Ruleset Addition Poll

[Theoden]

We have to decide whether we agree with the addition to the ruleset as proposed here.

 

[dutchfire]

No, the ability to give transports loaded full with marines is too nice to give away.

It should be allowed to trade vessel + cargo.

 

[Swissempire]

I only voted no because it should be a private poll

Edit: NVM, minor dyslexia kicked in and I thought it said post this private poll in your forums

 

[Theoden]

I only voted no because it should be a private poll

Why? All our other polls, except the ones concerning specific team members, have been public.

 

[DaveShack]

It's OK to gift both the vessel and contents. What would be prohibited is having a different civ's units inside any kind of boat.

Marines in a boat from the same civ as the boat have to go through combat. The exploit is that you capture the city with no combat involved at all. It's a bug in the game where an enemy unit entering a city is the trigger for ownership change. The programmers assumed that in order to enter the city it would have had to win the battle against any defenders.

If we have any important coastal cities, we want this rule to be in effect. The danger to ourselves if someone else uses it is far greater than the danger we pose to others by possibly using it.