None Shall Pass 2 [Game Thread - Concluded]

Kennigit said:
Im currently loving my serial killer proposal

Thoughts?
Click to expand...

We have nights with Berserker and warriors kills, I mean both in the same night... haven't we? So how works that with your theory?

I've like 315 different theories and none of them helps any... :(

----------------------------------

Returning to Verarde, we got previous results from him, Legato scan by example... why now we are getting no results, it wasn't part of his ability from the start, what changed?

There is only one explanation, he got the ring..

Tanar Aerdoth said:
The same thing happened to me when I scried him. It must be something about him.
Click to expand...

When was that?
 
Riedquat said:
That is his PG?

Who do you scanned last night?
Click to expand...

Night Scans:

Sprig, Bsmith, Kennigit, TFT, Verarde, Tanar (blocked), Internet Flea

And what is this way you mention to clarify Verarde of our current killers?
Click to expand...

Have him kill me tonight. Flea is lying for the whatever time, and I think his lynch would be illuminating and make me look a lot better. I'd prefer to stay alive if Flea were lynched and flips scum, but if you're still unsure...

Well, then this would clarify Verarde. Either we'll see that he isn't one of the killers moving about, or they'll lay low. One gets him innocent, (though I'm still pretty sure he's corrupted, just not sure what that means) or town doesn't lose more members and gains a bit of time to figure things out.

Or you can lynch me today, but that won't stop the night kills.
 
And before Verarde objects, he's got more than enough insurance at this point to follow through on this at least once.

His pg is to kill evil, but he succeeds as long as he's killed twice as much evil as good. Killing one non evil town won't ruin that.
 
It's not that I would object to that, Legato, but that makes me a little bit more inclined to lynch you right now. Here's what you sound like:

"Don't kill me during the day, kill this guy instead. Then kill me at night."

Which makes me wonder if there's something you're holding back that will keep you from being killed tonight. We could very easily lynch you, and then kill Internet Flea tonight. Your eagerness to "sacrifice" yourself worries me.
 
You know, actually, Legato. This would clarify so much, and i think we are going to have to get rid of Jedi Order eventually anyway. The fact that Eowyn was the one killed doesn't actually mean that much since there aren't very much LotR left.
 
Verarde said:
It's not that I would object to that, Legato, but that makes me a little bit more inclined to lynch you right now. Here's what you sound like:

"Don't kill me during the day, kill this guy instead. Then kill me at night."

Which makes me wonder if there's something you're holding back that will keep you from being killed tonight. We could very easily lynch you, and then kill Internet Flea tonight. Your eagerness to "sacrifice" yourself worries me.
Click to expand...

Not eager. More resigned. Also, a few things. First, only two people have tanked kills. I don't really fit the profile of either of them. An scanner with an extra life seems quite improbable. Morgoth and a person with a kill power and me? No. It's also clearly not a faction power, given Sprig's demise. Also that would be highly overpowered.

Two, what on earth would surviving the night give me if I'm scum? I'd be still get lynched tomorrow.

Three, if you leave Flea alive, Flea gets a kill even if you night killed him. This at least prevents that.
 
Riedquat said:
We have nights with Berserker and warriors kills, I mean both in the same night... haven't we? So how works that with your theory?

I've like 315 different theories and none of them helps any... :(

----------------------------------

Returning to Verarde, we got previous results from him, Legato scan by example... why now we are getting no results, it wasn't part of his ability from the start, what changed?

There is only one explanation, he got the ring..



When was that?
Click to expand...

Last night. Same as the others.

I'm ok with this plan. Internet Flea.
 
The thing that's bothering me is why would competing killers leave Verarde alive? Where I a SK I would definitely kill him. And perhaps also gain the ring of power if that is in the hands of Verarde. I'm sure there is some kind of twist here we don't know about.

I am however on-board with lynching Internet Flea. If Legato's scan is correct then he's scum. If he flips town, Verarde will kill Legato tonight. Should he fail to do that, we lynch Legato tomorrow.
 
I also can't figure out why JohannaK was targeted. It doesn't make sense from an ordinary scum point of view.
 
Legato Endless said:
Not eager. More resigned. Also, a few things. First, only two people have tanked kills. I don't really fit the profile of either of them. An scanner with an extra life seems quite improbable. Morgoth and a person with a kill power and me? No. It's also clearly not a faction power, given Sprig's demise. Also that would be highly overpowered.

Two, what on earth would surviving the night give me if I'm scum? I'd be still get lynched tomorrow.

Three, if you leave Flea alive, Flea gets a kill even if you night killed him. This at least prevents that.
Click to expand...

It could be applied against you as well, if you are the lightsaber dude... one thing favoring IF is his result on Verarde, how could he know that? He got the same result than me and Tanar and he claimed first.

To me is clear we have to deal with Verarde because he lying, now if he is the assassin is another matter.
 
Snerk said:
I also can't figure out why JohannaK was targeted. It doesn't make sense from an ordinary scum point of view.
Click to expand...

Crossposted, so please read my previous post! the only way for him to know about the inconclusive result of any carried action on him is, or he is my partner or Tanar's partner or Verarde's partner or as he stated, he tried to track him, there is no other explanation!

And why killing johannak? Because it was him, me or Tanar... and lets admit it, we are easier to get lynched...
 
Riedquat said:
It could be applied against you as well, if you are the lightsaber dude... one thing favoring IF is his result on Verarde, how could he know that? He got the same result than me and Tanar and he claimed first.
Click to expand...

He got what? The claimed result of the target everyone in the game knows or believes is lying? Furthermore, if he shares Choxorn's faction, he'd know exactly where the ring went. That's not proof of anything. It isn't a gamble when the outcome is known.
 
Alright. Let's lynch vote: Internet Flea and I'll kill Legato tonight. Then we can see where we stand after that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

RRRaskolnikov
Invitation to the MU mafia championship (s10)
Replies
13
Views
3K
Master Radishes
Master Radishes
civfanatic4sure
(AMA) First Playthrough - Deity Win w/ Game Feedback
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
V. Soma
V
Xefjord
Civ 7 and Ara: A Cross Comparison 100 hours in.
3 4 5
Replies
82
Views
6K
KayAU
KayAU
Gori the Grey
World-spirit or ruler? (split out from guessing thread)
2 3
Replies
48
Views
3K
Zaarin
Zaarin
Birdjaguar
  • Locked
[RD] Russia Invades Ukraine: The 7th Thread Itch; scratch it here!
306 307 308
Replies
6K
Views
317K
Birdjaguar
Birdjaguar
Back
Top Bottom