Yeah I would agree with your assessment of the films; neither was much good. What's with having a mardy teenager as a crap Darth Vadar stand-in, and who the hell is snook or snark or whatever his name is? The only one I would watch again was the side-story film Rogue One. Having said that, I wonder how much we love the original trilogy cos we were kids when we first saw them? I re-watched the prequel trilogy again recently and the are effing awful in terms of their dialogue and acting, but I'd maintain the over-arching plot between these 3 and the original 3 is decent, with the whole anakin /Vader fall and redemption story and the rise and defeat of the empire. If only old George had had the talent to pull it off with good dialogue and coherent storytelling.