Gunpowder rendered heavy armour relatively useless.

2, Bright, colourful uniforms were a sign of prestige. Representing the country or state the army belonged to. Trench warfare changed the way battles were faught, as such the emphasis was on not attracting attention.

3, Shrapnel. Artillery blasts produced large amounts of shrapnel responisble for many deaths and injuries in the opening months of the Great War.

4, Artillery. Can't think of how to be more precise.

5, Britain

6, Germany/Prussia

7, Shrapnel? Sky-born grape shot!!

8, Britain

9, Germany

10, France? Im guessing really

11, Hmm, I don't know that there is any name for the design. I'll have to desribe it! Well it had brown, khaki and green patches seperated by thick black lines. It proved ideal for use in the country side as well as in the trenches.

12, Germany, America, Britain, Russia?

13, No idea!

14, I'll hazard an educated guess and say that it was true.

15, Pass, Im not up on my French WW history!

16, Pass

17, Er..Pass

18, Cheaper to produce?

19, Pass

20, WW1 Prussian leather helmet?

21, C

Well thats that. Will you be posting a list of answers up?
 
Wow - quick responses!

Here goes the first:

Archer-007 wrote:

1. quicker movement was needed

No - for centuries Europeans were quite willing to surrender mobility for armor protection. Something else changed....

2. colorful uniforms provide poor camo

No - why would you need camo? Soldiers in this period didn't want to hide, they wanted to be found - which is part of the answer.

5. England

No.

6. Germany

Yes - you got the country right. Now what was the helmet? (You can describe it if you don't know the name...)

7. France

? No. I think you misunderstood the question.

8. France

Yes! These countries all adopted the French Adrian design helmet (substituting their own national insignia on the front) in WW I, and in the years after the war even more would adopt it (Czechoslovakia, Poland, etc.).

14. False

Right. The Japanese developed a steel helmet vaguely similar to the British colonial "pith" helmets.

16. Germany

No.

21. B

B is also right...


Good run Archer!
 
Vrylakas

I've noticed that on the improved WW1 German Helmet there are two screws or stumps coming out the sides of the helmet. What were they used for? I also have found out that some German troops did use a sort of body armour, but what for? Surely it would of made the soldier too slow for a determined charge at the enemy trench and I doubt from the look of it it could stand up to concentrated fire.

It's in your hands, our helmet expert.

Regards b
 
K-D's back! How's the job hunt K-D?

Knight-Dragon wrote:

Helmets...... OMG.

The wife won't let me collect anything sharp and pointy...

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have a strange hobby. Actually, I have many strange hobbies but we'll talk about one of my legal ones now.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

And someday, we'll have to talk about one of your non-legal ones.

When we know the local police authorities aren't watching...

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Medieval combatants in Europe wore increasingly large amounts of body armor including helmets - with weights sometimes approaching 140 kg/300 lbs - but in the 16th and 17th centuries this trend suddenly reversed itself. Why?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Armor can no longer provide protection against gunpowder weopans.

Yes! Gunpowder made body armor (as Renaissance Europe knew it) obsolete.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. At the same time as this trend reversal, European combatants began adopting extremely colorful uniforms. This 2nd trend persisted well into the 19th century, even through the standardization of military uniforms in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries, stopping abruptly in 1914. Why?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bright uniforms make you easier to see (and shoot at) on the battlefield.

Yes! Connected to Question # 1, the blackpowder used at the time covered the battlefield so no one knew where anyone else was; colorful uniforms made it easier to tell friend from foe...

Smokeless powder invented in the late 19th century and advances in military technologies made bright colorful uniforms a deadly trait, as the French discovered in 1914.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. After 400 years with minimal or no headgear (aside from decorative shakos and kepis), what compelled Europeans to clamor for helmets in the first few months of World War I?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Protection for the head. Probably due to artillery attks or maybe for trench warfare (so that can protect head while rearing it slightly above trench fortifications to look at the enemy). They used periscopes too for this purpose.

Yes! In the first few months of the war, massive casualties mounted on all sides, a very large number of them being head wounds. The reason, in Question # 4...

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rapid fire guns i.e. machine-guns? Or shrapnel fr artillery bombardment?

