Effects of Colonialism

asbestos

Prince
Joined
Jun 6, 2010
Messages
502
What are some good history books about the consequences of colonialism on the modern situation in the third world? Talking points on the subject differ widely from "it no longer has an effect, the problems of other nations / the third world are of their own making", to "the source of all third world conflicts and stagnation is colonialism". On either point, some people go so far as to add that a new wave of colonialism would be a good restorative force, and some add that colonialism never really went away but transformed into neocolonialism, hence the third world's endemic problems.

Most answers I've come across depend largely on a person's political or economic views. What I'd like is some exhaustive, unbiased sources that discuss the subject in factual detail (edit: or as much factual detail as possible). Thank you in advance.
 
What I'd like is some exhaustive, unbiased sources that discuss the subject in factual detail (edit: or as much factual detail as possible). Thank you in advance.

I don't think you'll find good books on the matter which are either exhaustive or unbiased. What you want is well reasoned arguments from a book with wide scope, but no "exhaustive" history book has ever been written.

Speaking of wide scope, maybe the board can give you better feedback if you could say some of the specific places within the Third World & particular issues that you're interested in within the range of things that are "problems and stagnation." Your OP does not describe a history topic; it describes a row of bookshelves in a large university library.
 
I don't think you'll find good books on the matter which are either exhaustive or unbiased. What you want is well reasoned arguments from a book with wide scope, but no "exhaustive" history book has ever been written.

Sure, I never said it had to be a single book. Even just pointing in the direction of one unbiased author who wrote case studies (detailed or partial) on the decolonization of country X would be fine.
 
'Unbiased'? Those exist?
 
That last . should have been a ? :p
 
Then can someone recommend some good scholarship (in their apparently biased opinion) on the subject of decolonization in the twentieth century?
 
Then can someone recommend some good scholarship (in their apparently biased opinion) on the subject of decolonization in the twentieth century?

I wasn't being facetious. If you want to know about a really broad topic, the best thing to do is go down to a university library and browse the shelves. There you can narrow it down by geography or economics or the opposition to colonization by the CIA or the back door recolonization run by the IMF or by methodologies of various liberation leaders. Right now your topic is too vague to get a good recommendation from a web discussion board. Plus, besides, this is the history board in CivFanatics. All these monkeys around here care about is Clausewitz, Rommel, and Caesar. But don't tell 'em I said that.
 
Try Westad, The Global Cold War for at least a bibliography
 
I wasn't being facetious. If you want to know about a really broad topic, the best thing to do is go down to a university library and browse the shelves. There you can narrow it down by geography or economics or the opposition to colonization by the CIA or the back door recolonization run by the IMF or by methodologies of various liberation leaders. Right now your topic is too vague to get a good recommendation from a web discussion board. Plus, besides, this is the history board in CivFanatics. All these monkeys around here care about is Clausewitz, Rommel, and Caesar. But don't tell 'em I said that.
Don't be offensive. We also care about Alexander.
 
I'm sure if you'd like us to cover more obscure topics Bucky, me and Dachs could cover decolonization in Europe very nicely, and Masada could do give some sources about a nation that went the decolonization. Which one, and in what region, I cannot possibly imagine. :mischief:
 
If you want to know about vile Europeans and their effect on the mighty Ottoman Empire and misguided Arabs I can tell you all about Perfidious Albion, the Russian barbarians and the French fools. Also poor Persia.
 
Back
Top Bottom