Fairness Pledge Amendment - Team Poll

[GenMarshall]

UN representatives: please post your team's vote in this thread after gathering their opinion. The admins will cast a tiebreaking vote if necessary.

Do you agree to the following amendments to the rules:

Current 4.3:

4.3 - Fairness Pledge

Every team must agree to the fairness pledge before the game starts:

“I pledge to compete fairly and within the rules of the game. I pledge to adhere not only to the written rules, but also to the unwritten, spirit of the rules. I understand that failure to live up to this pledge may result in penalties for me and my team.”

Proposed amendment (changes are in bold and italic):

“I pledge to compete fairly and within the rules of the game. I pledge to not tamper with the game itself, to not unfairly gain access to secret information from other teams, and to follow these rules to the best of my ability. I understand that failure to live up to this pledge may result in penalties for me and my team.”

Option 1 - Yes, my team supports this amendment.

Option 2 - No, my team does not support this amendment.

Option 3 - Abstain.

Original Thread

 

[ybbor]

I am undecided. can someone please tell me why they voted the way did on the poll?

 

[fe3333au]

Can people please vote ... there is a bit of a dealine on this !!!

@ybbor ... I voted yes as it is just an extension on the previous wording ... and added there due to a certain PWE requiring a legal definition for spirit of the game and fairplay ...

 

[peter grimes]

I voted abstain because I can't see what benefit or harm the wording change will effect.

 

[General_W]

dosn't seem like much of a difference - but the new way is a bit more clear.

With the agressive "player" on "the other team" - it seems best to have things as clear as possible.

I voted yes.