The 2nd part of your answer is correct. No steel helmet ever had any chance of stopping a bullet, but it was designed to stop shrapnel. The 19th century had seen a revolution in artillery technology, including timed shrapnel shells that filled a battlefield with lots of lead flying in all directions creating an extreme peril for frontline troops. A man's head is his most exposed body area in this situation, even if he's in a trench... The introduction of steel helmets in 1915 and 1916 drastically cut down on head wound injuries.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5. What country was the first to introduce a modern steel helmet into military service in the modern era, in October 1915?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Germany? If not, either France or Britain.

You just about covered the gamut.... ;) It was France, which after suffering massive casualties was forced to completely overhaul its obsolete uniforms.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6. This country (not the same as in question # 5) had actually entered World War I with its soldiers wearing a leather helmet with a famously-recognizable design, though this parade helmet proved inadequate for modern warfare. What country and helmet was this?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Turkey with the fez?

No.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. Italy, Russia, Serbia, and 9 other countries in World War I adopted the helmet from what country?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Germany?

No.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9. In sheer terms of military value, what helmet design of World War I (or which country's) was the most successful?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Germany?

You like Germany, don't you K-D?

Yes - you're right on this one. Germany's round pot helmet, with a short visor in front protecting the eyes from dangers above and with a wrap-around neck-protecting feature has proven the best helmet design of the war in terms of protection. (That's a hint for another question.)

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11. The Germans developed a strange and unique camouflage for their helmets in World War I that proved very successful, and was even adopted by the Allies for their helmets, tanks and even ships. What was this camouflage?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Not sure what it's called but using contrasting colors and streaking patterns to color their equipment.

Yes! The Germans colored their helmets with starkly contrasted colors like yellow, red, orange, blue, etc. with thick black lines between the colors in irregular patterns - thereby breaking up the helmet's outline from a distance very effectively. When the allies first saw this pattern they were incredulous because one wouldn't imagine bright colors as a part of camouflage, but within months Allied soldiers were painting thewir own helmets with this pattern, and it spread even to the navies.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12. In the 1920s and 30s, helmets were seen as objects of national pride in nationalism-soaked Europe, so that nearly every country designed their own unique helmets for their armies, with dramatic flairs, feathers, colorful designs, etc. However, the reality of modern war had sunk in enough by 1942 in another World War that almost all combatants adopted one of 4 dominant helmet designs in Europe. Indeed, two of these basic helmet designs would dominate the world's armies well into the 1980s. What four countries produced these helmets?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Germany, Britain, France, Soviet Union?

3 out of 4! Germany, Britain and the Soviet Union all equipped many foreign allied armies with their own helmets - as did one other country in World War II.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
13. Although the World War I model was still used by some branches of the U.S. military as late as 1942, the U.S. began the introduction in early World War II of a steel helmet with a unique design feature that allowed American soldiers to use their helmets in ways no other soldiers could. What was this feature? (P.S. Modern American helmets no longer have this feature.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

With straps on the outside to hold small items like notes, cigarrettes etc?

No - the U.S. soldiers just used chin straps or camo bands for that, like the soldiers in any army does. You're close thougfh; it has something to do with the liner.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
14. True or false: With a very different fighting terrain to contend with than the European theater in World War II, the Japanese Imperial forces never adopted a steel helmet in their uniform.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

False. The Japanese don't wear helmets due to the kind of enemies they fought with (Chinese). Or maybe because not enough resources to supply every soldier with one.

Of all the questions I figured you'd get right.... Yup. You know it. I suspect jungle heat on the islands precluded all Japanese troops from using them.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
15. The French Adrian helmet had been a staple for French forces from World War I until the defeat of 1940, and yet in 1945 De Gaulle did not continue it. Why?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Symbol of Vichy France?

Yes - and even moreso, a symbol of the failures of the Third Republic.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
17. For whatever their regular army helmets looked like in World War II, every countries' paratrooper helmets all looked similar, like overturned bowls with no edges. Why?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

To reduce air-friction when paradropping obviously.

Verrrryyyyy close, ands perhaps that is even a factor, but there's another part of the paradropping experience that influenced this.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
18. By the end of World War II many countries began to use plastic webbing in their helmet liners instead of leather. Why?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Plastic is cheaper/easier to produce?

