Hinin
Agnostophile
Current : There are three ideologies : "Freedom", "Order" and "Autocracy".
Hinin's proposal (6-55)
Proposal : Rename "Autocracy" into "Might".
Rationale : The two other ideologies are named after quite vague political notions, while "Autocracy" is much more focused, using a term more akin to "Democracy" or "Oligarchy" which creates a weird dissonance.
My first choice whould have been to replace "Autocracy" by "Authority", but it is already taken, so "Might" comes just next.
Recursive's proposal (6-55a)
You can read pre-poll discussion about this proposal here.
Combination proposal based on the feedback of several forumgoers.
Liberty: instead of 'Freedom' to represent political and economic liberalism. It is true that this is the vanilla name for Progress, but VP is such a different game from vanilla that it'll probably be fine.
Equity: instead of 'Order'. Unlike Equality, it has less overlap with the social equality espoused by political liberalism.
Authority: instead of 'Autocracy', as per the proposal.
Might: instead of 'Authority'. It's better representative of what Authority civs do, and is more akin to "Tradition" and "Progress" as an ancient society's overarching value than "Authority" is. It also doesn't require any change to the Honor policy.
Liberty (Progress policy): Reverted to its BNW name and Civilopedia entry, "Citizenship".
usadefcon1's proposal (6-55b)
You can read pre-poll discussion about this proposal here.
Proposal:
Rename Autocracy to Authority.
Rename Authority to Honor.
Replace Honor with Militia in the policy tree and provide an appropriate Civilopedia entry.
Hinin's proposal (6-55)
Proposal : Rename "Autocracy" into "Might".
Rationale : The two other ideologies are named after quite vague political notions, while "Autocracy" is much more focused, using a term more akin to "Democracy" or "Oligarchy" which creates a weird dissonance.
My first choice whould have been to replace "Autocracy" by "Authority", but it is already taken, so "Might" comes just next.
Recursive's proposal (6-55a)
You can read pre-poll discussion about this proposal here.
Combination proposal based on the feedback of several forumgoers.
Liberty: instead of 'Freedom' to represent political and economic liberalism. It is true that this is the vanilla name for Progress, but VP is such a different game from vanilla that it'll probably be fine.
Equity: instead of 'Order'. Unlike Equality, it has less overlap with the social equality espoused by political liberalism.
Authority: instead of 'Autocracy', as per the proposal.
Might: instead of 'Authority'. It's better representative of what Authority civs do, and is more akin to "Tradition" and "Progress" as an ancient society's overarching value than "Authority" is. It also doesn't require any change to the Honor policy.
Liberty (Progress policy): Reverted to its BNW name and Civilopedia entry, "Citizenship".
usadefcon1's proposal (6-55b)
You can read pre-poll discussion about this proposal here.
Proposal:
Rename Autocracy to Authority.
Rename Authority to Honor.
Replace Honor with Militia in the policy tree and provide an appropriate Civilopedia entry.
Last edited: