Hard to say. So much depends on the conditions of each game - other civs, proximity, resources, etc. - that all are capable of doing very well or very poorly. I will say that Montezuma does not seem to be, let's say, built to last. By the renaissance he's almost always gotten on everyone's nerves to the point that I've had 5-6 civs in a row troop into my presidential palace to ask me to join in a war against him.
I guess that's stupid from a standpoint of it would be smarter not to antagonize everyone to the point you get conquered just because they are tired of you, but if he played any differently, he wouldn't be Montezuma. (He's actually one of my favorite AIs, even though I know we'll be at war at some point if he's anywhere near me).