No - a more practical reason.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
19. In the early 1990s, the U.S. introduced a completely new helmet design to replace its 1942-1989 model. This new design incorporated two experimental features that were revolutionary, one in a technical sense and the other in a political sense. What were these features?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Externally it resemble those helmets used by the Wehrmacht during WW2. Not sure about the technical one, maybe the material used to produce it?

Yes - you've got the political issue correct! The U.S. in the 1990s finally adopted the very practical M1916 and M1935 German design for their helmets, a politically dangerous thing to do but the fact is no design beats it for protection.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
20. Care to guess what the most sought-after 20th century helmet is by avid collectors, sometimes (depending on condition) going for up to $6000 USD at an auction?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The German Wehrmacht helmet used during WW2?

Yes! Or close enough; for some reason the German SS helmets are the most prized ones, especially if the original decales are intact.

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
21. Multiple choice: There is an entire worldwide industry based on helmets collected from:

A. Grandpa's attic
B. Excavators who use metal-detectors on old battlefields
C. Counterfeiters who fabricate popular helmets
D. Paramilitary survivalist wacko freaks
E. All of the above
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

E?

Yes! Helmet collectors haunt estate sales looking for grandpa's old war helmet. Some collectors scan old battlefields for helmets that've been buried for 50 or even 80 years. (I have 3 in my collection that were found in this way.) There are indeed counterfeiters who spend lots of time trying to either falsify existing helmets or create brand new ones that look like the authentic ones, for thousands of USD profit. (German WW II helmets are the most counterfeited, naturally.) And yes, there are the survivalist freaks too...

Obviously, many of the above are wild guesses...

Obviously you're quite good at guessing! Great run, K-D!
 
My lunchtime is over folks so I'll catch the rest of these tonight from home. They all look like great answers though!
 
More answersw based upon the response to K-D. (No research involved, I promise.)

13. Just guessing, but they would hold water? That way US soldiers could use them for shaving, bathing, maybe even cooking...

18. Since they were used to put water in repeatedly, leather would wear out.

19. If you are looking for the material, it would be Kevlar, if I am not mistaken.

Good quiz!!!
 
Originally posted by Vrylakas
K-D's back! How's the job hunt K-D?
I'm always around, just not posting in the History section. ;) Just getting started on the job-hunting, after breaking for more than 2 months. :)

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9. In sheer terms of military value, what helmet design of World War I (or which country's) was the most successful?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Germany?

You like Germany, don't you K-D?

Yes - you're right on this one. Germany's round pot helmet, with a short visor in front protecting the eyes from dangers above and with a wrap-around neck-protecting feature has proven the best helmet design of the war in terms of protection. (That's a hint for another question.)
Yup, Germany and China are my favourite 'history-related' countries. :)

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12. In the 1920s and 30s, helmets were seen as objects of national pride in nationalism-soaked Europe, so that nearly every country designed their own unique helmets for their armies, with dramatic flairs, feathers, colorful designs, etc. However, the reality of modern war had sunk in enough by 1942 in another World War that almost all combatants adopted one of 4 dominant helmet designs in Europe. Indeed, two of these basic helmet designs would dominate the world's armies well into the 1980s. What four countries produced these helmets?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Germany, Britain, France, Soviet Union?

3 out of 4! Germany, Britain and the Soviet Union all equipped many foreign allied armies with their own helmets - as did one other country in World War II.
If not France, then the USA?

Or maybe Italy?

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
14. True or false: With a very different fighting terrain to contend with than the European theater in World War II, the Japanese Imperial forces never adopted a steel helmet in their uniform.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

False. The Japanese don't wear helmets due to the kind of enemies they fought with (Chinese). Or maybe because not enough resources to supply every soldier with one.

Of all the questions I figured you'd get right.... Yup. You know it. I suspect jungle heat on the islands precluded all Japanese troops from using them.
Not jungle heat. I was thinking more of the Japanese forces in China; some did wear helmets but most just made do with the typical Japanese military caps. I suspect it has something to do with resource restraints. At this period, I think Japan needed all the metal imports for her ships, aircraft etc.

