Border Re-drawing

[Shaitan]

Please also note that this is not Gem Mountain Province. It is the Province of Montis Abeo Gramen. A basic tenet of this requested change is that the mountains in question hold gems and the province was temporarily called "Gem Mountain". As that is no longer the case I ask for some justification why this change is still requested.

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Shaitan
Please also note that this is not Gem Mountain Province. It is the Province of Montis Abeo Gramen. A basic tenet of this requested change is that the mountains in question hold gems and the province was temporarily called "Gem Mountain". As that is no longer the case I ask for some justification why this change is still requested.

It did have the name.... It is still the province with large amounts of gem's and mountains. That has not changed even through the name has.

 

[Shaitan]

Originally posted by Strider
It's not crazy... It just shows that some people like the idea.

It shows that at least 7 people don't give enough of a flying rip to even care to see what the changes they are approving look like.

 

[Shaitan]

Originally posted by Strider


It did have the name.... It is still the province with large amounts of gem's and mountains. That has not changed even through the name has.

Southwest also has gems and mountains. By your logic we should expand Southwest to take the rest of the mountains with gems in them?

This proposal is BAD. It goes against our basic directive to make our provincial borders lie with natural terrain and I will challenge it as such. It would be easy for everybody else to see this if there was a graphic to show what the proposal looks like but I am apparently the only person who thinks that it is important to actually see the proposed new border before voting on it.

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Shaitan

It shows that at least 7 people don't give enough of a flying rip to even care to see what the changes they are approving look like.

People do have there own Civ3 games.... There is a map that Goonie posted in the Govonor thread. 5 minutes of searching could bring the information they want.

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Shaitan

Southwest also has gems and mountains. By your logic we should expand Southwest to take the rest of the mountains with gems in them?

This proposal is BAD. It goes against our basic directive to make our provincial borders lie with natural terrain and I will challenge it as such. It would be easy for everybody else to see this if there was a graphic to show what the proposal looks like but I am apparently the only person who thinks that it is important to actually see the proposed new border before voting on it.

You may think it is bad, but 7 people obviously does not think so.

Challange it all you want.... I will always be here to reply.

 

[Shaitan]

I almost had to moderate myself.

Moderator Action: Strider and Shaitan please refrain from commenting directly to each other and restrict your statements to the thread topic.
Please read the forum rules: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=422889

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Shaitan
I almost had to moderate myself.

Moderator Action: Strider and Shaitan please refrain from commenting directly to each other and restrict your statements to the thread topic.
Please read the forum rules: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=422889

Do you know how weird that looks? That's going into my sig!

 

[Shaitan]

I do think that this proposal is illegal as it specifically and intentionally avoids using the natural borders present in order to snake a city from a neighboring province.

I also think the poll is improper as it does not even have a graphic of the proposal. There is a map of the area in the Province thread (not the discussion thread) but there is no link to that graphic or the thread the graphic is in and even that graphic does not show this proposed border.

Furthermore the poll lacks the requirements of a posted end date.

 

[Strider]

The proposal to me is perfectly Legal.... This province is small.... Size 1 and 2 cities cover it. If we change the bordors than it will give less to do to one govonor giving him more time to work on othe cities. and more to do to another govonor who is perfectly able to handling anothr city. Like I've said a few times.... Screw the Consitution. If the citizens will it to be so. Than let it be.

 

[Octavian X]

I vote yes. Half of this province is mountains. If anything, the province should be significantly expanded.

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Octavian X
I vote yes. Half of this province is mountains. If anything, the province should be significantly expanded.

Thanks Oct!

8-8-1... It's the elections all over again!

 

[Goonie]

Shaitan you say that you voted no, because provincial borders must follow terrain. WELL THAT IS WHAT THIS PROPOSAL DOES!
Picture this. There is a block with a lind coming out of it. Why cut up that block? That is our current situation!

 

[Zarn]

I have to vote no on this. It doesn't seem to be a reasonable change.

 

[Shaitan]

Goonie, it does not follow the natural terrain. This proposal makes the province border the mountain ridge (which would be good) and then tacks on a hill tile, a grassland tile, a forest tile and one mountain tile from the next mountain chain.

 

[Goonie]

"I have to vote no on this. It doesn't seem to be a reasonable change." - Zarn.

Have you ever even seen what we are talking about? I doubt it....

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Goonie
"I have to vote no on this. It doesn't seem to be a reasonable change." - Zarn.

Have you ever even seen what we are talking about? I doubt it....

Goonie. You have no on to blame for that than yourself . Don't worry.... you can always re-poll it with a screenshot.

 

[Goonie]

I made a picture, but cant figure out how to post it

 

[Zarn]

Originally posted by Goonie
"I have to vote no on this. It doesn't seem to be a reasonable change." - Zarn.

Have you ever even seen what we are talking about? I doubt it....

You are talking to the former domestic advisor (and a jedi), my friend.

 

[Strider]

Originally posted by Goonie
I made a picture, but cant figure out how to post it

At th bottom of this page there is an upload button... Click that and upload your picture than link to it using the IMG button in the post reply.