Didn't the Spartans tell their new warriors, when given their shields, to return victorious with it, or return dead on it? Lowest scoring dom win shield feels like dead on it.
civ_steve and I discussed this back in
http://forums.civfanatics.com/showpost.php?p=4684250&postcount=37 and I must say, that having gotten this one is quite the accident. I think that for the dom, the shield is no achievement.
For other victory types, the shield has a flavor like a one city challenge. But dom is by definition incompatible with a small empire. So I think one can't escape the conclusion that the dom shield is kind of the "lamest winning general" award.
That having been said, any publicity is good publicity, right?

And it sure beats 162 out of 177 in GOTM 10!

So I'll accept it gracefully.
That is unless EricRoush wants it. If he sees it as a coveted prize, then I suppose it really should be his, as my score before adventurer penalty was 12,536, compared to his contender 11,490. If he would rather not have it, I'm happy to keep it.
dV