If it's the climate, well, the modern day forces of Singapore, Malaysia etc do incorporate the helmet into their standard military gear. ;)

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
18. By the end of World War II many countries began to use plastic webbing in their helmet liners instead of leather. Why?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Plastic is cheaper/easier to produce?

No - a more practical reason.
Smell? Longer durability?
 
Originally posted by Vrylakas

1. Medieval combatants in Europe wore increasingly large amounts of body armor including helmets - with weights sometimes approaching 140 kg/300 lbs - but in the 16th and 17th centuries this trend suddenly reversed itself. Why?

Iron was stronger at heavier weights, blocking sword blows and arrows

2. At the same time as this trend reversal, European combatants began adopting extremely colorful uniforms. This 2nd trend persisted well into the 19th century, even through the standardization of military uniforms in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries, stopping abruptly in 1914. Why?

The colors could be told apart easily, and no amount of armour could protect a soldier from musket balls.

3. After 400 years with minimal or no headgear (aside from decorative shakos and kepis), what compelled Europeans to clamor for helmets in the first few months of World War I?

New technologies in weaponry, ex. high-powered rifles

4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)

Fragmenting explosives and machine guns

5. What country was the first to introduce a modern steel helmet into military service in the modern era, in October 1915?

Great Britain

6. This country (not the same as in question # 5) had actually entered World War I with its soldiers wearing a leather helmet with a famously-recognizable design, though this parade helmet proved inadequate for modern warfare. What country and helmet was this?

Germany, the foolish helmet with a brass(?) spike on top

7. The British in World War I adopted a helmet based on a common design from the Hundred Years War some 500 years earlier. This 500 year old saucer-shaped design showed the British soldier of the Great War faced what similar threat as the English soldier of 1400?

The Frenchies

8. Italy, Russia, Serbia, and 9 other countries in World War I adopted the helmet from what country?

GB

9. In sheer terms of military value, what helmet design of World War I (or which country's) was the most successful?

GB

10. How many countries used the American-made helmet design in World War I?

???

11. The Germans developed a strange and unique camouflage for their helmets in World War I that proved very successful, and was even adopted by the Allies for their helmets, tanks and even ships. What was this camouflage?

Branches and leaves???

12. In the 1920s and 30s, helmets were seen as objects of national pride in nationalism-soaked Europe, so that nearly every country designed their own unique helmets for their armies, with dramatic flairs, feathers, colorful designs, etc. However, the reality of modern war had sunk in enough by 1942 in another World War that almost all combatants adopted one of 4 dominant helmet designs in Europe. Indeed, two of these basic helmet designs would dominate the world's armies well into the 1980s. What four countries produced these helmets?

Britain, Germany, USA, Soviet Union

13. Although the World War I model was still used by some branches of the U.S. military as late as 1942, the U.S. began the introduction in early World War II of a steel helmet with a unique design feature that allowed American soldiers to use their helmets in ways no other soldiers could. What was this feature? (P.S. Modern American helmets no longer have this feature.)

An elastic band??

14. True or false: With a very different fighting terrain to contend with than the European theater in World War II, the Japanese Imperial forces never adopted a steel helmet in their uniform.

True

15. The French Adrian helmet had been a staple for French forces from World War I until the defeat of 1940, and yet in 1945 De Gaulle did not continue it. Why?

He didn't feel like it, i dunno

16. What country in World War II went through 3 helmet designs?

Italy

17. For whatever their regular army helmets looked like in World War II, every countries' paratrooper helmets all looked similar, like overturned bowls with no edges. Why?

they were less obtrusive, but i swear American paras and German FJs had normal helms

18. By the end of World War II many countries began to use plastic webbing in their helmet liners instead of leather. Why?

It gave more support and was more comfortable???

19. In the early 1990s, the U.S. introduced a completely new helmet design to replace its 1942-1989 model. This new design incorporated two experimental features that were revolutionary, one in a technical sense and the other in a political sense. What were these features?

Kevlar, i dunno the other

20. Care to guess what the most sought-after 20th century helmet is by avid collectors, sometimes (depending on condition) going for up to $6000 USD at an auction?

Nepalese paratrooper helmets, obviously

21. Multiple choice: There is an entire worldwide industry based on helmets collected from:

A. Grandpa's attic
B. Excavators who use metal-detectors on old battlefields
C. Counterfeiters who fabricate popular helmets
D. Paramilitary survivalist wacko freaks
E. All of the above

B

Good luck folks! It really isn't as hard as it seems at first sight!
 
