If you were Aragorn, who'd it be?

[insurgent]

Arwen - just look at her! And she's an elf, and she's bright, and they're both in love with each other. (Movie considerations)

 

[jpowers]

Arwen is not as fiesty, is certainly more holier-than-thou, and brings Steven Tyler as a father-in-law. As a drinking buddy, OK, but as a father-in-law, no way. I vote Eowyn.

 

[Panda]

Arwen wins with both hands tied behind her back.

What's this Scottish widow thing, BTW? Her fate as explained by Elrond?

 

[HotDog Fish]

The answer is simple, I'd choose Gollum!

 

[Mikoyan]

Arg, Arwen of course!!
For me there would be no other option.

 

[Zcylen]

in the book:Arwen
in the movie:eowyn


and dont pushme man, the was a hard choice

 

[Richard III]

Originally posted by Zcylen
in the book:Arwen
in the movie:eowyn


and dont pushme man, the was a hard choice

Frickin' hilarious! Will you be ok?

Wasn't a tough choice for me; I always end up with the blondes, but deep down I'm a sucker for the dark-haired types. Arwen!!

 

[Knight-Dragon]

Arwen. Always prefer dark-haired girls. Not surprising - 99% of all the girls here are dark-haired (black actually).

 

[floppa21]

Long dark hair is good.

Eowyn's smile is good.

That close up of Arwen where her lips did that magic dance thing was VERY good.

My vote goes to the Elf Maiden though I did not vote. Liv Tyler is a goooood little elf.

 

[gr8ful wes]

The ageless mate sounds appealing, no doubt about it.
But there are also joys that accompany growing old together.
Personally, Eowyn is a hot woman who is strong, confident and rugged. More my cup o tea.

 

[Immortal]

Arwen for the same reason as Knight Dragon

 

[Zcylen]

Originally posted by Richard III




Frickin' hilarious! Will you be ok?

no, I wont. after knowing that guy faramir
I dont want to say why, because some people here dont know the rest of the story but...oh! what a waste...



but if you want I can tell you



edit: oops! I think I already did

 

[newfangle]

Oh my! Arwen of course! She weighs like 30 pounds. Nuff' said.

 

[TrailblazingScot]

The Scottish Widow reference...

In the FILM Elrond tells Arwen that to stay means that she will not age, not die and so still be around when the world of men falls and will be all alone. In the book, she becomes mortal, plain and simple.


"Scottish Widows" is a company that deals in life insurance and was setup after the Battle of Wellington to provide for widows of soldiers. NOW, in Britain their adverts have a lovely looking female (a tad like Arwen) going around in a large black clock around expensive and empty properties cos she is loaded cos the husband has snuffed it.

See the link!

 

[anarchywrksbest]

Arwen, for tis written

 

[cromagnon]

OK, I just watched it the movie for the second time, and hands down, it's Arwen.

Eowyn is too... homely. Yes, I know she's supposed to be nobility, but Arwen is divine (in many ways).

BTW, glad to see she's winning in the poll now. I got worried back there.

 

[Simon Darkshade]

The Very Secret Diary of Aragorn, Son of Arathorn
Day 28:


Beginning to find Frodo disturbingly attractive. Have a feeling if I make a move, Sam would kill me. Also, hairy feet kind of a turn-off.
Still not King.

 

[Trabpukcip]

Luthien Thinuviel (not sure of the spelling...). Only problem is that she's dead at the time... but still...

 

[Crimson Sunrise]

Eowyn, because I like mortal women with brains and not the Valar's puppets.

 

[Plexus]

Arwen. I have liked her since Armaged... err... The Fellowship of the Ring.