Hurricane wrote:

Originally posted by Vrylakas

1. Medieval combatants in Europe wore increasingly large amounts of body armor including helmets - with weights sometimes approaching 140 kg/300 lbs - but in the 16th and 17th centuries this trend suddenly reversed itself. Why?

Rifles with good armor penetration started appearing. Fast movement became more important than body protection.

Yes! Exactly!

2. At the same time as this trend reversal, European combatants began adopting extremely colorful uniforms. This 2nd trend persisted well into the 19th century, even through the standardization of military uniforms in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries, stopping abruptly in 1914. Why?

The first guns created lots of white smoke, dramatically reducing sight on the battlefield. Thus it was vital for the soldiers to have distinct uniforms, so they could be properly identified. In 1914, black gunpowder had removed the smoke, and with long-range weapons as the machine gun, the uniform was made to conceal the bearer and act as a camouflage.

Exactly again!

3. After 400 years with minimal or no headgear (aside from decorative shakos and kepis), what compelled Europeans to clamor for helmets in the first few months of World War I?

Shrapnel from artillery. Helmets don´t protect against bullets.

Right on!

4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)

Indirect artillery.

Yes!

A short run, H., but an excellent one!
 
Rodgers wrote:

"Now don't worry; I'm not asking arcane details about models or chin strap designs"

This is crying out for a lewd remark!

Probably to be answered by a lewd gesture. ;)

Great quiz - when will you put up the answers? Is there a time limit or something?

It's an as-we-go-along thing. Some ignore the others' answers and try it all for themselves, others just try to answer the linger questions others can't get. take a swipe!
 
Originally posted by Vrylakas CivGeneral's Answers in Bold ;)
Greetings,

I have a strange hobby. Actually, I have many strange hobbies but we'll talk about one of my legal ones now. ;)

I collect helmets from the World Wars. I am fanatic about this; on the Saturday after the attack on the World Trade Center (Tuesday), I was on a flight from Poland to the U.S. that was complicated enough without the two Polish helmets I insisted on bringing back. (I got shook down by Polish, then later Danish soldiers because of this....) To celebrate my hobby, I put together a short quiz on the history of the helmet in modern warfare. Now don't worry; I'm not asking arcane details about models or chin strap designs. A general knowledge of modern military history will get you through this just fine. Give it a try!

1. Medieval combatants in Europe wore increasingly large amounts of body armor including helmets - with weights sometimes approaching 140 kg/300 lbs - but in the 16th and 17th centuries this trend suddenly reversed itself. Why?

Iron is stronger and heaver

2. At the same time as this trend reversal, European combatants began adopting extremely colorful uniforms. This 2nd trend persisted well into the 19th century, even through the standardization of military uniforms in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries, stopping abruptly in 1914. Why?

The bright colors on an infantrymen made him prone to any sniper attacks (The American Reviolutionary War is one example where minutemen in subdued clothing were hiding in the bushes and ambushing a formation of British solders

3. After 400 years with minimal or no headgear (aside from decorative shakos and kepis), what compelled Europeans to clamor for helmets in the first few months of World War I?

Machine guns, Faster bullets, etc

4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)

Machine guns and Grenades

5. What country was the first to introduce a modern steel helmet into military service in the modern era, in October 1915?

Great Britian

6. This country (not the same as in question # 5) had actually entered World War I with its soldiers wearing a leather helmet with a famously-recognizable design, though this parade helmet proved inadequate for modern warfare. What country and helmet was this?

The German's Pickelhaub helmit, The one with that spike :D

7. The British in World War I adopted a helmet based on a common design from the Hundred Years War some 500 years earlier. This 500 year old saucer-shaped design showed the British soldier of the Great War faced what similar threat as the English soldier of 1400?

The French

8. Italy, Russia, Serbia, and 9 other countries in World War I adopted the helmet from what country?

Great Britian

9. In sheer terms of military value, what helmet design of World War I (or which country's) was the most successful?

Great Britian

10. How many countries used the American-made helmet design in World War I?

About 6

11. The Germans developed a strange and unique camouflage for their helmets in World War I that proved very successful, and was even adopted by the Allies for their helmets, tanks and even ships. What was this camouflage?

Branches and twigs

12. In the 1920s and 30s, helmets were seen as objects of national pride in nationalism-soaked Europe, so that nearly every country designed their own unique helmets for their armies, with dramatic flairs, feathers, colorful designs, etc. However, the reality of modern war had sunk in enough by 1942 in another World War that almost all combatants adopted one of 4 dominant helmet designs in Europe. Indeed, two of these basic helmet designs would dominate the world's armies well into the 1980s. What four countries produced these helmets?

Germany, Russia, Great Britan, and the United States

13. Although the World War I model was still used by some branches of the U.S. military as late as 1942, the U.S. began the introduction in early World War II of a steel helmet with a unique design feature that allowed American soldiers to use their helmets in ways no other soldiers could. What was this feature? (P.S. Modern American helmets no longer have this feature.)

Chin Straps

14. True or false: With a very different fighting terrain to contend with than the European theater in World War II, the Japanese Imperial forces never adopted a steel helmet in their uniform.

T

15. The French Adrian helmet had been a staple for French forces from World War I until the defeat of 1940, and yet in 1945 De Gaulle did not continue it. Why?

They were not up to the standards

16. What country in World War II went through 3 helmet designs?

Italy

17. For whatever their regular army helmets looked like in World War II, every countries' paratrooper helmets all looked similar, like overturned bowls with no edges. Why?

To prevent metal cuts

18. By the end of World War II many countries began to use plastic webbing in their helmet liners instead of leather. Why?

For comfort and support

19. In the early 1990s, the U.S. introduced a completely new helmet design to replace its 1942-1989 model. This new design incorporated two experimental features that were revolutionary, one in a technical sense and the other in a political sense. What were these features?

Kevlar

20. Care to guess what the most sought-after 20th century helmet is by avid collectors, sometimes (depending on condition) going for up to $6000 USD at an auction?

The German Picklehaub helmit

21. Multiple choice: There is an entire worldwide industry based on helmets collected from:

A. Grandpa's attic
B. Excavators who use metal-detectors on old battlefields
C. Counterfeiters who fabricate popular helmets
D. Paramilitary survivalist wacko freaks
E. All of the above

E

Good luck folks! It really isn't as hard as it seems at first sight!
 
Knowltok [series 1,2,3] wrote:

Originally posted by Vrylakas

4. What technological revolution in the 19th century had suddenly made helmets a necessity? (Related obviously to # 3)

Others have touched on this, but I think what you are looking for is explosive shells

Yes! Advances in artillery technology filled the modern battlefield with deadly shrapnel.

7. The British in World War I adopted a helmet based on a common design from the Hundred Years War some 500 years earlier. This 500 year old saucer-shaped design showed the British soldier of the Great War faced what similar threat as the English soldier of 1400?

I'm going to guess that is attack from above. in the 1400's it was archers, in WWI it was airburst artillery over the trenches. The Biritish helmet flared out a bit, which would off a bit more protection.

Yes! You got it right on! The British helmet was designed to protect the wearer's neck and shoulders from shrapnel and debris falling from above. The problem with it was that once out of the trenches, it left the wearer's neck and shoulders unprotected from the sides.

10. How many countries used the American-made helmet design in World War I?

Just the US. (Guess)

Sorry, trick question. :D The U.S. in 1917 was completely unprepared for modern warfare (as the Great Powers were in 1914) and American soldiers showed up with campaign hats and nothing else. Like the Canadians, Australians, etc., the Americans simply donned British helmets.

17. For whatever their regular army helmets looked like in World War II, every countries' paratrooper helmets all looked similar, like overturned bowls with no edges. Why?

Edges could get caught on the parachute strings. I would expect this could be rather uncofortable, taking the shock of opening on your head and neck as opposed to your torso. Also, theoretically, the helmet might cut the cords.

This is not what I had in mind, but it sounds very plausible (as does K-D's theory) and it may have also impacted the ultimate decisions on design. However, there is yet another aspect that I know for sure influenced the final decisions. You're definitely on the right track though.

Great run Knowltok!
 
Back
Top Bottom